Vanguard funds: life strategy funds vs target retirement funds
Vanguard has an article about comparing Vanguard LifeStrategy Funds and Vanguard Target Retirement Funds. In addition to what Vanguard already mentioned, you may consider the following.
The target retirement funds have a minimum investment of $1,000 for opening an account; this makes it easier for small investors, just beginning their investment careers, to begin an investment program. The LifeStrategy funds have a higher $3,000 minimum investment requirement.
Control over asset allocation
If you selected a target retirement fund based on its current asset allocation, not the target year, you may find that the fund shifts its asset allocation either too soon or too late. For example, suppose you plan to retire in 2030, but you think the 85% stocks 15% allocation in Vanguard Target Retirement 2030 Fund is too aggressive for your need, ability and willingness to take risk. Instead, you like the allocation in Vanguard Target Retirement 2015 Fund, which currently invests approximately 65% in stocks and 35% in bonds. If you invest in Target Retirement 2015, however, at some time close to 2015, the fund will shift its allocation more conservatively, while you are still at least 15 years away from your planned retirement. Or if you'd like to be more aggressive and invest in Target Retirement 2035 while you plan to retire in 2015, you may find the allocation in Target Retirement 2035 not shifting when you need a less aggressive allocation.
If you invest in a LifeStrategy fund, this problem can be mitigated. You pick an allocation and change your allocation only when you want to. Alternatively, you can still invest in a Target Retirement fund but you have to watch for the allocation changes every year or every few years. If the allocation no longer suits you, switch to a different Target Retirement fund. This is best implemented in a tax deferred or tax free (Roth) account because there are no tax implications for switching. It somewhat defeats the "set it and forget it" appeal of a Target Retirement fund, but it's a good compromise between simplicity and maintaining your desired asset allocation.
Short-term asset allocation swings
From inception in 1994 through the fourth quarter of 2011, all LifeStrategy funds had an allocation to Vanguard Asset Allocation Fund. The underlying asset allocation in Vanguard Asset Allocation Fund changed frequently in the short-term. This caused swings to the asset allocation of LifeStrategy funds. For example, when Vanguard Asset Allocation Fund changed from 60% in stocks to 100% in stocks, LifeStrategy Moderate Growth Fund's allocation also changed from 60% in stocks to 70% in stock.
Vanguard announced a revision in the LifeStragegy funds allocations in a September 30, 2011 web posting and instituted an additional change in 2013, adding international bonds to the portfolios.The new allocations consist of four broad-based index funds:
- Vanguard Total Market Index Fund
- Vanguard Total International Index Fund
- Vanguard Total Bond Market II Index Fund
- Vanguard Total International Bond Index Fund
Historical data indicate that if you held the funds in a taxable account (not normally recommended for either one, but the simplicity may be worth the tax costs), the target retirement funds were slightly better options. The LifeStrategy funds held the Vanguard Asset Allocation Fund, which can realize capital gains as it changes its allocation. The revised post 2011 fund choices for the LifeStrategy funds will mean that the LifeStrategy funds can be expected to realize fewer short term and long term gains going forward.
All target retirement funds and LifeStrategy funds have 40% of the fund's equity allocation in international stocks. The actual portfolio weighting of international stocks will depend on the overall strategic equity allocation of the fund (the range will fall between ~12% and ~36% international stock for target retirement funds; and fall between 8% and 32% for the LifeStrategy funds.
The international bond fund represents 30% of the fixed income allocation of LifeStrategy and most target retirement funds. The Income and near-term Target Retirement funds (in the next 10 years) have slightly less international bond allocation due to an increasing allocation to short-term TIPS along the glide path.
The target retirement funds and LifeStrategy funds have similar expense ratios.
LifeStrategy funds have longer history. They were launched on 30 Sep 1994. Target retirement funds were launched on 27 Oct 2003 or later.
- LifeStrategy Funds to adopt all-index approach
- See Vanguard Target Retirement Funds (2005-2025) tax distributions and Vanguard Target Retirement Funds (2030-2050) tax distributions
- See Vanguard LifeStrategy Fund tax distributions
- See Vanguard Asset Allocation Fund tax distributions
- See Vanguard target retirement funds#Detailed fund allocations
- See Vanguard LifeStrategy Funds#Fund allocations
- See Glide paths#Target retirement funds glide paths