Fidelity charges to close accounts!
-
- Posts: 1407
- Joined: Thu Nov 16, 2017 3:03 am
Re: Fidelity charges to close accounts!
Hmm. I'm planning to open a solo 401k next month and roll my SEP into my Rollover IRA -- good to know that this fee *might* exist (given varying thoughts in this thread). I'll report back.
-
- Posts: 820
- Joined: Sat Jun 28, 2014 7:49 pm
Re: Fidelity charges to close accounts!
The fee is disclosed at the time you open your account. When I opened mine decades ago, some guy (or lady) wearing a green eye shade in a back room had to do the work of closing the account, so maybe $50 was reasonable then. When I opened the account, a lot of places had the closing fee. Many charts were available comparing fees across different brokers. At that time at least, it wasn't a secret you'd pay a closing fee.
Nowadays I imagine the closing is untouched by human hands, so $50 relative to today's actual cost to do so is probably a bit much. Nonetheless, the monetary benefit I received from the Fidelity account dwarfs the $50, so I'm not bothered by it.
If they raised the fee, I'd be livid
Nowadays I imagine the closing is untouched by human hands, so $50 relative to today's actual cost to do so is probably a bit much. Nonetheless, the monetary benefit I received from the Fidelity account dwarfs the $50, so I'm not bothered by it.
If they raised the fee, I'd be livid
He that loveth silver shall not be satisfied with silver; nor he that loveth abundance with increase: this is also vanity.
Re: Fidelity charges to close accounts!
Burden and simplicity are fair points, agreed. In retrospect, the Op's characterization of it as spite or childishness is what made no sense to me. There are good reasons to leave it open that don't involve either.goingup wrote: ↑Fri Dec 08, 2017 8:15 amI'm not the poster who said that, but I don't find it savvy to keep a $1 in an account to outflank a closing fee. It's messy. The material impact of $50 is essentially immaterial compared the "burden" of dragging around another custodian's passwords, policies, marketing solicitations. If you place a premium on simplicity, $50 is worth it.
-
- Posts: 259
- Joined: Mon Oct 06, 2008 8:16 pm
Re: Fidelity charges to close accounts!
As previously mentioned, Fidelity's IRA closing fee isn't that bad.
Discount brokers: Etrade, Scottrade, TD Ameritrade are all $75
Merrill Lynch is $75
US Bank charges $40 annually just to have an IRA.
Morgan Stanley charges $40 annually (with less than $25,000 assets) and as a bonus has an IRA closing fee of $95.
I could continue, but comparatively speaking, it ain't so bad.
Discount brokers: Etrade, Scottrade, TD Ameritrade are all $75
Merrill Lynch is $75
US Bank charges $40 annually just to have an IRA.
Morgan Stanley charges $40 annually (with less than $25,000 assets) and as a bonus has an IRA closing fee of $95.
I could continue, but comparatively speaking, it ain't so bad.
Re: Fidelity charges to close accounts!
What happens if there's a zero balance at the time of closing?
Wife and I were making some updates to accounts this year and liquidated her HSA at HSA Bank. Later, when we went to close it, I noticed there was a $25 account closing fee on their fee schedule. Account had $0.00 in it and when we called to close the account, they said no charge.
Would other custodians send you a bill for the fee?
Wife and I were making some updates to accounts this year and liquidated her HSA at HSA Bank. Later, when we went to close it, I noticed there was a $25 account closing fee on their fee schedule. Account had $0.00 in it and when we called to close the account, they said no charge.
Would other custodians send you a bill for the fee?
Re: Fidelity charges to close accounts!
My mom has a Rollover IRA + checking account at Fidelity
Was looking into closing her IRA and withdrawing the remaining $2800 for 2018 tax year
Looks like $50 account closing fee applies if I select an external account for transfer, but waived if I select Fidelity checking account instead
Close IRA & transfer funds to external Ally account:
From Account ROLLOVER IRA
Action Withdraw full amount and close account
Date 01/08/2018
Estimated Withdrawal Amount $2,801.12
Federal Tax Withholding 0.00%
Estimated State Tax Withholding 0.00%
Account Closing Fee $50.00
Estimated Net Amount $2,751.12
Withdrawal Type Normal
To Account ALLY BANK
Close IRA & transfer funds to Fidelity checking account:
From Account ROLLOVER IRA
Action Withdraw full amount and close account
Date 01/08/2018
Estimated Withdrawal Amount $2,801.12
Federal Tax Withholding 0.00%
Estimated State Tax Withholding 0.00%
Account Closing Fee $0.00
Estimated Net Amount $2,801.12
Withdrawal Type Normal
To Account MyCash
Went ahead and submitted the request to Fidelity checking account and pending transfer activity shows full amount so the fee is being waived
Was looking into closing her IRA and withdrawing the remaining $2800 for 2018 tax year
Looks like $50 account closing fee applies if I select an external account for transfer, but waived if I select Fidelity checking account instead
Close IRA & transfer funds to external Ally account:
From Account ROLLOVER IRA
Action Withdraw full amount and close account
Date 01/08/2018
Estimated Withdrawal Amount $2,801.12
Federal Tax Withholding 0.00%
Estimated State Tax Withholding 0.00%
Account Closing Fee $50.00
Estimated Net Amount $2,751.12
Withdrawal Type Normal
To Account ALLY BANK
Close IRA & transfer funds to Fidelity checking account:
From Account ROLLOVER IRA
Action Withdraw full amount and close account
Date 01/08/2018
Estimated Withdrawal Amount $2,801.12
Federal Tax Withholding 0.00%
Estimated State Tax Withholding 0.00%
Account Closing Fee $0.00
Estimated Net Amount $2,801.12
Withdrawal Type Normal
To Account MyCash
Went ahead and submitted the request to Fidelity checking account and pending transfer activity shows full amount so the fee is being waived
- BrandonBogle
- Posts: 4467
- Joined: Mon Jan 28, 2013 10:19 pm
Re: Fidelity charges to close accounts!
So today I helped my mother "close out" her IRA at Fidelity now that her last bond matured. When on the transfer screen to go from the IRA to her Fidelity Brokerage account, it explicitly said that closing the account would be subject to a closure fee (but didn't list the amount). We instead left $0.01 in the IRA. At some point, we'll call or message Fidelity to see if they want to no-fee close it out, or we'll just "abandon" the $0.01.
Re: Fidelity charges to close accounts!
In hopes of adding some clarity and reducing some noise. Fidelity does not charge a fee when you close an IRA account by Roth converting, close a Roth by recharacterizing, close either by merging, etc. I was told that the fee applies only if a person totally leaves Fidelity (i.e. closes their last account). I'll never do that so I'll never pay the fee.
I am not a lawyer, accountant or financial advisor. Any advice or suggestions that I may provide shall be considered for entertainment purposes only.
Re: Fidelity charges to close accounts!
A little confused here. If you leave money in the accounts so they are not closed, why are they charging you $50.00 closing fee? Wouldn't the $50 closing fee apply if you withdrew your money and closed the account? Sorry, not getting this.gaiusgracchus wrote: ↑Wed Apr 17, 2013 6:46 pm We are learning that Fidelity has account closing fees of $50.00. So we leave our money in their accounts (earning nothing) and they charge $50.00 for the privilege.
Vanguard does not charge for closing retirement accounts, thankfully.
Also, I know from past experience that E*Trade charges a $50 account closing fee, at least they did when I closed my accounts years ago.
- Earl Lemongrab
- Posts: 7270
- Joined: Tue Jun 10, 2014 1:14 am
Re: Fidelity charges to close accounts!
With Etrade at least, they won't charge you if the final transfer is to a linked account. For an IRA you could do a 60-day rollover (remember you get but one per IRA type).
- LiveSimple
- Posts: 2312
- Joined: Thu Jan 03, 2013 6:55 am
Re: Fidelity charges to close accounts!
Folks, really does $50 matters, when you transfer your assets worth more.
Call it a “doing business” fees and move on.
Did we not order or buy something from a store worth $50, and not use it ?
Call it a “doing business” fees and move on.
Did we not order or buy something from a store worth $50, and not use it ?
Invest when you have the money, sell when you need the money, for real life expenses...
- BrandonBogle
- Posts: 4467
- Joined: Mon Jan 28, 2013 10:19 pm
Re: Fidelity charges to close accounts!
Just an update that we looked today and choosing to "close account and transfer all funds" still said an account closure fee would be assessed. However, when going through the screens before hitting submit, the final review page listed the closure fee as $0.00. I printed that out as a PDF and we submitting the closure for the last penny.BrandonBogle wrote: ↑Mon Jan 08, 2018 3:28 pm So today I helped my mother "close out" her IRA at Fidelity now that her last bond matured. When on the transfer screen to go from the IRA to her Fidelity Brokerage account, it explicitly said that closing the account would be subject to a closure fee (but didn't list the amount). We instead left $0.01 in the IRA. At some point, we'll call or message Fidelity to see if they want to no-fee close it out, or we'll just "abandon" the $0.01.
Re: Fidelity charges to close accounts!
We are Bogleheads!LiveSimple wrote: ↑Tue Jan 09, 2018 5:21 am Folks, really does $50 matters, when you transfer your assets worth more.
- saltycaper
- Posts: 2650
- Joined: Thu Apr 24, 2014 8:47 pm
- Location: The Tower
Re: Fidelity charges to close accounts!
Now that others have mentioned it, I too recall closing a taxable Fidelity brokerage account and not being assessed any fee. I did have other Fidelity accounts that I kept open.
Quod vitae sectabor iter?
Re: Fidelity charges to close accounts!
I recently closed out one of my wife's IRAs at Fidelity by withdrawal and transfer to a joint Fidelity Cash Management account. No charge. YMMV. We both still have other Fidelity accounts.The Wizard wrote: ↑Wed Dec 06, 2017 4:45 pm This is a four year old thread.
Some details may have changed...
- Earl Lemongrab
- Posts: 7270
- Joined: Tue Jun 10, 2014 1:14 am
Re: Fidelity charges to close accounts!
As I understand it, the only thing they charge for is closing an IRA. That's better than many, as they don't have any fees for partial or total asset transfers.saltycaper wrote: ↑Tue Jan 09, 2018 12:36 pm Now that others have mentioned it, I too recall closing a taxable Fidelity brokerage account and not being assessed any fee. I did have other Fidelity accounts that I kept open.
Re: Fidelity charges to close accounts!
If you have asubstantial IRA and a taxable account, tell your saleman or office manager that you will leave the taxable account with Fidelity if they waive the fee when you move the IRA. (This may actually be the policy - it was at eTrade, no fee if $50K remained. Then if you really want to move the taxable account you transferf a little bit at a time. When you have all cash in the account yiu just write a check leaving $1.28. I did this when I left eTrade and kept getting monthly statements with the $1.28 balance for 10 years. Etrade has no inactivity fee!!!
Bottom line is that the brokerages have flexibility in getting you to transfer into their firm so it makes sense that they have the same flexibility in trying to slow a plan to move assets out of the firm.
Bottom line is that the brokerages have flexibility in getting you to transfer into their firm so it makes sense that they have the same flexibility in trying to slow a plan to move assets out of the firm.
- CokeSlurpee711
- Posts: 69
- Joined: Sun Mar 25, 2012 8:50 pm
Re: Fidelity charges to close accounts!
Moved all but $0.01 of a small IRA out of Fidelity. Sticking it to the man!
Re: Fidelity charges to close accounts!
Companies that charge me $ when I stop doing business with them are companies I'd be suspicious of.
"Optimum est pati quod emendare non possis." |
-Seneca
-
- Posts: 3338
- Joined: Thu May 19, 2016 5:04 pm
Re: Fidelity charges to close accounts!
You can just leave $0.01 there and avoid the closing fees.
Re: Fidelity charges to close accounts!
I just got hit with a $50 fee for rolling a Fidelity 401k ($70k or so in there) into a new Fidelity rollover IRA (done online). No mention of it while setting the IRA up, which is annoying. I have a feeling that a quick call will get it resolved, but any other advice on how to do it the quickest?
-
- Posts: 25625
- Joined: Thu Apr 05, 2007 8:20 pm
- Location: New York
Re: Fidelity charges to close accounts!
Maybe they didn’t get the notice-no fees! At least I think that is what they are advertising.Bendee wrote: ↑Sun Aug 05, 2018 7:17 am I just got hit with a $50 fee for rolling a Fidelity 401k ($70k or so in there) into a new Fidelity rollover IRA (done online). No mention of it while setting the IRA up, which is annoying. I have a feeling that a quick call will get it resolved, but any other advice on how to do it the quickest?
"One should invest based on their need, ability and willingness to take risk - Larry Swedroe" Asking Portfolio Questions
Re: Fidelity charges to close accounts!
A few months ago I rolled over a sizable 401K (at Fidelity) into a Fidelity Rollover IRA. Not only did they not charge me a fee, but I got them to offer me a $2,500 bonus to keep the funds at Fidelity (once I told them I was considering other brokers at which to open the Rollover IRA - based upon bonuses being offered by those brokers for the transferred funds).Bendee wrote: ↑Sun Aug 05, 2018 7:17 am I just got hit with a $50 fee for rolling a Fidelity 401k ($70k or so in there) into a new Fidelity rollover IRA (done online). No mention of it while setting the IRA up, which is annoying. I have a feeling that a quick call will get it resolved, but any other advice on how to do it the quickest?
Something sounds very wrong to me. I’d call Fidelity and suspect they will quickly reverse the charge.
Real Knowledge Comes Only From Experience
-
- Posts: 13977
- Joined: Fri Mar 02, 2007 1:39 pm
Re: Fidelity charges to close accounts!
I'm pretty sure would have been a plan fee, not a Fidelity fee on the IRA receiving side. I have rolled over several 401k plans over decades to Fidelity IRAs and have never been subjected to a "rollin" fee.Grt2bOutdoors wrote: ↑Sun Aug 05, 2018 7:25 amMaybe they didn’t get the notice-no fees! At least I think that is what they are advertising.Bendee wrote: ↑Sun Aug 05, 2018 7:17 am I just got hit with a $50 fee for rolling a Fidelity 401k ($70k or so in there) into a new Fidelity rollover IRA (done online). No mention of it while setting the IRA up, which is annoying. I have a feeling that a quick call will get it resolved, but any other advice on how to do it the quickest?
I keep repeating this, but nobody seems to get it. Even if Fidelity, Vanguard, etc... are the custodian and/or administrator of your 401k plan. Your employer controls the fund selection, expense ratios, employee administrative fees and the rest of fee schedule.
-
- Posts: 9477
- Joined: Sun Oct 08, 2017 7:16 pm
Re: Fidelity charges to close accounts!
So instead of making a quick call to Fidelity, call your employer's plan administrator.Spirit Rider wrote: ↑Sun Aug 05, 2018 7:42 amI'm pretty sure would have been a plan fee, not a Fidelity fee on the IRA receiving side. I have rolled over several 401k plans over decades to Fidelity IRAs and have never been subjected to a "rollin" fee.Grt2bOutdoors wrote: ↑Sun Aug 05, 2018 7:25 amMaybe they didn’t get the notice-no fees! At least I think that is what they are advertising.Bendee wrote: ↑Sun Aug 05, 2018 7:17 am I just got hit with a $50 fee for rolling a Fidelity 401k ($70k or so in there) into a new Fidelity rollover IRA (done online). No mention of it while setting the IRA up, which is annoying. I have a feeling that a quick call will get it resolved, but any other advice on how to do it the quickest?
I keep repeating this, but nobody seems to get it. Even if Fidelity, Vanguard, etc... are the custodian and/or administrator of your 401k plan. Your employer controls the fund selection, expense ratios, employee administrative fees and the rest of fee schedule.
- cheese_breath
- Posts: 11786
- Joined: Wed Sep 14, 2011 7:08 pm
Re: Fidelity charges to close accounts!
I've avoided Fidelity ever since they screwed me over rolling my GM 401K into my TIAA IRA two decades ago. I have a loooong memory.
The surest way to know the future is when it becomes the past.
-
- Posts: 9477
- Joined: Sun Oct 08, 2017 7:16 pm
Re: Fidelity charges to close accounts!
How is this actionable? Are you recommending that the rest of us avoid Fidelity because you had a bad experience two decades ago?cheese_breath wrote: ↑Sun Aug 05, 2018 9:14 am I've avoided Fidelity ever since they screwed me over rolling my GM 401K into my TIAA IRA two decades ago. I have a loooong memory.
- cheese_breath
- Posts: 11786
- Joined: Wed Sep 14, 2011 7:08 pm
Re: Fidelity charges to close accounts!
Well, you just took the action of commenting on it.UpperNwGuy wrote: ↑Sun Aug 05, 2018 9:25 amHow is this actionable? Are you recommending that the rest of us avoid Fidelity because you had a bad experience two decades ago?cheese_breath wrote: ↑Sun Aug 05, 2018 9:14 am I've avoided Fidelity ever since they screwed me over rolling my GM 401K into my TIAA IRA two decades ago. I have a loooong memory.
The surest way to know the future is when it becomes the past.
- Earl Lemongrab
- Posts: 7270
- Joined: Tue Jun 10, 2014 1:14 am
Re: Fidelity charges to close accounts!
I agree with the above. 401(k) fees are usually established by the plan. Fidelity just adminsters it.Bendee wrote: ↑Sun Aug 05, 2018 7:17 am I just got hit with a $50 fee for rolling a Fidelity 401k ($70k or so in there) into a new Fidelity rollover IRA (done online). No mention of it while setting the IRA up, which is annoying. I have a feeling that a quick call will get it resolved, but any other advice on how to do it the quickest?
Re: Fidelity charges to close accounts!
I would give them a call.Bendee wrote: ↑Sun Aug 05, 2018 7:17 am I just got hit with a $50 fee for rolling a Fidelity 401k ($70k or so in there) into a new Fidelity rollover IRA (done online). No mention of it while setting the IRA up, which is annoying. I have a feeling that a quick call will get it resolved, but any other advice on how to do it the quickest?
I recently rolled over a Fidelity Keogh (like a 401k) retirement account to my Fidelity IRA. Before doing so I called to verify there is no fee. They told me rolling over inside of Fidelity will not generate a fee. After doing that I checked. They did not charge me a fee.
- TimeRunner
- Posts: 1939
- Joined: Sat Dec 29, 2012 8:23 pm
- Location: Beach-side, CA
Re: Fidelity charges to close accounts!
Right, but your problem twenty years ago was with (the old) GM as the Plan Administrator, per upthread, not Fidelity. Of course GM is no longer GM either. So it goes....cheese_breath wrote: ↑Sun Aug 05, 2018 9:28 amWell, you just took the action of commenting on it.UpperNwGuy wrote: ↑Sun Aug 05, 2018 9:25 amHow is this actionable? Are you recommending that the rest of us avoid Fidelity because you had a bad experience two decades ago?cheese_breath wrote: ↑Sun Aug 05, 2018 9:14 am I've avoided Fidelity ever since they screwed me over rolling my GM 401K into my TIAA IRA two decades ago. I have a loooong memory.
One cannot enlighten the unconscious. | "All I need are some tasty waves, a cool buzz, and I'm fine." -Jeff Spicoli
-
- Posts: 12
- Joined: Fri Jul 13, 2018 1:18 pm
Re: Fidelity charges to close accounts!
No, not any more they don't. As of August 1, 2018, Fidelity no longer has any closeout fee for any kind of IRA. Part of their big "Zero" initiative.
They never have, at least not in recent years, had a transfer-out fee for doing an in-kind ACATS out of security positions. But they did have a $50 IRA close fee, if your out-transfer was in fact for everything.
I kept an unused Fidelity IRA alive with only 1 penny in it for about 5 years from 2011-2016 to avoid the fee. Started using it again in 2016 through now.
If you have a Workplace Savings Account managed by Fidelity at their Netbenefits site, like a 401(k), 401(a), 403(b), or a 457 plan, there may well be some fees, but that's likely based on what your employer set up with Fidelity and the plan trustee board when they picked Fidelity to manage it. Those are not Fidelity Brokerage Services accounts ("Fidelity retail accounts"), even if they have the BrokerageLink feature. Similar if you have an outside RIA who uses Fidelity's Institutional Wealth Services platform for your account - fees are not set entirely by Fidelity.
But FBS ("retail") IRAs no longer have any account closing fees. Nor any cost on literally getting the funds out as cash either. ACH transfers already were free. Also no longer any domestic wire sending fees. It's not clear on foreign wires, because they only mention a fee still existing on foreign currency wires, but a lot of foreign wires are sent as USD, so I suspect that even if you're enjoying some "Escape to Sovereign International Haven Living Overseas" and close out your Fido IRA with a USD wire to "Republic of Beach Haven National Bank", it may be no charge to send. (Charge if Fido has to send as BeachHaven ShellPesos.)
So pretty much no fee to get your money and/or shares out of Fidelity Brokerage in any normal situation. Though with now-lowest index fund expense ratios (not just the two "Zero" funds), less reason than ever to leave it.
They never have, at least not in recent years, had a transfer-out fee for doing an in-kind ACATS out of security positions. But they did have a $50 IRA close fee, if your out-transfer was in fact for everything.
I kept an unused Fidelity IRA alive with only 1 penny in it for about 5 years from 2011-2016 to avoid the fee. Started using it again in 2016 through now.
If you have a Workplace Savings Account managed by Fidelity at their Netbenefits site, like a 401(k), 401(a), 403(b), or a 457 plan, there may well be some fees, but that's likely based on what your employer set up with Fidelity and the plan trustee board when they picked Fidelity to manage it. Those are not Fidelity Brokerage Services accounts ("Fidelity retail accounts"), even if they have the BrokerageLink feature. Similar if you have an outside RIA who uses Fidelity's Institutional Wealth Services platform for your account - fees are not set entirely by Fidelity.
But FBS ("retail") IRAs no longer have any account closing fees. Nor any cost on literally getting the funds out as cash either. ACH transfers already were free. Also no longer any domestic wire sending fees. It's not clear on foreign wires, because they only mention a fee still existing on foreign currency wires, but a lot of foreign wires are sent as USD, so I suspect that even if you're enjoying some "Escape to Sovereign International Haven Living Overseas" and close out your Fido IRA with a USD wire to "Republic of Beach Haven National Bank", it may be no charge to send. (Charge if Fido has to send as BeachHaven ShellPesos.)
So pretty much no fee to get your money and/or shares out of Fidelity Brokerage in any normal situation. Though with now-lowest index fund expense ratios (not just the two "Zero" funds), less reason than ever to leave it.