A SUV for towing a Travel Trailer
A SUV for towing a Travel Trailer
I am getting prepared to buy a SUV for towing a 3200 lb loaded Travel Trailer with Brakes due in May 2017.
I have read up on many automobile reviews, write ups..etc but I am looking for your take on one and reasons for suggesting that particular SUV from a Towing & vehicle reliability are concerned.
A few points to keep in mind are -
- Smaller Garage size - Our RX350 L188" & W 74" (3500 lb Towing Capacity) just about fills up the Garage & any larger size may be a problem size wise.
- Need at least 5000 lbs Towing Capacity
- At least a 6 Cylinder with good amount of Torque
- Money, within reason is not a constraint
- I take care of & usually keep my vehicles about 8 to 10 yrs
Thanks for any & all suggestions.
I have read up on many automobile reviews, write ups..etc but I am looking for your take on one and reasons for suggesting that particular SUV from a Towing & vehicle reliability are concerned.
A few points to keep in mind are -
- Smaller Garage size - Our RX350 L188" & W 74" (3500 lb Towing Capacity) just about fills up the Garage & any larger size may be a problem size wise.
- Need at least 5000 lbs Towing Capacity
- At least a 6 Cylinder with good amount of Torque
- Money, within reason is not a constraint
- I take care of & usually keep my vehicles about 8 to 10 yrs
Thanks for any & all suggestions.
Re: A SUV for towing a Travel Trailer
With the recent (towing) demise of the GM mid-sized SUVs, if you want a new vehicle, maybe an Explorer (10" longer, though) or one of the Jeep models? Keep in mind the GVWR and how much weight you'll end up with in the SUV including the tongue weight - you might hit that limit well before the towing capacity limit.Rajsx wrote:I am getting prepared to buy a SUV for towing a 3200 lb loaded Travel Trailer with Brakes due in May 2017.
I have read up on many automobile reviews, write ups..etc but I am looking for your take on one and reasons for suggesting that particular SUV from a Towing & vehicle reliability are concerned.
A few points to keep in mind are -
- Smaller Garage size - Our RX350 L188" & W 74" (3500 lb Towing Capacity) just about fills up the Garage & any larger size may be a problem size wise.
- Need at least 5000 lbs Towing Capacity
- At least a 6 Cylinder with good amount of Torque
- Money, within reason is not a constraint
- I take care of & usually keep my vehicles about 8 to 10 yrs
Thanks for any & all suggestions.
Also a 4-runner is just a few inches longer than what you have, I believe.
-
- Posts: 12073
- Joined: Fri Sep 18, 2009 1:10 am
Re: A SUV for towing a Travel Trailer
Grand Cherokee has a high tow rating (6000?, 7000?) and is not much longer than your current vehicle.
Camping last year, the lot next door had one and was pulling a 30' trailer with 2 slides, I talked with the owner. He was very happy with the Grand Cherokee.
[edit] Just went to the Jeep website - the 5.7 liter V8 is rated at 7200 lbs. 189.8" long - within 2 inches of your RX
Camping last year, the lot next door had one and was pulling a 30' trailer with 2 slides, I talked with the owner. He was very happy with the Grand Cherokee.
[edit] Just went to the Jeep website - the 5.7 liter V8 is rated at 7200 lbs. 189.8" long - within 2 inches of your RX
Last edited by David Jay on Sun Mar 19, 2017 9:47 pm, edited 1 time in total.
It's not an engineering problem - Hersh Shefrin | To get the "risk premium", you really do have to take the risk - nisiprius
-
- Posts: 631
- Joined: Tue Oct 29, 2013 11:11 pm
Re: A SUV for towing a Travel Trailer
Toyota Highlander. Will tow 5000 lbs and is a really nice car. It is likely to be my tow-vehicle upgrade when I move on from my Lincoln MKX (aka, pimped out Ford Edge) which has a 3500lb tow capacity. I'm hoping to move to a larger AFrame or Fiberglass camper than my current smaller AFrame.
A mid-sized short-bed pickup could also be an option as well, and would be a little cheaper and give you perhaps upwards to 7500lbs or more..
A mid-sized short-bed pickup could also be an option as well, and would be a little cheaper and give you perhaps upwards to 7500lbs or more..
Re: A SUV for towing a Travel Trailer
We recently replaced our 2001 Jeep Grand Cherokee (5000 lb. towing) with a 2015 Summit model (7000 lb. towing) and are completely delighted with our choice. Great safety and luxury features and about $10-15k cheaper than the comparable Toyota choice. Can't even feel our 4500 lb. trailer behind us!
Re: A SUV for towing a Travel Trailer
A friend who like me is biased towards Japanese (reliable) cars got a Lexus GX for his trailer and is happy with it. I recall from his research that the vast majority of SUV's fulfilling his criteria were larger American made SUV's. Like you cost was not a major concern for him, but he thought that Lexus LX was too costly.(I have never owned a SUV)
Ram
-
- Posts: 348
- Joined: Thu Nov 18, 2010 2:29 pm
Re: A SUV for towing a Travel Trailer
Our Chevy Traverse tows up to 5,200 lbs.
- tractorguy
- Posts: 679
- Joined: Wed May 19, 2010 6:32 pm
- Location: Chicago Suburb
Re: A SUV for towing a Travel Trailer
I ended up with a 2015 Mercedes ML350. I've towed my 4500# Jayco to Wisconsin & Pittsburgh with no issues at 65 MPH. It doesn't really want to go faster than 65. Weight isn't the issue, wind resistance is. I haven't climbed any mountains with the rig yet but don't anticipate any problems keeping up with traffic on the interstates.
This is my spouse's daily driver and she didn't want a truck (her previous car was a Camry). She's very happy with the Mercedes in town and on the highway.
I drove every SUV that had a 5000# or greater tow capacity before settling on the Mercedes. My second choice was a Jeep Grand Cherokee or Explorer but thought they would be too much like a truck for her. The Toyota Highlander was the most carlike driver but although it was rated at 5000#, it was very obvious that tow capacity was an afterthought for the car's designers. No built in wiring harness for trailer brakes, no anti-sway control, and a low max GVW rating convinced me that I didn't want to pull anything bigger than a pop up with a Highlander. Also my experience with the Camry was that Toyota is designed to the stated limits. We overloaded the Camry frequently taking kids to college and with our annual beach vacation. Think of a car loaded to the windowsills with a full car top carrier going over the Appalachians. It put up with this but I had to replace the brake rotors a few times and it was worn out at 150K miles. Loose suspension, play in the steering rack, and the beginnings of a knock in the engine (eg worn bearings) convinced me it was time to sell.
I've got 40K miles on the Mercedes at 2 years and so far no issues except for the cost of oil changes. I've addressed this partially by going to an independent mechanic but the thing takes 7 quarts of synthetic oil, and very expensive filters. Luckily oil change interval is 10000 miles.
Besides pickups, I see a lot of Grand Cherokees at campsites. A friend who has one, suggests that you go with the V-8 if you are serious about towing.
This is my spouse's daily driver and she didn't want a truck (her previous car was a Camry). She's very happy with the Mercedes in town and on the highway.
I drove every SUV that had a 5000# or greater tow capacity before settling on the Mercedes. My second choice was a Jeep Grand Cherokee or Explorer but thought they would be too much like a truck for her. The Toyota Highlander was the most carlike driver but although it was rated at 5000#, it was very obvious that tow capacity was an afterthought for the car's designers. No built in wiring harness for trailer brakes, no anti-sway control, and a low max GVW rating convinced me that I didn't want to pull anything bigger than a pop up with a Highlander. Also my experience with the Camry was that Toyota is designed to the stated limits. We overloaded the Camry frequently taking kids to college and with our annual beach vacation. Think of a car loaded to the windowsills with a full car top carrier going over the Appalachians. It put up with this but I had to replace the brake rotors a few times and it was worn out at 150K miles. Loose suspension, play in the steering rack, and the beginnings of a knock in the engine (eg worn bearings) convinced me it was time to sell.
I've got 40K miles on the Mercedes at 2 years and so far no issues except for the cost of oil changes. I've addressed this partially by going to an independent mechanic but the thing takes 7 quarts of synthetic oil, and very expensive filters. Luckily oil change interval is 10000 miles.
Besides pickups, I see a lot of Grand Cherokees at campsites. A friend who has one, suggests that you go with the V-8 if you are serious about towing.
Lorne
Re: A SUV for towing a Travel Trailer
The Traverse is even longer than the Explorer though, but if it fits it apparently has retained the towing capacity that its former twin, the Acadia, lost.lostinjersey wrote:Our Chevy Traverse tows up to 5,200 lbs.
Re: A SUV for towing a Travel Trailer
I would second the Toyota 4runner for towing, it is very reliable and dependable car and is very capable off road vehicle is a plus.
Re: A SUV for towing a Travel Trailer
Jeep Grand Cherokee with the diesel v6 will tow your trailer no problem, and get halfway decent fuel economy while doing so. As others mentioned, the Lexus GX and Toyota 4Runner are real trucks with ladder frames that are designed for towing. The V8 in the GX will have quite a bit more grunt than the V6 in the 4Runner.
-
- Posts: 422
- Joined: Sun Nov 16, 2014 5:18 pm
- Location: San Francisco Peninsula
Re: A SUV for towing a Travel Trailer
One could argue only vehicles with full frames are TRULY designed for towing IMHO.....................
-
- Posts: 1712
- Joined: Wed Nov 05, 2014 2:23 pm
Re: A SUV for towing a Travel Trailer
My inlaws bought an RPOD and pulled it across the country with a diesel Jeep Grand Cherokee. Pulled it with no problems and got great fuel mileage while towing.Rajsx wrote:I am getting prepared to buy a SUV for towing a 3200 lb loaded Travel Trailer with Brakes due in May 2017.
-
- Posts: 13356
- Joined: Tue Mar 23, 2010 1:45 pm
- Location: Reading, MA
Re: A SUV for towing a Travel Trailer
Are you saying that some vehicles come with no frame?Frisco Kid wrote:One could argue only vehicles with full frames are TRULY designed for towing IMHO.....................
Attempted new signature...
-
- Posts: 18499
- Joined: Tue Dec 31, 2013 6:05 am
- Location: 26 miles, 385 yards west of Copley Square
Re: A SUV for towing a Travel Trailer
YesThe Wizard wrote:Are you saying that some vehicles come with no frame?Frisco Kid wrote:One could argue only vehicles with full frames are TRULY designed for towing IMHO.....................
Explorer, Grand Cherokee and most SUVs are now unibody.
Wheelbase is very important with a tow vwhicle and the longer, the moe stable it will be. I pulled an 18' enclosed racecar trailer wih a Yukon XL and it did great. Also an 18 foot bowrider boat.
Bogle: Smart Beta is stupid
Re: A SUV for towing a Travel Trailer
He is referring to unibody vs body-on-frame construction.The Wizard wrote:Are you saying that some vehicles come with no frame?Frisco Kid wrote:One could argue only vehicles with full frames are TRULY designed for towing IMHO.....................
Brief discussion here: http://www.autotrader.com/car-shopping/ ... ver-245716
Re: A SUV for towing a Travel Trailer
I would be very hesitant about towing a large trailer with a small SUV after what I observed on a mountain road up in Canada one time. I was pulling a 25 foot trailer with a large Dodge Van so I never had any sway problems but on the other side of the road I saw a rig coming down the mountain when all of a sudden the trailer started to sway and then it just wouldn't stop. It got worse and worse until the whole rig flipped over and kept flipping over until it landed in the middle of the highway. To my amazement everyone got out alive but somebody's family vacation was definitely ruined as there was practically nothing left of the trailer. Maybe they made a mistake in their rigging and didn't have sway bars or something but it shook me bad enough to make me question towing with a SUV, at least a small one.
Re: A SUV for towing a Travel Trailer
That is typically caused by improper trailer loading (tongue weight too low). Tongue weight should be 15% of trailer weight to prevent this.invst65 wrote:I would be very hesitant about towing a large trailer with a small SUV after what I observed on a mountain road up in Canada one time. I was pulling a 25 foot trailer with a large Dodge Van so I never had any sway problems but on the other side of the road I saw a rig coming down the mountain when all of a sudden the trailer started to sway and then it just wouldn't stop. It got worse and worse until the whole rig flipped over and kept flipping over until it landed in the middle of the highway. To my amazement everyone got out alive but somebody's family vacation was definitely ruined as there was practically nothing left of the trailer. Maybe they made a mistake in their rigging and didn't have sway bars or something but it shook me bad enough to make me question towing with a SUV, at least a small one.
I had this event with a tiny (8 ft) utility trailer. I hung a load of 12' drywall out of the back of the trailer, such that I had negative tongue weight. At 50 miles an hour it started oscillating and nearly pulled my 5000+ pound Tahoe off the road!!!
[edit] I would never have believed the violence of the oscillation if I hadn't experienced it myself. I would have insisted that it was a gross exaggeration that a ~2000 pound (loaded) utility trailer could throw my truck around like that. Don't mess with tongue weight rules!
Last edited by David Jay on Mon Mar 20, 2017 11:01 am, edited 1 time in total.
It's not an engineering problem - Hersh Shefrin | To get the "risk premium", you really do have to take the risk - nisiprius
Re: A SUV for towing a Travel Trailer
Well, at least you didn't learn a lesson about tongue weight going down the side of a mountain. I felt very sorry for that family. It was harrowing for me just to see it. Couldn't imagine what it must have been like to be in that SUV. It was a small SUV towing a mid-size trailer so I always thought it had something to do with the smaller wheel-base towing the larger one but you might be right about tongue weight - or maybe some combination of the two.David Jay wrote:That is typically caused by improper trailer loading (tongue weight too low). Tongue weight should be 15% of trailer weight to prevent this.invst65 wrote:I would be very hesitant about towing a large trailer with a small SUV after what I observed on a mountain road up in Canada one time. I was pulling a 25 foot trailer with a large Dodge Van so I never had any sway problems but on the other side of the road I saw a rig coming down the mountain when all of a sudden the trailer started to sway and then it just wouldn't stop. It got worse and worse until the whole rig flipped over and kept flipping over until it landed in the middle of the highway. To my amazement everyone got out alive but somebody's family vacation was definitely ruined as there was practically nothing left of the trailer. Maybe they made a mistake in their rigging and didn't have sway bars or something but it shook me bad enough to make me question towing with a SUV, at least a small one.
I had this event with a tiny (8 ft) utility trailer. I hung a load of 12' drywall out of the back of the trailer, such that I had negative tongue weight. At 50 miles an hour it started oscillating and nearly pulled my 5000+ pound Tahoe off the road!!!
-
- Posts: 1329
- Joined: Wed Sep 26, 2012 5:30 pm
Re: A SUV for towing a Travel Trailer
I think you also need to separate what a vehicle can tow 'by the numbers' vs. what it can really do comfortably/safely. Few people drive the speed limit. 3,500-5,000 lbs is not a small trailer. The fact that it comes with trailer brakes confirms as such. Towing that big of a trailer with a unibody SUV, despite the manufacturer's numbers, probably is not the best idea. I'd be looking at a full-size truck (Silverado/Sierra, F1/2/350, Tahoe/Suburban, etc.). A Tahoe is probably 10" longer than you're looking for though.
We ride dirt bikes and quads throughout the warm weather months, trailering hours to the riding spot. 2 friends tow multiple bikes (light), or single quad (heavier), with a 4Runner on a small trailer - no problem. But as soon as the trip either involves multiple quads, and/or pulling campers too (multi-day trip), the full-size trucks are only used.
Beyond unibody vs. BOF, I'd also pay particular attention to the stopping power of the vehicles you're considering. I certainly would not want to be in front of your 4Runner with 5k lb trailer pulling up to stop light that you didn't fully anticipate changing to yellow, and trying to stop with distance to spare. Trailer brake failure or misadjustment is going to be critical when on a vehicle that small. Not worth the risk IMO.
We ride dirt bikes and quads throughout the warm weather months, trailering hours to the riding spot. 2 friends tow multiple bikes (light), or single quad (heavier), with a 4Runner on a small trailer - no problem. But as soon as the trip either involves multiple quads, and/or pulling campers too (multi-day trip), the full-size trucks are only used.
Beyond unibody vs. BOF, I'd also pay particular attention to the stopping power of the vehicles you're considering. I certainly would not want to be in front of your 4Runner with 5k lb trailer pulling up to stop light that you didn't fully anticipate changing to yellow, and trying to stop with distance to spare. Trailer brake failure or misadjustment is going to be critical when on a vehicle that small. Not worth the risk IMO.
- Sandtrap
- Posts: 19590
- Joined: Sat Nov 26, 2016 5:32 pm
- Location: Hawaii No Ka Oi - white sandy beaches, N. Arizona 1 mile high.
Re: A SUV for towing a Travel Trailer
Toyota Fourunner at a minimum. Truck frame. Based on Tacoma. rock solid. Tow vehicle heavier than load adds stability. Truck frame with class II hitch to frame. Avoid unibody SUV. Bigger is better. Tundra. Landcruiser. F150. or Bigger. IMHO based on decades of construction towing large loads. Install a top of the line brake controller and learn how to adjust it per load and condition. Safety is the priority.
Re: A SUV for towing a Travel Trailer
Thanks for all the replies, I appreciate your in put.
I had prepared the (already owned) RX 350 (3500 lbs capacity) with a class III Hitch & a Brake Controller to tow the single axle 17' fiberglass escape trailer with electric brakes, as many are towing with a similar set up of Sienna & Odyssey Vans.
Last month our second vehicle, the trusted Avalon XLS was dented bad, making us look for another Vehicle. We decided to upgrade the Tow Vehicle to have a 5000 lb capacity & plan to move the Hitch & Brake Controller to next Tow vehicle.
Because of our smaller Garage, the vehicles we are looking at are
-2016 Sorento V6 AWD - 5000 lbs capacity
-Jeep Cherokee V6 - 4500 lbs "
- 2013 V6 Highlander Limited - 5000 lbs "
- 4runner -5000 lbs
We have had good luck with Toyotas & are the preferred vehicles in the house hold.
Anything I am missing ? Are there any other SUVs with above details I am not looking at ? Keep your thoughts coming
-I am reading reliability problems with Jeeps,
-Sorento has a lower height hitch receiver causing sagging issues of the rear end
I wish I could buy the larger SUVs with V8s , but may have to park them in the drive way instead of thr Garage
Thanks a lot.
I had prepared the (already owned) RX 350 (3500 lbs capacity) with a class III Hitch & a Brake Controller to tow the single axle 17' fiberglass escape trailer with electric brakes, as many are towing with a similar set up of Sienna & Odyssey Vans.
Last month our second vehicle, the trusted Avalon XLS was dented bad, making us look for another Vehicle. We decided to upgrade the Tow Vehicle to have a 5000 lb capacity & plan to move the Hitch & Brake Controller to next Tow vehicle.
Because of our smaller Garage, the vehicles we are looking at are
-2016 Sorento V6 AWD - 5000 lbs capacity
-Jeep Cherokee V6 - 4500 lbs "
- 2013 V6 Highlander Limited - 5000 lbs "
- 4runner -5000 lbs
We have had good luck with Toyotas & are the preferred vehicles in the house hold.
Anything I am missing ? Are there any other SUVs with above details I am not looking at ? Keep your thoughts coming
-I am reading reliability problems with Jeeps,
-Sorento has a lower height hitch receiver causing sagging issues of the rear end
I wish I could buy the larger SUVs with V8s , but may have to park them in the drive way instead of thr Garage
Thanks a lot.
Re: A SUV for towing a Travel Trailer
Those are 4 very different vehicles. The Highlander has been described as the vehicle for those who need a minivan but want an SUV. My BIL is one of those. It has been a good car but very much a pavement only vehicle in his opinion.
I have rented a 4Runner a few times. It is way to truck like for me. I can't wait to get out after an hour on the Interstate.
I love the ride, handling and capability of the Jeep Grand Cherokee. I really wish the reliability was better.
If you are willing to spend a bit more or get a little older car, you could consider an Ml 350.
I have rented a 4Runner a few times. It is way to truck like for me. I can't wait to get out after an hour on the Interstate.
I love the ride, handling and capability of the Jeep Grand Cherokee. I really wish the reliability was better.
If you are willing to spend a bit more or get a little older car, you could consider an Ml 350.
Re: A SUV for towing a Travel Trailer
A lot of the replies you received weren't applicable to a 17ft Escape, which is much less demanding to tow than many other trailers. I think the OP is looking at an appropriate vehicle. I suggest asking on the rv.net forums, although beware the weight police over there, who would have you heading off to the local Kenworth dealer.
I think it's preferable to get a vehicle with a factory towing package, even that consists of not much more than the 7-pin connector wiring.
I'm not sure I understand the comments about rear end squatting. There should be no squatting with the trailer connected since its weight is fairly equally distributed between the front and rear, and the height of the ball is dependent on how you configure the hitch head.
I think it's preferable to get a vehicle with a factory towing package, even that consists of not much more than the 7-pin connector wiring.
I'm not sure I understand the comments about rear end squatting. There should be no squatting with the trailer connected since its weight is fairly equally distributed between the front and rear, and the height of the ball is dependent on how you configure the hitch head.
- Sandtrap
- Posts: 19590
- Joined: Sat Nov 26, 2016 5:32 pm
- Location: Hawaii No Ka Oi - white sandy beaches, N. Arizona 1 mile high.
Re: A SUV for towing a Travel Trailer
Highlander .. no frame/unibody .. . . light . . . comfy when not towing
4runner . . . frame, solid platform that tow hitch is attached to .. . heavier.. . stable when towing . . . beefier when not towing
Toyota reliability and value.
4runner . . . frame, solid platform that tow hitch is attached to .. . heavier.. . stable when towing . . . beefier when not towing
Toyota reliability and value.
Re: A SUV for towing a Travel Trailer
You don't want to tow 3k plus pounds with a unibody vehicle. Get the 4Runner.
Reliable, good on and off-road. Will run forever if properly maintained.
Reliable, good on and off-road. Will run forever if properly maintained.
Re: A SUV for towing a Travel Trailer
What was your (bad, I assume) towing with a unibody vehicle? I towed several trailers with unibody vehicles, and while I wouldn't have towed the rated maximum 7000lbs, I wouldn't hesitate to tow 4000lbs with them, at least not a reasonably aerodynamic 4000lbs like the trailer in question. I would have wanted more power for high-elevation mountain towing, but didn't have the largest available engines in those vehicles.pyld76 wrote:You don't want to tow 3k plus pounds with a unibody vehicle. Get the 4Runner.
Reliable, good on and off-road. Will run forever if properly maintained.
- sunny_socal
- Posts: 2732
- Joined: Tue Mar 24, 2015 4:22 pm
Re: A SUV for towing a Travel Trailer
Another vote for the 4runner. Any vehicle will work when on a flat freeway, but wait until you're climbing some real hills! Even my 5.7L Tundra starts to break a sweat (and my trailer is also 4k pounds.) Many would tell me to get a diesel instead
Re: A SUV for towing a Travel Trailer
Even with a WD hitch and sway bars, had hellacious problems with wheel spin off the line and sway at speed with a Honda odessy. Ditto a Toyota RAV4, although the scary thing about the latter was getting things stopped and finding one of the hitch mount bolts ostensibly sheared.tibbitts wrote: What was your (bad, I assume) towing with a unibody vehicle? I towed several trailers with unibody vehicles, and while I wouldn't have towed the rated maximum 7000lbs, I wouldn't hesitate to tow 4000lbs with them, at least not a reasonably aerodynamic 4000lbs like the trailer in question. I would have wanted more power for high-elevation mountain towing, but didn't have the largest available engines in those vehicles.
Both loads subsequently pulled with a family member's (ironically) 4Runner absent incident.
Not implying unibody construction won't tow. I simply wouldn't do it regularly. A body on frame SUV or truck knocks these problems aside...
Re: A SUV for towing a Travel Trailer
I can definitely relate because I had a similar experience when a friend asked me to relieve him for a while while towing something with a trailer. The violence of it was downright scary. The natural instinct is to slow down but that's probably the wrong thing to do. Hitting the gas, if possible, would have probably made more sense. Going down the side of a mountain like the family in my OP, that would have probably been even harder to do.David Jay wrote: [edit] I would never have believed the violence of the oscillation if I hadn't experienced it myself. I would have insisted that it was a gross exaggeration that a ~2000 pound (loaded) utility trailer could throw my truck around like that. Don't mess with tongue weight rules!
Re: A SUV for towing a Travel Trail
Weatherbug and RadarScope.
- Sandtrap
- Posts: 19590
- Joined: Sat Nov 26, 2016 5:32 pm
- Location: Hawaii No Ka Oi - white sandy beaches, N. Arizona 1 mile high.
Re: A SUV for towing a Travel Trailer
Here's some perspective for towing ease and safety. I live in high mountain cattle country. The most common tow vehicle whether for 5th wheel, RV, cattle trailer, and everything else, is a 1 ton dually pickup diesel with a Cummins or Duramax engine. Why? Weight, power, stability, safety, reliability. As a general rule, the heavier and longer wheelbase the tow vehicle in relation to the load, the better. Yes. Someone can rent a UHaul trailer and tow it with nearly anything undersized, but is it optimal?
We've all seen trailers towed with a bumper mounted hitch on something as small as a Honda Civic. Will it work? Sure. So the options are wide for everyone.
We've all seen trailers towed with a bumper mounted hitch on something as small as a Honda Civic. Will it work? Sure. So the options are wide for everyone.
Re: A SUV for towing a Travel Trailer
+1 for the 4Runner. They're built like a tank-----and the resale value on them is incredible:
http://www.autoguide.com/auto-news/2017 ... -2017.html
http://www.autoguide.com/auto-news/2017 ... -2017.html
I know you think you understand what you thought I said but I'm not sure you realize that what you heard is not what I meant. - Alan Greenspan
Re: A SUV for towing a Travel Trailer
While a vehicle like a 1 ton dually truck, all the way up through a class 8, could certainly tow a 17ft Escape, they wouldn't be the most suitable. The Escape would likely weigh around 2800-3000lbs loaded for travel, and has relatively little wind resistance compared to a typical box-like trailer. With a few modifications a 1-ton truck would be capable of carrying the trailer - and 1-ton duallies are definitely appropriate for carrying truck campers, which are a similar size.Sandtrap wrote:Here's some perspective for towing ease and safety. I live in high mountain cattle country. The most common tow vehicle whether for 5th wheel, RV, cattle trailer, and everything else, is a 1 ton dually pickup diesel with a Cummins or Duramax engine. Why? Weight, power, stability, safety, reliability. As a general rule, the heavier and longer wheelbase the tow vehicle in relation to the load, the better. Yes. Someone can rent a UHaul trailer and tow it with nearly anything undersized, but is it optimal?
We've all seen trailers towed with a bumper mounted hitch on something as small as a Honda Civic. Will it work? Sure. So the options are wide for everyone.
Re: A SUV for towing a Travel Trailer
The OP has a potential trailer that will be fully loaded at 3,200 # , he wants a suitable tow vehicle with at least a 5,000 # capacity.
Sounds very logical and safe to me.
No need for huge vehicles if the two vehicle is suet up correctly and the trailer and tongue weight is correct.
I have a Ford Dually with a diesel and its way more truck then required for this load, even my Chevy 1500 is overkill for this bit would work fine.
Sounds very logical and safe to me.
No need for huge vehicles if the two vehicle is suet up correctly and the trailer and tongue weight is correct.
I have a Ford Dually with a diesel and its way more truck then required for this load, even my Chevy 1500 is overkill for this bit would work fine.
Re: A SUV for towing a Travel Trailer
OP..you never want to tow with a vehicle where you're even close to maxing out the towing capacity. Towing that 17 Escape with a Sienna or Odyssey..yikes..I'll pass. Being able to just tow a trailer is one thing, being able to control the trailer is different..and more of a safety issue. If you've ever towed in difficult conditions(high wind, rain..) you tend to understand what "control" means.
Google "tow trailer calculator". You'll find all kinds of guides to bounce your numbers off of.
Out of the vehicles you've listed..I go with the 4-Runner (disclosure..I run a Sequoia for towing). If you can find a 4th generation 4-Runner it came with the 4.7L V8. V8 towing MPG will be about the same as pushing a smaller, towing V6 harder. Keep an eye on the 4th-gen V8 timing belt change when recommended. Other than that..great vehicle.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Toyota_4Runner
2009 Toyota 4Runner Sport V8
Sport utility vehicle
Model: 2009 Toyota 4Runner
Towing capacity: 7,000 to 7,300 lbs
MPG: Up to 15 city / 19 highway
Horsepower: 260 hp
Curb weight: 4,280 to 4,530 lbs
Torque: 306 lb-ft
Dimensions: 189″ L x 75″ W x 69-71″ H
Google "tow trailer calculator". You'll find all kinds of guides to bounce your numbers off of.
Out of the vehicles you've listed..I go with the 4-Runner (disclosure..I run a Sequoia for towing). If you can find a 4th generation 4-Runner it came with the 4.7L V8. V8 towing MPG will be about the same as pushing a smaller, towing V6 harder. Keep an eye on the 4th-gen V8 timing belt change when recommended. Other than that..great vehicle.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Toyota_4Runner
2009 Toyota 4Runner Sport V8
Sport utility vehicle
Model: 2009 Toyota 4Runner
Towing capacity: 7,000 to 7,300 lbs
MPG: Up to 15 city / 19 highway
Horsepower: 260 hp
Curb weight: 4,280 to 4,530 lbs
Torque: 306 lb-ft
Dimensions: 189″ L x 75″ W x 69-71″ H
- Sandtrap
- Posts: 19590
- Joined: Sat Nov 26, 2016 5:32 pm
- Location: Hawaii No Ka Oi - white sandy beaches, N. Arizona 1 mile high.
Re: A SUV for towing a Travel Trailer
Yep. There's that Toyota 4Runner agin'. It'll work fer sure. . . .smitcat wrote:The OP has a potential trailer that will be fully loaded at 3,200 # , he wants a suitable tow vehicle with at least a 5,000 # capacity.
Sounds very logical and safe to me.
No need for huge vehicles if the two vehicle is suet up correctly and the trailer and tongue weight is correct.
I have a Ford Dually with a diesel and its way more truck then required for this load, even my Chevy 1500 is overkill for this bit would work fine.
But course there's trucks n then there's trucks if a fella is a truck fella. N' that Ford Dually you're ridin' is mighty nice indeed. King Ranch is a nice one.
Re: A SUV for towing a Travel Trailer
I agree with the towing package.tibbitts wrote:A lot of the replies you received weren't applicable to a 17ft Escape, which is much less demanding to tow than many other trailers. I think the OP is looking at an appropriate vehicle. I suggest asking on the rv.net forums, although beware the weight police over there, who would have you heading off to the local Kenworth dealer.
I think it's preferable to get a vehicle with a factory towing package, even that consists of not much more than the 7-pin connector wiring.
I'm not sure I understand the comments about rear end squatting. There should be no squatting with the trailer connected since its weight is fairly equally distributed between the front and rear, and the height of the ball is dependent on how you configure the hitch head.
I'm not an expert...but I have turned nice looking transmission fluid black by overdoing it with trailers...because I didn't have a transmission cooler.
I don't know if all towing packages have as many features as this article lays out...
http://www.boatus.com/magazine/traileri ... or-not.asp
It's already been said...but pulling a trailer is serious business....I'm sure you'll do your homework. I've had riders that wanted me to go ahead and drive 70-75 miles an hour with a trailer.
Re: A SUV for towing a Travel Trailer
+1. I would only consider the 4Runner with the V8 for towing, the new V6 ones are only rated to 5,000 lbs and I wouldn't feel comfortable towing over 3k lbs with that. You could look at a Tundra or Sequoia also.fishboat wrote:OP..you never want to tow with a vehicle where you're even close to maxing out the towing capacity. Towing that 17 Escape with a Sienna or Odyssey..yikes..I'll pass. Being able to just tow a trailer is one thing, being able to control the trailer is different..and more of a safety issue. If you've ever towed in difficult conditions(high wind, rain..) you tend to understand what "control" means.
Google "tow trailer calculator". You'll find all kinds of guides to bounce your numbers off of.
Out of the vehicles you've listed..I go with the 4-Runner (disclosure..I run a Sequoia for towing). If you can find a 4th generation 4-Runner it came with the 4.7L V8. V8 towing MPG will be about the same as pushing a smaller, towing V6 harder. Keep an eye on the 4th-gen V8 timing belt change when recommended. Other than that..great vehicle.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Toyota_4Runner
2009 Toyota 4Runner Sport V8
Sport utility vehicle
Model: 2009 Toyota 4Runner
Towing capacity: 7,000 to 7,300 lbs
MPG: Up to 15 city / 19 highway
Horsepower: 260 hp
Curb weight: 4,280 to 4,530 lbs
Torque: 306 lb-ft
Dimensions: 189″ L x 75″ W x 69-71″ H
-
- Posts: 1294
- Joined: Thu Mar 12, 2015 7:05 pm
Re: A SUV for towing a Travel Trailer
The OP intends to pull a 3,000lb fiberglass travel trailer with trailer brakes...emoore wrote:+1. I would only consider the 4Runner with the V8 for towing, the new V6 ones are only rated to 5,000 lbs and I wouldn't feel comfortable towing over 3k lbs with that. You could look at a Tundra or Sequoia also.
This is 40% LESS than the max tow rating of the vehicles he is considering.
Why are so many people recommending vehicles with tow ratings of 7,500 - 20,000+ lbs? This is complete overkill.
There is no reason to purchase a vehicle with 3X or 5X the needed towing capacity.
Re: A SUV for towing a Travel Trailer
It's just my opinion but I would aim for at least 2X towing capacity but I live near the mountains and would need the extra capacity to go up steep grades.researcher wrote:The OP intends to pull a 3,000lb fiberglass travel trailer with trailer brakes...emoore wrote:+1. I would only consider the 4Runner with the V8 for towing, the new V6 ones are only rated to 5,000 lbs and I wouldn't feel comfortable towing over 3k lbs with that. You could look at a Tundra or Sequoia also.
This is 40% LESS than the max tow rating of the vehicles he is considering.
Why are so many people recommending vehicles with tow ratings of 7,500 - 20,000+ lbs? This is complete overkill.
There is no reason to purchase a vehicle with 3X or 5X the needed towing capacity.
Re: A SUV for towing a Travel Trailer
With the right tow vehicle you can do that.hudson wrote:I've had riders that wanted me to go ahead and drive 70-75 miles an hour with a trailer.
Re: A SUV for towing a Travel Trailer
No, most trailer tires are only rated for 65mph.Luke Duke wrote:With the right tow vehicle you can do that.hudson wrote:I've had riders that wanted me to go ahead and drive 70-75 miles an hour with a trailer.
Re: A SUV for towing a Travel Trailer
Hill climbing ability tends to be one of the least important aspects of towing. You can just choose to go slower uphill, as long as you can maintain the minimum legal speed. Most large trucks climb hills relatively slowly due to the weight they're pulling. They could be designed to climb faster, but aren't. On the other hand, factors like loads on suspension, wheels, and bearings can be more of a safety concern, and those are what's important to keep well within specifications. I would say that more than 2x for those factors would be overkill, but moderate extra margin would be a good idea.emoore wrote:It's just my opinion but I would aim for at least 2X towing capacity but I live near the mountains and would need the extra capacity to go up steep grades.researcher wrote:The OP intends to pull a 3,000lb fiberglass travel trailer with trailer brakes...emoore wrote:+1. I would only consider the 4Runner with the V8 for towing, the new V6 ones are only rated to 5,000 lbs and I wouldn't feel comfortable towing over 3k lbs with that. You could look at a Tundra or Sequoia also.
This is 40% LESS than the max tow rating of the vehicles he is considering.
Why are so many people recommending vehicles with tow ratings of 7,500 - 20,000+ lbs? This is complete overkill.
There is no reason to purchase a vehicle with 3X or 5X the needed towing capacity.
Re: A SUV for towing a Travel Trailer
A mid-sized SUV with a 5,000 lbs towing capacity and actually being a good idea are two different things. We have a 20 foot boat and I can't imagine towing it with our Highlander especially up/down hills or mountains. It would tear up the transmission and if you have to stop suddenly, the pucker factor would be high. Anything over 3,000 lbs I would strongly consider a truck or a Tahoe. If you live in a place like Florida where the roads are flat and in good shape you might be OK. However, if you ever tow in hills or mountains, windy conditions, winding roads, etc. you'll be thankful to have a truck or larger SUV.
Depending on how often you tow, maybe buy the small SUV for a daily driver and rent a truck for towing. Also, are you sure the trailer is only 3,200 lbs? How much will it weigh fully loaded? Add 20% as a fudge factor.
Depending on how often you tow, maybe buy the small SUV for a daily driver and rent a truck for towing. Also, are you sure the trailer is only 3,200 lbs? How much will it weigh fully loaded? Add 20% as a fudge factor.
- Sandtrap
- Posts: 19590
- Joined: Sat Nov 26, 2016 5:32 pm
- Location: Hawaii No Ka Oi - white sandy beaches, N. Arizona 1 mile high.
Re: A SUV for towing a Travel Trailer
Also consider what happens when the tow vehicle has a short wheelbase.
Of your selection. 4Runner. Not ideal but certainly a wonderful vehicle. In 4wd, added fun when not towing. An exploration vehicle
Will a Tacoma pickup fit in your garage?
Of your selection. 4Runner. Not ideal but certainly a wonderful vehicle. In 4wd, added fun when not towing. An exploration vehicle
Will a Tacoma pickup fit in your garage?
-
- Posts: 1294
- Joined: Thu Mar 12, 2015 7:05 pm
Re: A SUV for towing a Travel Trailer
You must have missed it...chmcnm wrote:A mid-sized SUV with a 5,000 lbs towing capacity and actually being a good idea are two different things...
and if you have to stop suddenly, the pucker factor would be high.
If you live in a place like Florida where the roads are flat and in good shape you might be OK.
Also, are you sure the trailer is only 3,200 lbs? How much will it weigh fully loaded? Add 20% as a fudge factor.
- The OP's trailer has trailer brakes.
- The OP lives in Florida.
- Even adding 20%, the trailer is still well below the rated towing capacity of vehicles he is considering.
Re: A SUV for towing a Travel Trailer
I didn't miss anything. I know he's from Florida. They have flat, good roads mostly but they still get wind and rain which can cause problems. You still have to pull onto highways. Who says he will always stay in Florida. The point of having a travel trailer is to travel.researcher wrote:You must have missed it...chmcnm wrote:A mid-sized SUV with a 5,000 lbs towing capacity and actually being a good idea are two different things...
and if you have to stop suddenly, the pucker factor would be high.
If you live in a place like Florida where the roads are flat and in good shape you might be OK.
Also, are you sure the trailer is only 3,200 lbs? How much will it weigh fully loaded? Add 20% as a fudge factor.
- The OP's trailer has trailer brakes.
- The OP lives in Florida.
- Even adding 20%, the trailer is still well below the rated towing capacity of vehicles he is considering.
Trailer brakes are very nice but that doesn't make up for a short wheelbase, less stability, and less horsepower. The towing weight capacity is a recommendation only and I've seen plenty of people who "think" their trailer/boat weighs XYZ but it's XYZ+ and it might be unbalanced. Not good for safety. Just because my speedometer goes to 120mph doesn't mean I should.
Most people overestimate their driving ability, especially when it comes to towing. Most of the time it goes well. Be smart and take your time. However, when you're rolling down a hill/mountain at 65mph and you have to lock-em up because someone pulls out too close you'll really appreciate a larger, more stable vehicle. After taking a look through the thread again, there's a lot of good advice...from people who've ACTUALLY towed with their vehicles. Seems like almost all would recommend against a smallish SUV. Good luck. YMMV.
Of the cars you've listed I'd choose the 4Runner. I'm biased for Toyota's. We have a Highlander and a Tundra. You could always rent a truck or large SUV for towing if you only do it a few times a year.
Last edited by chmcnm on Thu Mar 23, 2017 2:28 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Re: A SUV for towing a Travel Trailer
+1chmcnm wrote: I didn't miss anything. I know he's from Florida. They have flat, good roads mostly but they still get wind and rain which can cause problems. You still have to pull onto highways. Who says he will always stay in Florida. The point of having a travel trailer is to travel.
Trailer brakes are very nice but that doesn't make up for a short wheelbase, less stability, and less horsepower. The towing weight capacity is a recommendation only and I've seen plenty of people who "think" their trailer/boat weighs XYZ but it's XYZ+ and it might be unbalanced. Not good for safety. Just because my speedometer goes to 120mph doesn't mean I should.
Most people overestimate their driving ability, especially when it comes to towing. Most of the time it goes well. Be smart and take your time. However, when you're rolling down a hill/mountain at 65mph and you have to lock-em up because someone pulls out too close you'll really appreciate a larger, more stable vehicle. Good luck. YMMV.
One other consideration that many tend to gloss over is the gross vehicle weight ratings and specifically the cargo or payload weight rating of marginal tow vehicles. Payload weight is often in the 1000-1300 pounds range (unless you go to a larger vehicle). Payload is comprised of tongue weight, fuel, people, gear...it adds up fast.