Do you diversify into international bond?
Do you diversify into international bond?
Hi all
I've been weighing my options of adding international bond to further diversify my bond holdings.
Vanguard seems to have published a few articles 'selling' the neccessity of hedging the currency exposure for max diversification benefits. Appears to me they're inherently 'selling' their ETF BNDX - Vanguard Total International Bond ETF. I wonder if an FX hedged bond would just give you a risk-return very similar to a US domestic bond?
https://advisors.vanguard.com/VGApp/iip ... gGlblBonds
I've been searching around market and seems neither PICB - International Corporate Bond Portfolio nor IBND - SPDR Barclays Capital International Corporate Bond ETF are currency hedged.
Sooooo, questions -
1) Do you hold international bonds? If so, hedged or not and which particular instrument?
2) If any of my understandings above are wrong? (A being: FX hedged intl bond gives US-like return; B being both PICB/IBND are not currency hedged)
Appreciate your thoughts! Many thanks!
RC
I've been weighing my options of adding international bond to further diversify my bond holdings.
Vanguard seems to have published a few articles 'selling' the neccessity of hedging the currency exposure for max diversification benefits. Appears to me they're inherently 'selling' their ETF BNDX - Vanguard Total International Bond ETF. I wonder if an FX hedged bond would just give you a risk-return very similar to a US domestic bond?
https://advisors.vanguard.com/VGApp/iip ... gGlblBonds
I've been searching around market and seems neither PICB - International Corporate Bond Portfolio nor IBND - SPDR Barclays Capital International Corporate Bond ETF are currency hedged.
Sooooo, questions -
1) Do you hold international bonds? If so, hedged or not and which particular instrument?
2) If any of my understandings above are wrong? (A being: FX hedged intl bond gives US-like return; B being both PICB/IBND are not currency hedged)
Appreciate your thoughts! Many thanks!
RC
Re: Do you diversify into international bond?
I'm gradually accumulating Dodge and Cox Global Bond Fund (mostly corporate US and international bonds including emerging markets) paired with the US government bond fund in the federal employee retirement plan (G Fund). I believe this combination will outperform US Total Bond Market Fund with greater diversification and less risk. I am not a fan of market cap indexing in bond funds. "Invest in the biggest debtors" doesn't make sense to me either domestically or globally.
70/30 AA for life, Global market cap equity. Rebalance if fixed income <25% or >35%. Weighted ER< .10%. 5% of annual portfolio balance SWR, Proportional (to AA) withdrawals.
Re: Do you diversify into international bond?
Ben Graham does not recommend international bonds.
Brokerage account-100% stocks |
VG total Market 55% |
VG small cap value 20% |
VG Reit index 25% |
|
TSP Account 75C/25S |
C Fund75%, S25%, |
|
Bonds: U.S. Treasury 5 year Note, 1 year T Bill
- FelixTheCat
- Posts: 2035
- Joined: Sat Sep 24, 2011 12:39 am
Re: Do you diversify into international bond?
Vanguard recommends international bonds. Look at the LifeStrategy Funds.
Felix is a wonderful, wonderful cat.
Re: Do you diversify into international bond?
But Sir, Ben Graham does not recommend international bonds, I take Graham's advice above all.imgritz wrote:Vanguard recommends international bonds. Look at the LifeStrategy Funds.
Brokerage account-100% stocks |
VG total Market 55% |
VG small cap value 20% |
VG Reit index 25% |
|
TSP Account 75C/25S |
C Fund75%, S25%, |
|
Bonds: U.S. Treasury 5 year Note, 1 year T Bill
Re: Do you diversify into international bond?
Minimal to no benefit in the past with added complexity. Total bond is more than enough diversification.
-
- Posts: 312
- Joined: Tue Aug 13, 2013 12:25 am
- Location: Boston, MA
Re: Do you diversify into international bond?
I don't know how much advice you'll be getting out of Benjamin Graham nowadays...riptide wrote:But Sir, Ben Graham does not recommend international bonds, I take Graham's advice above all.imgritz wrote:Vanguard recommends international bonds. Look at the LifeStrategy Funds.
"The problem with diversification is that it works, whether or not we want it to"
-
- Posts: 8421
- Joined: Tue Aug 06, 2013 12:43 pm
Re: Do you diversify into international bond?
All my fixed income is in the 401k and the international bond fund there is actively managed and relatively expensive so even if I thought there were some small benefit I probably wouldn't.
- nisiprius
- Advisory Board
- Posts: 52211
- Joined: Thu Jul 26, 2007 9:33 am
- Location: The terrestrial, globular, planetary hunk of matter, flattened at the poles, is my abode.--O. Henry
Re: Do you diversify into international bond?
I don't use international bonds. The unhedged international bond funds are basically FOREX investments and I'm not interested in investing in FOREX. The hedged funds don't seem to be very different from U.S. bond funds, I don't see any theoretical reason to expect them to be very different. I read Vanguard's Global fixed income: Considerations for U.S. investors paper, full of data and information... and based on their presentation, I came to almost the opposite conclusion. It seemed completely pointless and a completely unnecessary complication.
Sort of like suggesting I should fill my car with a mixture of U.S. and Petro-Canada gasoline in order to get international diversification of my gasoline portfolio.
Sort of like suggesting I should fill my car with a mixture of U.S. and Petro-Canada gasoline in order to get international diversification of my gasoline portfolio.
Annual income twenty pounds, annual expenditure nineteen nineteen and six, result happiness; Annual income twenty pounds, annual expenditure twenty pounds ought and six, result misery.
Re: Do you diversify into international bond?
I just read the paper. Vanguard has convinced me that if I'm going to own international bonds, they should be hedged. They don't seem to have an argument, though, for actually owning international bonds.nisiprius wrote:I read Vanguard's Global fixed income: Considerations for U.S. investors paper, full of data and information... and based on their presentation, I came to almost the opposite conclusion. It seemed completely pointless and a completely unnecessary complication.
The closest thing to an argument comes on page 10 in figure 7. It shows that a 60/40 portfolio has historically had the least amount of volatility with 30% of stocks in international and 100% of bonds in hedged international. Something somewhere has gone very wrong.
The authors of the paper calmly note in the caption to figure seven that "the least-volatile portfolio (highlighted) holds only international bonds for its fixed income portion." They fail to note that this result is also absurd. A US investor should not expect to be able to reduce risk by avoiding US bonds.
Re: Do you diversify into international bond?
They should have also noted that volatility change from 0% to 100% for hedged international bonds is approximately 0.2% for any amount of unhedged international stocks, while the volatility change from 0% to 100% unhedged international stocks is ~1.5% for any amount of hedged bonds. Their argument of lower volatility (0.2%) for owning hedged international bonds is "underwhelming" to say the least.berntson wrote:The closest thing to an argument comes on page 10 in figure 7. It shows that a 60/40 portfolio has historically had the least amount of volatility with 30% of stocks in international and 100% of bonds in hedged international. Something somewhere has gone very wrong.
The authors of the paper calmly note in the caption to figure seven that "the least-volatile portfolio (highlighted) holds only international bonds for its fixed income portion." They fail to note that this result is also absurd. A US investor should not expect to be able to reduce risk by avoiding US bonds.
I no longer hold international bonds. I owned a small amount at one time but when I researched the literature I found the evidence to be weak and replaced them with my US Total Bond index fund. Hedged bonds, to the best of my knowledge, have very similar returns to the US bonds.chasiu209 wrote: Sooooo, questions -
1) Do you hold international bonds? If so, hedged or not and which particular instrument?
2) If any of my understandings above are wrong? (A being: FX hedged intl bond gives US-like return; B being both PICB/IBND are not currency hedged)
Re: Do you diversify into international bond?
I did precisely the same thing. I came to slightly opposite conclusion than Nisi. I.e. There is a small difference. Small.nisiprius wrote:I don't use international bonds. The unhedged international bond funds are basically FOREX investments and I'm not interested in investing in FOREX. The hedged funds don't seem to be very different from U.S. bond funds, I don't see any theoretical reason to expect them to be very different. I read Vanguard's Global fixed income: Considerations for U.S. investors paper, full of data and information... and based on their presentation, I came to almost the opposite conclusion. It seemed completely pointless and a completely unnecessary complication.
Sort of like suggesting I should fill my car with a mixture of U.S. and Petro-Canada gasoline in order to get international diversification of my gasoline portfolio.
Pragmatically low-cost, FOREX hedged funds are not available in my wife's plans nor in nine as a standalone offering . I use institutional extra–low–cost Vanguard Target retirement funds in my plan, Total Bond in wife's. [Vanguard target retirement has hedged international bonds.]
At end of the day it probably doesn't matter much, and probably has the same "spirit" as SCV tilts. Especially with bonds(except high yield) --- they're much less volatile than stock funds, and perform portfolio stabilization duty well.
I'm huge fan of Vanguard target retirement funds, based on their "engineering" whitepaper. International bonds are the cherry on top, not the main course.
I'm often amazed about nitpicking on bond discussions here. It's a very simple duration and risk story to (low-cost) bond fund returns. PIMCO (example) & high-yields take more risk. Bond fund(s) of the appropriate duration are more cost-effective, than the nonsense brokers play in reselling individual bonds to unsuspecting and unsophisticated old people. Like my Mother. Arrgh
Nisi is, however, completely wrong in his gasoline analogy ; North American gasoline is completely fungible (reference my screen name), so:
It's more like mixing Starbuck's & Tim Horton's coffee, just in case one of them has a slight miscalculation in the roasting times of the beans...
Re: Do you diversify into international bond?
Not needed.
Chaz |
|
“Money is better than poverty, if only for financial reasons." Woody Allen |
|
http://www.bogleheads.org/wiki/index.php/Main_Page
-
- Posts: 1125
- Joined: Fri Jul 01, 2011 7:33 pm
Re: Do you diversify into international bond?
+1.chaz wrote:Not needed.
Re: Do you diversify into international bond?
Selling.
The key word on the original post is "selling" and the best way to sell the product was to include it in as many balanced funds as possible. I sold my target retirement fund due to the addition of total international bond. Now, I wrote sometime ago that the total international bond fund could become Vanguard's second largest bond fond in the not so distant future (second only to Total Bond Market Index, VBMFX) due to their "aggressive selling" and just for fun, here are a couple of funds (with the fund total net assets as of 31 July 2014):
- GNMA (VFIIX) - $26.1 billion (inception 6/27/1980)
- Inflation Protected Securities (VIPSX) - $26.3 billion (inception 6/29/2000)
- Total Bond (VBMFX) - $119.3 billion (inception 12/11/86)
- Total International Bond (VTIBX) - $25.9 billion (inception 5/31/2013)
GNMA with $26 billion after 34 years, Inflation Protected Securities with $26 billion after 14 years, and total international bond with $26 billion after only 14 months. Of course other bond funds (not included above) are doing much better, but the question is for how long. Let the "selling" continue, but in my opinion this total international bond fund is not needed in my imperfect SWAN (sleep well at night) portfolio.
Thanks for reading.
The key word on the original post is "selling" and the best way to sell the product was to include it in as many balanced funds as possible. I sold my target retirement fund due to the addition of total international bond. Now, I wrote sometime ago that the total international bond fund could become Vanguard's second largest bond fond in the not so distant future (second only to Total Bond Market Index, VBMFX) due to their "aggressive selling" and just for fun, here are a couple of funds (with the fund total net assets as of 31 July 2014):
- GNMA (VFIIX) - $26.1 billion (inception 6/27/1980)
- Inflation Protected Securities (VIPSX) - $26.3 billion (inception 6/29/2000)
- Total Bond (VBMFX) - $119.3 billion (inception 12/11/86)
- Total International Bond (VTIBX) - $25.9 billion (inception 5/31/2013)
GNMA with $26 billion after 34 years, Inflation Protected Securities with $26 billion after 14 years, and total international bond with $26 billion after only 14 months. Of course other bond funds (not included above) are doing much better, but the question is for how long. Let the "selling" continue, but in my opinion this total international bond fund is not needed in my imperfect SWAN (sleep well at night) portfolio.
Thanks for reading.
~ Member of the Active Retired Force since 2014 ~
- Christine_NM
- Posts: 2796
- Joined: Tue Feb 20, 2007 12:13 am
- Location: New Mexico
Re: Do you diversify into international bond?
Per Strunk & White, omit needless funds. Writing and investing have a lot in common.
16% cash 49% stock 35% bond. Retired, w/d rate 2.5%
-
- Posts: 8421
- Joined: Tue Aug 06, 2013 12:43 pm
Re: Do you diversify into international bond?
That's a great thought but how do you determine with a fund is needless?
Re: Do you diversify into international bond?
I have no money invested in international bonds.
Emotionless, prognostication free investing. Ignoring the noise and economists since 1979. Getting rich off of "smart people's" behavioral mistakes.
Re: Do you diversify into international bond?
I pondered about it, but the higher fees of international bond funds (vs not so great yields/expected returns) stopped me cold. If I were to take a tiny bit more risk on bonds, I'd rather go with more corporate bonds, as John Bogle himself stated multiple times in the recent past. This being said, I keep it simple, VBMFX has ~ 30% corporate, and that sounds good enough.
Hm, funny, I was checking my 30% number to make sure I wasn't saying something stupid, and... VBMFX has 6.6% of foreign bonds. I never noticed! Ok, cool, as long as they keep the low fees...
https://personal.vanguard.com/us/funds/ ... =INT#tab=2
Hm, funny, I was checking my 30% number to make sure I wasn't saying something stupid, and... VBMFX has 6.6% of foreign bonds. I never noticed! Ok, cool, as long as they keep the low fees...
https://personal.vanguard.com/us/funds/ ... =INT#tab=2
Last edited by siamond on Fri Aug 15, 2014 7:24 pm, edited 1 time in total.
- Christine_NM
- Posts: 2796
- Joined: Tue Feb 20, 2007 12:13 am
- Location: New Mexico
Re: Do you diversify into international bond?
Good question. Why start with international bonds just because they are now easy to buy. Greater availability implies to me a stronger correlation with Total Bond in the future. The buyers/sellers of international bonds now overlap the Total Bond buyers/sellers.placeholder wrote:That's a great thought but how do you determine with a fund is needless?
16% cash 49% stock 35% bond. Retired, w/d rate 2.5%
-
- Posts: 8421
- Joined: Tue Aug 06, 2013 12:43 pm
Re: Do you diversify into international bond?
I don't see how ease of purchase implies that at all.
Re: Do you diversify into international bond?
I seek maximum diversity when it is offered at reasonable cost, so moved 20% of my fixed income to international bonds when Vanguard first offered their two funds...would prefer non-hedged but c'est la vie. To those that say this 'adds complexity' and the 'additional costs don't justify' the move, I would note that reconciling my accounts is a 10-minute a week hobby, and would further note that BNDX has outperformed BND substantially over one-year, six-month and 3-month time periods. I am not performance chasing, and haven't changed my allocation since I first invested in the funds...and would be happy with the allocation even if BNDX had underperformed...but it is interesting to note that these two funds do not trade in lockstep at all - there does appear to be some diversification benefit.
Re: Do you diversify into international bond?
My 401K does not even offer an international bond fund. When I started here 20 years ago they didn't even offer international equities. I don't invest in either so it's not a problem for me.
International equities might be worth it, but I really don't see any advantage with international bonds if you are long term index investor.
International equities might be worth it, but I really don't see any advantage with international bonds if you are long term index investor.
Choose Simplicity ~ Stay the Course!! ~ Press on Regardless!!!
-
- Posts: 163
- Joined: Mon Mar 24, 2014 4:02 pm
- Location: South Carolina
Re: Do you diversify into international bond?
I do invest in the VG Total International Bond Index Fund (VTABX). I feel that this provides maximum diversification at a low Expense Ratio of 0.20%.
While this tactic is not necessarily recommended in John Bogle's "Common Sense on Mutual Funds", some current VG advisors are offering it.
Good luck.
While this tactic is not necessarily recommended in John Bogle's "Common Sense on Mutual Funds", some current VG advisors are offering it.
Good luck.
Re: Do you diversify into international bond?
Not yet -- at least as a separate product. There is a small allocation in Total Bond. I don't understand enough about the risks/benefits and need.
At a time of low yields it is tempting to jump into "new" fixed income products -- when I get that feeling I usually move away from the ledge and let others jump. Having been in the mutual fund/brokerage industry for most of my working years I have seen a lot of carnage when people buy "new" products or products that are new to them.
Another factor is that my fixed income is focused on asset preservation/stability not growth or yield. I'd rather go longer in a "safer" CD than put much money into International bonds.
At a time of low yields it is tempting to jump into "new" fixed income products -- when I get that feeling I usually move away from the ledge and let others jump. Having been in the mutual fund/brokerage industry for most of my working years I have seen a lot of carnage when people buy "new" products or products that are new to them.
Another factor is that my fixed income is focused on asset preservation/stability not growth or yield. I'd rather go longer in a "safer" CD than put much money into International bonds.
- ruralavalon
- Posts: 26351
- Joined: Sat Feb 02, 2008 9:29 am
- Location: Illinois
Re: Do you diversify into international bond?
No, we don't use international bonds.
Duration of 6.71 years, extra expense, more complication, and little or no apparent benefit.
Mormimgstsar, "Diversification for the Sake of Diversification".
Duration of 6.71 years, extra expense, more complication, and little or no apparent benefit.
Mormimgstsar, "Diversification for the Sake of Diversification".
"Everything should be as simple as it is, but not simpler." - Albert Einstein |
Wiki article link: Bogleheads® investment philosophy
Re: Do you diversify into international bond?
Yes.chasiu209 wrote: Sooooo, questions -
1) Do you hold international bonds?
Unhedged. 1/3 each of:If so, hedged or not and which particular instrument?
BND (US Total Bond)
EMLC (Emerging Markets)
IGOV (Developed Markets ex-US)
Note: IGOV is only 77% foreign (non-Japan), so 23% of it counts towards my domestic (Japan) bond allocation.
I think those are basically right.2) If any of my understandings above are wrong? (A being: FX hedged intl bond gives US-like return; B being both PICB/IBND are not currency hedged)
Regarding the Vanguard paper, I agree with Nisiprius that the numbers presented in that paper are completely unconvincing of anything. The numbers there shown do not make a strong argument for adding hedged foreign bonds. They do not even make a strong argument against adding unhedged foreign bonds. I also get the feeling, as you say, that they seem to be trying to sell BNDX.
Re: Do you diversify into international bond?
No. I am disappointed with Vanguard for pushing these.
Re: Do you diversify into international bond?
BNDX is up 4.58% ytd vs. 2.66% for BND - yes that's recency bias and has no predictive value, but it does indicate that the two funds do not operate in lockstep, and a (reasonably priced) diversification benefit is available. Rather than being 'disappointed with Vanguard for pushing these,' I am gratified that they have sensibly offered investors the opportunity!
Re: Do you diversify into international bond?
Me too. And people with their all in one funds were forced to buy into them. I don't like those anymore.sdsailing wrote:No. I am disappointed with Vanguard for pushing these.
"Don't trust everything you read on the Internet"- Abraham Lincoln
Re: Do you diversify into international bond?
I wonder if the sentiment/conclusion would be different if Vanguard hasn't forced it to some of our portfolios!denovo wrote:Me too. And people with their all in one funds were forced to buy into them. I don't like those anymore.sdsailing wrote:No. I am disappointed with Vanguard for pushing these.
Re: Do you diversify into international bond?
If I thought market timing worked... I would be selling all my non US bonds based on the fact everyone seems to recommend them now days :-/ I have them as part of my bonds and have close to when they were first available.
|
Rob |
Its a dangerous business going out your front door. - J.R.R.Tolkien
Re: Do you diversify into international bond?
Thanks for all the previous feedback, fellow Bogleheads.
Looks like 90%+ of us don't agree with intl bond allocation.
With recent USD strength, I wonder if the remaining 'supporters' (I have certain allocation for PICB / IBND but never really pull the trigger and buy them) will be backing out..... Indeed PICB and IBND have been performing poorly lately.
Looks like 90%+ of us don't agree with intl bond allocation.
With recent USD strength, I wonder if the remaining 'supporters' (I have certain allocation for PICB / IBND but never really pull the trigger and buy them) will be backing out..... Indeed PICB and IBND have been performing poorly lately.
Re: Do you diversify into international bond?
I pondered about it for a while, but... I don't bother with Int'l Bonds either. I can understand that some people are eager to find better yield out of the US, but the ER is simply too high. And yes, the currency risk goes in the way. Just doesn't seem sensible compared to the fundamental reason to use bonds (e.g. stability). I am a big believer in Int'l diversification, but only for equities (and REITs).