Portfolio Review - Validation for First Timer

Have a question about your personal investments? No matter how simple or complex, you can ask it here.
Post Reply
Topic Author
BarrelAged
Posts: 3
Joined: Sun Nov 19, 2023 11:23 am

Portfolio Review - Validation for First Timer

Post by BarrelAged »

Have been reading and learning for a year+ now and appreciate all the contributors. First post and looking for general validation of near term plans. Thank you in advance!

Emergency funds: Yes and then some, more details in questions below. Currently holding in Discover savings & Ally no-penalty CD's.

Debt: 152K mortgage, 10-yr ARM @ 2.875% through July 2026 then rate subject to change.

Tax Filing Status: Married Filing Jointly

Tax Rate: 22% Federal, 4.95% State

State of Residence: Illinois

Age: 35 / 39, 2 kids age 6 & 3

Desired Asset allocation: 80% stocks / 20% bonds
Desired International allocation: unknown

Current retirement assets

His 401k
-$130K in Vanguard Target Retirement 2050 (.045% ER)
-Currently contributing as roth, maxed for first time this year and will continue to do so. $55K of balance is roth basis.

Her IRA
-$44K Traditional
-$124K Roth
-held with EJ. Not listing all the holding details but majority in ETFs and mutual funds in similar AA to desired. I know the recommendation of this forum will be to pull these from EJ, which I'm working on convincing spouse :happy

His & Her Corporate Pension
-Both have defined benefit pensions with same megacorp.
-He is still working and if stay with company, will be based on salary and yrs (currently 12 yrs and $150K total income with ongoing career progression expected if remain with employer)
-Spouse stopped working after having kids, will receive benefit but only modest based on 13 yrs service and $70K top salary. Even if returns to work for same company, will not resume pension benefits as plan is no longer offered to new/re-hires.

_______________________________________________________________

Contributions

New annual Contributions
$23K (max) his 401k (employer matches a few thousand for employees with pension)

Questions:
1. We currently have $122K sitting in mix of Discover savings and no penalty CD's with Ally, earning 4-5%. When spouse stopped working 6 years ago we intentionally held larger than typical emergency fund, expecting to potentially need to draw from it to make it work on single income while wife is SAHM. My income has increased 2x since starting family and current expenses are supported by one income while maxing 401K, so I feel comfortable putting more of this into investing.

Plan is to open IRA's for him and her (have current Fidelity account) and contribute annual max for this year in simple three-fund at desired AA - assume this is advisable first step?

This still leaves ~$110K which I plan to invest a portion of - assume in a taxable account with Fidelity in same funds & AA as IRA accounts would be the next step after maxing IRA's?

Additional considerations:

-Current expenses are around $80K, I would be comfortable with 3-6 months in mm or current no-penalty CD's with some in savings as well for flexibility

-Have 529's for each kid, $10K balance currently and plan to increase contributions to $300-400/month.

-We don't have any major expenses planned/needed but have been discussing some home improvements as funds and time allows - mostly modest and that can be supported between cash flow and/or pulling a month or so from emergency fund. Only mentioning as justification to stay a little heavier in emergency (or more liquid funds) - maybe $40-50K target.

-Wife will likely return to some income when we're done having kids

2. I know there is not one answer to the traditional/roth question but should we be looking at switching to traditional given current amount in roth and expecting ongoing income increases through career, eventual pension benefit?

3. Mortgage - I'm obviously kicking myself for not locking in low rate... any guidance here knowing our current low rate will start changing in 2026? Should we just wait and see what rates do but generally assume to keep a mortgage at lowest rate possible.
User avatar
ruralavalon
Posts: 25764
Joined: Sat Feb 02, 2008 9:29 am
Location: Illinois

Re: Portfolio Review - Validation for First Timer

Post by ruralavalon »

Welcome to the forum :D .


BarrelAged wrote: Sun Nov 19, 2023 12:56 pm Hi all! Have been reading and learning for a year+ now and appreciate all the contributors. First post and looking for general validation of near term plans. Thank you in advance!

Emergency funds: Yes and then some, more details in questions below. Currently holding in Discover savings & Ally no-penalty CD's.

Debt: 152K mortgage, 10-yr ARM @ 2.875% through July 2026 then rate subject to change.
Will your mortgage lender permit recasting the mortgage? Not all lenders permit this.

Mortgage recasting: What it is and how it works




BarrelAged wrote: Sun Nov 19, 2023 12:56 pmTax Filing Status: Married Filing Jointly

Tax Rate: 22% Federal, 4.95% State

State of Residence: Illinois

Age: 35 / 39, 2 kids age 6 & 3

Desired Asset allocation: 80% stocks / 20% bonds
Desired International allocation: unknown
In my opinion, at age 35/39 with a pension expected, 20% in bonds is within the range of what is reasonable.


BarrelAged wrote: Sun Nov 19, 2023 12:56 pm Current retirement assets

His 401k
-$130K in Vanguard Target Retirement 2050 (.045% ER)
-Currently contributing as roth, maxed for first time this year and will continue to do so. $55K of balance is roth basis.

Her IRA
-$44K Traditional
-$124K Roth
-held with EJ. Not listing all the holding details but majority in ETFs and mutual funds in similar AA to desired. I know the recommendation of this forum will be to pull these from EJ, which I'm working on convincing spouse :happy

His & Her Corporate Pension
-Both have defined benefit pensions with same megacorp.
-He is still working and if stay with company, will be based on salary and yrs (currently 12 yrs and $150K total income with ongoing career progression expected if remain with employer)
-Spouse stopped working after having kids, will receive benefit but only modest based on 13 yrs service and $70K top salary. Even if returns to work for same company, will not resume pension benefits as plan is no longer offered to new/re-hires.

_______________________________________________________________

Contributions

New annual Contributions
$23K (max) his 401k (employer matches a few thousand for employees with pension)

Questions:
1. We currently have $122K sitting in mix of Discover savings and no penalty CD's with Ally, earning 4-5%. When spouse stopped working 6 years ago we intentionally held larger than typical emergency fund, expecting to potentially need to draw from it to make it work on single income while wife is SAHM. My income has increased 2x since starting family and current expenses are supported by one income while maxing 401K, so I feel comfortable putting more of this into investing.

Plan is to open IRA's for him and her (have current Fidelity account) and contribute annual max for this year in simple three-fund at desired AA - assume this is advisable first step?

This still leaves ~$110K which I plan to invest a portion of - assume in a taxable account with Fidelity in same funds & AA as IRA accounts would be the next step after maxing IRA's?
In a taxable brokerage account I suggest using a very tax-efficient stock index funds or a stock index ETF like: Vanguard Total Stock Market ETF (VTI) OR iShares Core S&P Total US Stock Mkt ETF (ITOT).I

Wiki article, Tax-efficient fund placement.


BarrelAged wrote: Sun Nov 19, 2023 12:56 pmAdditional considerations:

-Current expenses are around $80K, I would be comfortable with 3-6 months in mm or current no-penalty CD's with some in savings as well for flexibility

-Have 529's for each kid, $10K balance currently and plan to increase contributions to $300-400/month.

-We don't have any major expenses planned/needed but have been discussing some home improvements as funds and time allows - mostly modest and that can be supported between cash flow and/or pulling a month or so from emergency fund. Only mentioning as justification to stay a little heavier in emergency (or more liquid funds) - maybe $40-50K target.

-Wife will likely return to some income when we're done having kids
This seems reasonable in my opinion.



BarrelAged wrote: Sun Nov 19, 2023 12:56 pm2. I know there is not one answer to the traditional/roth question but should we be looking at switching to traditional given current amount in roth and expecting ongoing income increases through career, eventual pension benefit?
Yes, you should consider more traditional tax-deferred contributions.


BarrelAged wrote: Sun Nov 19, 2023 12:56 pm3. Mortgage - I'm obviously kicking myself for not locking in low rate... any guidance here knowing our current low rate will start changing in 2026? Should we just wait and see what rates do but generally assume to keep a mortgage at lowest rate possible.
Will your mortgage lender permit recasting the mortgage? Not all lenders permit this.

Mortgage recasting: What it is and how it works
"Everything should be as simple as it is, but not simpler." - Albert Einstein | Wiki article link: Bogleheads® investment philosophy
User avatar
welderwannabe
Posts: 1577
Joined: Fri Jun 16, 2017 8:32 am

Re: Portfolio Review - Validation for First Timer

Post by welderwannabe »

BarrelAged wrote: Sun Nov 19, 2023 12:56 pm
Debt: 152K mortgage, 10-yr ARM @ 2.875% through July 2026 then rate subject to change.

3. Mortgage - I'm obviously kicking myself for not locking in low rate... any guidance here knowing our current low rate will start changing in 2026? Should we just wait and see what rates do but generally assume to keep a mortgage at lowest rate possible.
Is that all you have for debt? If so then bravo. No one knows what interest rates will do between now and 2026, but if I had to guess, they will probably be lower than they are now, but possibly not as low as your 2.875% you've got now.

You have enough cash to come close to knocking the mortgage out. If you can make it happen, I'd consider continuing to save between now and July 2026 and be in a position to just pay the home off. I'd put the cash in a short duration bond fund until then, or possibly a 3 year CD. You could also dump it in a total market/S&P500 fund now and just hope its up in 3 year, but thats a bit more risky. Regardless, I wouldn't want that $400+ monthly interest increase upon the rate reset hanging over my head.

You've come to an investing forum so most of the advice you'll get would be to just invest. I'll be the contrarian.
I am not an investment professional, but I did stay at a Holiday Inn Express last night.
Topic Author
BarrelAged
Posts: 3
Joined: Sun Nov 19, 2023 11:23 am

Re: Portfolio Review - Validation for First Timer

Post by BarrelAged »

Thank you both for the responses!

I will consider mortgage recasting closer to the rate lock ending, that does seem like a decent way to balance paying less interest overall with not putting so much of investable funds in house. If it matters, we currently have ~$275K in equity.

I did omit a debt item - we owe $4K on one of the vehicles (other is paid off) at 1.9% but this (I assume) is not a factor in what I'm considering.
Topic Author
BarrelAged
Posts: 3
Joined: Sun Nov 19, 2023 11:23 am

Re: Portfolio Review - Validation for First Timer

Post by BarrelAged »

Appreciate the replies so far! Looking for any additional input or validation of my plan before I move forward with IRA’s and taxable?
Post Reply