Marginal tax rate

A marginal tax rate is the tax rate that applies to the last dollar of the tax base (taxable income or spending), and often applied to the change in one's tax obligation as income rises. An individual's tax bracket is the range of income for which a given marginal tax rate applies.

(In investing, the word margin is the same as additional. To say it another way, this is the tax rate you would pay for each additional dollar earned. )

The rate also indicates how much tax you would save on each dollar of income that does not need to be reported on your tax return.

Marginal tax rates do not fully describe the impact of taxation. A tax is progressive if marginal rates increase with the tax base, and regressive if marginal rates decrease. In the US, income taxes are progressive, and thus the fraction of your income that you pay in taxes is less than your marginal tax rate.

Calculation
To calculate a marginal income tax rate, consider how much additional tax you would owe if you added $1 to your income. For example, if your federal tax bracket is 25%, your state tax bracket is 8%, and you do not itemize deductions, an extra $1 of income would cause you to pay 8 cents in state tax and 25 cents in federal tax, so your marginal rate is 33%. If you do itemize, the 8 cents in state taxes mean that you pay federal tax on only 92 cents, which is 23 cents of federal tax (23% = 92 cents * 25%) and a marginal rate of 31% = (23% + 8%).

Note that you may have a different marginal tax rate on different types of income. In the example above, your marginal tax rate on Treasury bonds (which are fully taxed by federal, not taxed by the state) is 25%. Your marginal tax rate on capital gains (which are taxed by the federal government at 15% but are probably still taxed at the full state rate) is 21% = (15% + 8%, minus the 2% = (8% * 25%) for the federal deduction of the state taxes).

The actual marginal rate can be complicated if your taxes include credits, deductions, and exemptions which are phased out with income; if you are nominally in the 25% bracket but you lose $5 in tax credits for every additional $100 you earn, your marginal rate is actually 30%.

In particular, taxation of Social Security benefits causes many moderate-income retirees to be subject to a much higher marginal tax rate than their tax bracket. If you are in the range in which Social Security becomes taxable, each additional $1 of income causes an extra 50 or 85 cents of Social Security to be taxable at the same tax rate, until 85% of the whole benefit is taxable. If you are in the 15% bracket and each $1 causes an extra 85 cents to be taxable, that extra $1 of income increases your taxable income by $1.85, with 27.75 cents due in tax giving you a marginal tax rate of 27.75%. If you are in the 25% bracket and each $1 causes 85 cents to be taxable, your marginal tax rate is 46.25%.

Another unusually high marginal rate is the result of the 0% tax rate on qualified dividends and capital gains in the 15% bracket. If your ordinary-taxable income is in the 15% tax bracket but your total income is in the 25% tax bracket, your marginal tax rate is 30%. Every additional $1 of ordinary income is taxed at 15%, but it also moves $1 of qualified dividends and capital gains from the 15% bracket (where it is taxed at 0%) to the 25% bracket (where it is taxed at 15%), so you pay 30 cents in additional tax.

If you use tax software, you can compute your actual marginal rate by adding $1000 to some category of your income and looking at the change in your tax bill; you may need to make a small adjustment for the deductibility of state taxes, as a higher state tax this year will give you a federal tax deduction next year.

Using the marginal rate for investment decisions
The marginal tax rate determines the relative after-tax value of different investments. If your marginal federal tax rate is 25%, then a corporate bond fund with a 4% yield and a municipal bond fund with a 3% yield have the same after-tax value to you. It is important to use the marginal tax rate for the appropriate type of income; if the muncipal bond fund is from your own state and is exempt from the 8% state tax as well, then you have a 31% marginal tax rate on the corporate fund and 0% on the municipal fund, and thus the municipal fund has a better after-tax yield.

Marginal rate of zero
A tax with a marginal rate of zero is a fixed-amount tax, such as a tax of $100 on every house rather than a percentage of the value of the house.

Flat rate tax
A flat rate tax has a constant marginal tax rate. Sales taxes and property taxes are normally flat, a fixed percentage of the value. Income taxes in some states are almost flat; typically, there is a fixed amount (such as a standard deduction) which is exempt from tax, and everyone making more than that fixed amount pays the same marginal tax rate, so the average tax rate varies.

Marginal rates explained
In finance, the term "marginal" means derivative. A marginal tax rate is one example of a partial derivative. We show why it's a derivative and then why it's partial. A full derivative results when the two variables are related through a third variable.

As a derivative
Applying calculus principles, the equivalence of marginal and derivatives is a matter of definition as described below:

Your income increases from $20,000 to $20,100; which provides you with $100 of extra income. This additional $100 of income results in $15 of additional tax. The marginal rate is therefore 15% = $15 / $100. Stated another way, your marginal tax rate at an income of $20,000 is 15%.

$$ \begin{align} {marginal\ tax\ rate\ at\ income\ of\ $20,000} & = \frac{tax(20,000 + 100) - tax(20,000)}{(20,000 + 100) - (20,000)} \\ \\ {marginal\ tax\ rate(I)}&= \frac{tax(I + \Delta) - tax(I)}{\Delta}\\ \\ \frac{df(x)}{dx}&=\lim_{\delta\rightarrow \infty} \frac{(f(x+\delta)-f(x))}{\delta} \end{align} $$

As a partial derivative
A partial derivative indicates that the tax is not a function of one income, e.g. total income, but several different types of income. For example, wages and capital gains. So we have not a function of one variable tax(income) but a function of two variables tax(wages,gains).

A partial derivative of a function of two or more variables is just the derivative if we change one variable and leave the others constant. This is how marginal tax rates are usually calculated. Refer to the previous example. At an income of $20,000, the marginal tax rate on wages is 15% because an extra $100 of wages increase taxes by $15. However, the marginal tax rate on capital gains is 0% because an extra $100 of capital gains results in $0 extra tax.

As a full derivative
Now, let's convert some of the wages into capital gains (through various investments). Both wages and capital gains are a function of a third variable, the proportion chosen to allocate to gains, x, which results in a form of tax(wage(x),gain(x)). Looking how this tax changes as the allocation changes results in a full derivative in the case of tax with respect to x (formally as  d(tax(x))/dx).

Forum discussions

 * Important to know Marginal Tax Rate? Effective Tax Rate?
 * Explains the importance of understanding the difference between marginal and effective tax rates.
 * Re: Effective Tax Rate [How to Calculate? ]