Effective Tax rate poll
Effective Tax rate poll
I thought it would be fun to post a poll question on effective tax rate. I'm sure it's been done before, but it's been lost in time and files, so I'll start it again. Our personal effective rate of return is according to TT is 9.53%. Our joint return AGI was $92,309. for 2010. Enjoy.
Even educators need education. And some can be hard headed to the point of needing time out.

 Posts: 12073
 Joined: Fri Sep 18, 2009 1:10 am
The definition of the denominator is much more troubling. To livesoft's list above, I would add taxexempt interest, untaxed social security (you can see I must be older than livesoft), and the $3000 deduction you take for carryover capital losses. Just because you didn't pay tax on it or you got a deduction to offset it, doesn't mean it wasn't income.letsgobobby wrote:how do you calculate this? Assume numerator is Total federal income tax/AMT owed?
The effective tax rate shown by Turbo Tax is Total Tax divided by Adjusted Gross Income. It's not your marginal tax rate.
Effective tax rate is your total tax owed divided by your total income. Check the math and see if you get what Turbo Tax generates. Mine works that way.
Effective tax rate is your total tax owed divided by your total income. Check the math and see if you get what Turbo Tax generates. Mine works that way.
Even educators need education. And some can be hard headed to the point of needing time out.

 Posts: 7184
 Joined: Sun Dec 16, 2007 12:25 pm
You might get more responses if you would be specific. AGI and your "total income" are two different lines on form 1040. Line 37 & line 22. Which do you want to use? Or something else? I don't have turbotax.rustymutt wrote: The effective tax rate shown by Turbo Tax is Total Tax divided by Adjusted Gross Income. It's not your marginal tax rate.
Effective tax rate is your total tax owed divided by your total income. Check the math and see if you get what Turbo Tax generates. Mine works that way.
JW
 market timer
 Posts: 6350
 Joined: Tue Aug 21, 2007 1:42 am

 Posts: 2522
 Joined: Fri Nov 20, 2009 2:39 pm
 ruralavalon
 Posts: 19417
 Joined: Sat Feb 02, 2008 10:29 am
 Location: Illinois
http://financialdictionary.thefreedict ... e+tax+rate .
(emphasis added).Effective tax rate
The net rate a taxpayer pays on income that includes all forms of taxes. It is calculated by dividing the total tax paid by taxable income.
Copyright © 2004, Campbell R. Harvey. All Rights Reserved.

Effective Tax Rate
The tax rate one pays assuming that one pays a flat rate rather than under a progressive system. Under progressive tax systems, one pays different rates for different amounts in income. For example, one may pay 10% for the first $10,000 of income and 25% for all additional income. In practice this means that one would pay somewhere between 10% and 25%. One calculates the effective tax rate simply by taking the total tax liability, dividing by one's taxable income and multiplying by 100.Suppose one makes $20,000 in a year and is taxed under the above system. This person pays $1000 (10%) of the first $10,000 and 2500 (25%) of the second $10,000. The total tax liability is $3500, which when divided by the $20,000 of income and multiplied 100, is found to have an effective tax rate of 17.5%.
"Everything should be as simple as it is, but not simpler."  Albert Einstein 
Wiki article link:Getting Started

 Posts: 158
 Joined: Mon Jul 07, 2008 10:15 pm
Early 30's solid middleclass "professionals", one RN in a public hospital and one Business Analyst for Fortune 100 financial services company, no kids (which I think makes the below number all the more impressive considering our parentfriendly tax code).
I go with what TurboTax tells us because it's easy and I like the looks of it.
For 2010 it said 7.21%. In straightup gross income we're hanging around the middle of the 25% marginal tax bracket, but subtract the standard exemption, two maxedout retirement plans, itemized deductions (mortgage interest/property taxes, student loan interest), the $1500 energy efficiency credit, and here we are.
I go with what TurboTax tells us because it's easy and I like the looks of it.
For 2010 it said 7.21%. In straightup gross income we're hanging around the middle of the 25% marginal tax bracket, but subtract the standard exemption, two maxedout retirement plans, itemized deductions (mortgage interest/property taxes, student loan interest), the $1500 energy efficiency credit, and here we are.

 Posts: 2237
 Joined: Wed Feb 03, 2010 10:17 am
Mine is certainly above 15%. It is more in the mid to high 20% range. Not having any kids or itemized deductions will do that to you, especially when your income is considered to be in the "rich" category by some of those who draft the tax laws. Federal income tax alone is higher than my yearly living expenses, which just seems wrong to me. Add in social security, Medicare, sales, and all the various user fees, and the bill is just headshakingly high to me.

 Posts: 12073
 Joined: Fri Sep 18, 2009 1:10 am
0%, but an ankle broken in three places, a tooth implant, and a new heat pump isn't the most fun way to achieve this milestone. I see the last and only other time it was 0% was 1965 on an AGI of $382.
This year is looking to be 0% again, without the extra incentives, thanks to a careful mix of SS and IRA withdrawals.
This year is looking to be 0% again, without the extra incentives, thanks to a careful mix of SS and IRA withdrawals.
Retired 
Twotime in top10 in Bogleheads S&P500 contest; 14time loser
 fishnskiguy
 Posts: 2604
 Joined: Tue Feb 27, 2007 1:27 pm
 Location: Sedona, AZ

 Posts: 134
 Joined: Tue Aug 21, 2007 11:26 am
Effective Tax Rate 0.30% (per TurboTax).. and I even got to make very productive use of the zero capital gains rate!
 White Coat Investor
 Posts: 14828
 Joined: Fri Mar 02, 2007 9:11 pm
 Location: Greatest Snow On Earth
I was feeling good that mine was only 15.7% this year. Now I realize I'm in the top category of the poll. And that's not even counting payroll taxes or state taxes...or sales taxes....or property taxes
1) Invest you must 2) Time is your friend 3) Impulse is your enemy 
4) Basic arithmetic works 5) Stick to simplicity 6) Stay the course
Looking at the responses, it is clear that there should have been more categories above 15%. Right now, over 50% are in the over 15% category (38/75).
So now the question becomes, who has the highest effective tax rate?
Mine is 19.0%, but I sure that some of our friends are over 20% or even 25%. Where are all those AMT people when we need them?
But since people are using three different denominators, line 22 (total income), line 37 (AGI), and line 43 (taxable income), the results are not very meaningful. Using the smallest denominator (line 43 for most folks) gives you the highest effective tax rate.
For those with a taxable income of zero, what is zero divided by zero?
So now the question becomes, who has the highest effective tax rate?
Mine is 19.0%, but I sure that some of our friends are over 20% or even 25%. Where are all those AMT people when we need them?
But since people are using three different denominators, line 22 (total income), line 37 (AGI), and line 43 (taxable income), the results are not very meaningful. Using the smallest denominator (line 43 for most folks) gives you the highest effective tax rate.
For those with a taxable income of zero, what is zero divided by zero?
SmartMoney Magazine Term of the Month
SmartMoney magazine includes a "Term of the Month" in each issue. The April 2009 issue was effective tax rate. It is too lengthy to type out, but it boils down to dividing the amount you paid in taxes by your taxable income (i.e., Form 1040 line 46 divided by line 43). Mine is 16% for 2010 as a retiree.
Tom D.
A few more income categories:sscritic wrote:But since people are using three different denominators, line 22 (total income), line 37 (AGI), and line 43 (taxable income), the results are not very meaningful. Using the smallest denominator (line 43 for most folks) gives you the highest effective tax rate.
Pretax income (not shown on 1040) including employer match to 401(k)
Off the books income (pizza anyone?)
Free or subsidized meals and housing
Taxexempt income
Maybe total income should come from Form 1116 Line 3e?
 market timer
 Posts: 6350
 Joined: Tue Aug 21, 2007 1:42 am
I used TurboTax this year and the only way I can make the numbers match their reported effective tax rate is to divide my tax on line 44 (not including the additional AMT on line 45, and not my "total tax" on line 46) by my AGI on line 37 (not by my taxable income on line 43).
The usual way I calculate it myself is to add up ALL of the money we get (adding back the $22K contribution to my wife's 401K, the money we put in a pretax flexible spending account, and the pretax savings on our health insurance) and use that as the denominator, instead of AGI or taxable income. The numerator is simply the federal income tax we pay.
Eric
The usual way I calculate it myself is to add up ALL of the money we get (adding back the $22K contribution to my wife's 401K, the money we put in a pretax flexible spending account, and the pretax savings on our health insurance) and use that as the denominator, instead of AGI or taxable income. The numerator is simply the federal income tax we pay.
Eric

 Posts: 7501
 Joined: Mon Dec 17, 2007 7:32 pm
I agree. I wish my effective tax rate was higher.livesoft wrote:You should feel very very good because you are in the top category of the poll.EmergDoc wrote:I was feeling good that mine was only 15.7% this year. Now I realize I'm in the top category of the poll. And that's not even counting payroll taxes or state taxes...or sales taxes....or property taxes
same here, 15.7% and exactly same feelings...EmergDoc wrote:I was feeling good that mine was only 15.7% this year. Now I realize I'm in the top category of the poll. And that's not even counting payroll taxes or state taxes...or sales taxes....or property taxes
was kind of happy before read this poll
 House Blend
 Posts: 4761
 Joined: Fri May 04, 2007 1:02 pm
Regarding effective tax rates, consider a single yuppie with a simple financial profile:
wage and interest income;
no dependents;
standard deduction;
all retirement investing is taxdeferred or in a Roth;
no qualified dividends or foreign tax credits or capital gains/losses.
With $66K in taxable wages plus interest for 2010, she'll have an exemption of $3650 and a standard deduction of $5700, leaving her with a taxable income of $56650. Solidly in the middle of the 25% bracket.
She'll owe $10343.75 in income tax, but qualifies for a $400 Making Work Pay tax credit, for a net tax of $9943.75 and an effective tax rate of 15.1%.
Enough to put her in the top category in this poll.
wage and interest income;
no dependents;
standard deduction;
all retirement investing is taxdeferred or in a Roth;
no qualified dividends or foreign tax credits or capital gains/losses.
With $66K in taxable wages plus interest for 2010, she'll have an exemption of $3650 and a standard deduction of $5700, leaving her with a taxable income of $56650. Solidly in the middle of the 25% bracket.
She'll owe $10343.75 in income tax, but qualifies for a $400 Making Work Pay tax credit, for a net tax of $9943.75 and an effective tax rate of 15.1%.
Enough to put her in the top category in this poll.