Government agency bonds

From Bogleheads
Jump to: navigation, search

Government agency bonds are debentures issued by a Federal Agency or a government-sponsored enterprise (GSE).[1]. Bonds issued by a Federal Agency are usually backed by the full faith and credit of the Untied States government. Agency debentures issued by a GSE are backed only by that GSE's ability to pay. [2] Government agency bonds (mortgage backed securities excluded) are tracked by the Barclays Capital US Agency Index. US government mortgage backed securities are tracked by the Barclays Capital MBS Index.

Agency bonds issued by federal government agencies

Federal agencies issuing bonds include:

  • Federal Housing Administration
  • GNMA (Ginnie Mae)
  • Small Business Administration

These bonds are backed by the full faith and credit of the U.S. government to pay interest and pay back principal at maturity. Some agency issues may be callable and subject to call risk. Agency issues are less liquid than treasury bonds and usually pay a slightly higher interest rate as compensation. Tennessee Valley Authority (TVA) bonds are not backed by a government full faith and credit guarantee but rather by the power revenue generated by the Authority. [3]

Other agencies of the Federal Government issue bonds through the Federal Financing Bank (created in 1973 to lower borrowing costs for smaller governmental agencies).

Bonds issued by Government Sponsored Enterprise (GSEs)

GSEs issuing bonds include:

GSEs are not backed by the full faith and credit of the U.S. government. These bonds are subject to both credit risk and default risk and the yield on these bonds is typically slightly higher than on U.S. Treasury bonds. [4]

On September 6, 2008, both Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae were placed into conservatorship by the Federal Housing Finance Agency (FHFA), essentially confirming the market's longstanding assumption that the GSEs' debt securities would be backed by the U.S. Government in case of crisis.

Bond structures

Agency Bonds Snapshot
  • Issuer: Government-sponsored enterprises (GSEs)
  • Minimum Investment: Varies—generally $10,000
  • Interest Payment: Fixed coupon or floating/variable coupon rates. Interest is paid semiannually for fixed-coupon security.
  • How to Buy/Sell: Through a broker
  • Bond Interest Rate: Determined at origination and varies by bond
  • Price Information: Issue price and secondary trade data available through a broker and data vendors

Agency Risk Report Card

  • Credit and default risk are real for GSE-issued agencies: The federal government is under no legal obligation to save a GSE from default.
  • Call risk: Many agency securities—step-ups in particular—carry call provisions that allow the issuer to pay you prior to the bond's maturity date, typically when interest rates drop, leaving you to reinvest at lower prevailing rates.
  • Interest rate risk: If interest rates rise, the value of an agency bond on the secondary market will likely fall.

Mortgage backed securities Risk Report Card

  • Credit and default risk are real for MBSs issued by GSEs: The federal government is under no legal obligation to save a GSE from default.
  • Prepayment risk that acts much like call risk: You get your principal back sooner than the stated maturity, but the reinvestment opportunities are limited due to the inconsistent prepayment rates, which are driven by real estate mortgage interest rates and refinancing trends; population, geographic mobility and employment opportunities; and social and economic factors that are difficult to model.
  • Extension risk: The opposite of prepayment risk—the risk that interest rates will go up, lengthening the estimated maturity (but not the stated maturity) of your MBS and creating more holding-period risk.
  • Interest rate risk: If interest rates rise, the value of a mortgage-backed security on the secondary market will likely fall.
-- FINRA


Agency and GSEs issue debt securities with different structures. These structures include:

  • Fixed coupon: Most agency debt issues are fixed rate, non-callable bonds. Note that GNMA securities are (full faith and credit) mortgage pass-through securities. Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac also issue mortgage pass through securities (not full faith and credit) in addition to bond issues. [5] [6]
  • Variable or floating coupon rate: These bonds have floating rates that change periodically. The interest rate is linked by formula to a treasury bond or LIBOR [7] index.
  • No coupon: Very short term agency debt is issued at a discount and matures at par value. These securities are similar in structure to Treasury bills.
  • Callable: Agencies issue callable bonds with what is known as "step up" coupon rates. Callable agency bonds have a preset coupon rate "step up" option that provides for increases in interest rates or the coupon rate as the bonds approach maturity. This feature is designed to minimize the interest rate risk for investors over time. However, step up bonds are often called by issuers during periods of declining interest rates. A called bond returns an investor's principal sooner than expected and usually forces the investor to reinvest principal at a lower rate of interest. [8]
  • Mortgage backed securities: Mortgage-backed securities (MBS) are pools of first mortgages on residential properties. As the underlying loans are paid off by homeowners, the investors in MBS receive payments of interest and principal over time.

Taxation

GNMA bonds, and all bonds from GSEs are subject to federal tax, and to state and local income tax in most states. Most other agency bonds are subject to federal income taxation but are exempt from state and local income tax.

Role in a portfolio

These bonds are as safe (when backed by the full faith and credit of the Government) or almost as safe (GSEs) as Treasury bonds, in terms of risk of default. However, they often have additional options embedded within them, which add risk to the purchaser.

In particular, the oft-included GNMAs have significant negative convexity resulting from the underlying mortgage holder's ability to reduce repayments when rates rise or refinance when rates fall. Since these markets are reasonably efficient, bondholders are compensated by some amount for bearing these risks. However, since risks may come into play at precisely the wrong time, some portfolio theorists advise that caution to be exercised in designing a portfolio using mortgage backed securities. This is a controversial topic among many Bogleheads. However, most agree that choosing to include bonds with significant optionality in your portfolio is of secondary importance to choosing your overall stock/bond split in a way that reduces risk to a comfortable level.

A reasonable summary of the controversy might be the following conclusion: Inclusion of such bonds by purchasing Total Bond Market or a similar fund is unlikely to hugely affect portfolio performance (see the arguments of Taylor Larimore on the forum), [9] whereas allowing bonds with significant optionality to comprise a much larger portion of the bond component of your portfolio would likely be unwise. Deciding to not include any such bonds in your portfolio can also be a wise choice (see the arguments of Larry Swedroe). [10] [11]

Index returns

Table 1. includes Barclays Capital index return data for agency bonds and US government mortgage backed securities.

Low cost investment options

The following list provides low cost ETFs and mutual funds investing in government agency debt.

See also

References

  1. Government-Sponsored Enterprise (GSE): Enterprises that are chartered by Congress to fulfill a public purpose, but are privately owned and operated, such as the Federal National Mortgage Association (Fannie Mae) and the Federal Home Loan Mortgage Corporation (Freddie Mac), from the FINRA
  2. Agency Debentures Definition, investopedia
  3. About Government/Agency Bonds
  4. About Government/Agency Bonds
  5. Fannie Mae debt securities.
  6. Freddie Mac debt securities.
  7. The London Interbank Offered Rate (LIBOR), which is the short-term floating rate at which large banks with high credit ratings lend to each other. LIBOR definition, investopedia
  8. About Government/Agency Bonds
  9. Have GNMAs hurt or helped Total Bond Market ?, forum discussion
  10. Why GNMAs Shouldn’t Be Your Bond Choice
  11. Is Vanguard’s Total Bond Fund Right for Your Portfolio?
  12. Barclays Capital Index Products pdf files and ishares ETF returns

External links