Tesla Motors Stock
-
- Posts: 474
- Joined: Tue Nov 25, 2008 3:34 pm
Tesla Motors Stock
I've decided to set aside some "fun money" to play with an individual stock, specifically Tesla Motors. I looked up Vanguard website first to see if I could get some Tesla shares from it. I have, however, not found any individual Tesla stock at Vanguard; it is usually in funds such as Small Cap ETF.
Can anybody tell me what is the best place in terms of investment fee and cost to buy some Tesla shares?
Many thanks in advance.
Can anybody tell me what is the best place in terms of investment fee and cost to buy some Tesla shares?
Many thanks in advance.
The finest, albeit the most difficult, of all human achievements is being reasonable.
Re: Tesla Motors Stock
Interesting timing, considering it's currently something like 5 times higher than its 52 week low
When I was into stock speculation (which is what you're asking about) I bought at both Schwab and Fidelity. Schwab was very easy to use.

When I was into stock speculation (which is what you're asking about) I bought at both Schwab and Fidelity. Schwab was very easy to use.
Re: Tesla Motors Stock
Posts like this are like nails on a chalk board to me. I cringe every time.
To answer your question you can get Tesla stock by opening any normal taxable brokerage account. Examples are Fidelity, Tradeking, Scottrade etc.
Now that I've answered the question can I please ask why you are going to buy Tesla? I was on vacation last week and I kid you not I talked to at least 4 different people all of whom said they were thinking about buying Tesla. Yes its had big gains buy what makes you think you've divined anything that the thousands of other people (including professional money managers) havn't yet with such a widely publicized company that will give you positive risk adjusted returns.
If you want to gamble on the next stock "pop" you'll probably have a better chance randomly investing in something that hasn't gotten so much publicity in the last 3 months.
If you want a pure high risk high reward play you can at least make a portfolio of high beta stocks to at least work in some semblance of diversification.
To answer your question you can get Tesla stock by opening any normal taxable brokerage account. Examples are Fidelity, Tradeking, Scottrade etc.
Now that I've answered the question can I please ask why you are going to buy Tesla? I was on vacation last week and I kid you not I talked to at least 4 different people all of whom said they were thinking about buying Tesla. Yes its had big gains buy what makes you think you've divined anything that the thousands of other people (including professional money managers) havn't yet with such a widely publicized company that will give you positive risk adjusted returns.
If you want to gamble on the next stock "pop" you'll probably have a better chance randomly investing in something that hasn't gotten so much publicity in the last 3 months.
If you want a pure high risk high reward play you can at least make a portfolio of high beta stocks to at least work in some semblance of diversification.
-
- Posts: 244
- Joined: Wed May 22, 2013 10:02 pm
Re: Tesla Motors Stock
I have a friend that's big into CAN SLIM and he bought TSLA at 102. He says he can get 10% return on his portfolio with no problem...
- BestWishes
- Posts: 83
- Joined: Tue May 07, 2013 10:51 pm
Re: Tesla Motors Stock
My son uses Scottrade. I think $7 per trade. He likes Tesla cars so he bought one share for fun 

Re: Tesla Motors Stock
I work in the automotive field; there is nothing magical about Tesla. The laws of physics have not been overcome, nor will they soon.
"Build it and they will come" does not apply to electric cars.
"Build it and they will come" does not apply to electric cars.
"The tyranny of compounding expenses is the eighth deadly sin." - George Sisti
- InvestorNewb
- Posts: 1578
- Joined: Mon Sep 03, 2012 11:27 am
Re: Tesla Motors Stock
It's pretty crazy that the stock is up 259% year to date. 

My Portfolio: VTI [US], VXUS [Int'l], VNQ [REIT], VCN [Canada] (largest to smallest)
Re: Tesla Motors Stock
The Tesla bubble visualized. Of course, I probably would have said the same thing a few years ago about Apple...long before it deflated. Edit: meaning I have no idea if the stock will keep going higher like Apple did before finally reversing. Good luck.
http://chartianity.wordpress.com/2013/0 ... isualized/
http://chartianity.wordpress.com/2013/0 ... isualized/
Last edited by matjen on Mon Jul 08, 2013 4:55 pm, edited 1 time in total.
A man is rich in proportion to the number of things he can afford to let alone.
Re: Tesla Motors Stock
Exactly why I currently have negative interest in it.InvestorNewb wrote:It's pretty crazy that the stock is up 259% year to date.
In order to get ahead, can't be the last one to the party.
-
- Posts: 474
- Joined: Tue Nov 25, 2008 3:34 pm
Re: Tesla Motors Stock
Thank you pointing me towards Fidelity, Scottrade, etc.SHB wrote:Posts like this are like nails on a chalk board to me. I cringe every time.
To answer your question you can get Tesla stock by opening any normal taxable brokerage account. Examples are Fidelity, Tradeking, Scottrade etc.
Now that I've answered the question can I please ask why you are going to buy Tesla? I was on vacation last week and I kid you not I talked to at least 4 different people all of whom said they were thinking about buying Tesla. Yes its had big gains buy what makes you think you've divined anything that the thousands of other people (including professional money managers) havn't yet with such a widely publicized company that will give you positive risk adjusted returns.
If you want to gamble on the next stock "pop" you'll probably have a better chance randomly investing in something that hasn't gotten so much publicity in the last 3 months.
If you want a pure high risk high reward play you can at least make a portfolio of high beta stocks to at least work in some semblance of diversification.
To answer your question as to why Tesla Motors, I just want to do something fun to celebrate my achievement of financial goal by sticking to boglehead way for past 10 years. I want to feel what it is like to own a "hot" individual stock share, which I have never had in my investing years, then experience the exciting roller-coaster ride it may offer. In addition, I can also have a bragging right as an owner of a "most-talked-about" stock

I appreciate your well-intended warning about stock gambling. No, I do not intend to gamble. I'm going to buy ONE share of Tesla Motors instead of a bottle of excellent wine, then sit back and enjoy its ride

The finest, albeit the most difficult, of all human achievements is being reasonable.
Re: Tesla Motors Stock
Vanguard Capital Opportunity and Vanguard Small Cap Index hold Telsa Motors Stock. Here are some other funds that have holdings in Telsa.
http://investors.morningstar.com/owners ... tml?t=TSLA
http://investors.morningstar.com/owners ... tml?t=TSLA
Re: Tesla Motors Stock
I think optionshouse has the cheapest trades at $4/pop. Only thing cheaper than that is a vanguard brokerage with a half mil sitting in it.
-
- Posts: 474
- Joined: Tue Nov 25, 2008 3:34 pm
Re: Tesla Motors Stock
I'll also look at Optionhouse.brianbooth wrote:I think optionshouse has the cheapest trades at $4/pop. Only thing cheaper than that is a vanguard brokerage with a half mil sitting in it.
Thanks for the info.
The finest, albeit the most difficult, of all human achievements is being reasonable.
Re: Tesla Motors Stock
Indeed, if you want to play the market you can do much better than Tesla. Look for cheap, not overpriced, stocks.WHL wrote:Interesting timing, considering it's currently something like 5 times higher than its 52 week low
Re: Tesla Motors Stock
I bought and sold TSLA - Telsa Stock through Vanguard VBS some weeks back. Don't understand why you can not use Vanguard Brokerage.
I made 46% in six days with my FUN money. IRA. no taxes
edit:
I just checked on Vanguard VBS and TSLA is available for trade on the Brokerage Site.
investor
I made 46% in six days with my FUN money. IRA. no taxes
edit:
I just checked on Vanguard VBS and TSLA is available for trade on the Brokerage Site.
investor
Re: Tesla Motors Stock
I think the P/E on that stock is 100+
-
- Posts: 474
- Joined: Tue Nov 25, 2008 3:34 pm
Re: Tesla Motors Stock
I've found TSLA on Vanguard Brokerage site.investor wrote:I bought and sold TSLA - Telsa Stock through Vanguard VBS some weeks back. Don't understand why you can not use Vanguard Brokerage.
I made 46% in six days with my FUN money. IRA. no taxes
edit:
I just checked on Vanguard VBS and TSLA is available for trade on the Brokerage Site.
investor
Thanks
The finest, albeit the most difficult, of all human achievements is being reasonable.
Re: Tesla Motors Stock
It's nice to have some company!BigHead wrote:Exactly why I currently have negative interest in it.InvestorNewb wrote:It's pretty crazy that the stock is up 259% year to date.
In order to get ahead, can't be the last one to the party.
It's been a rough ride...
-
- Posts: 7501
- Joined: Mon Dec 17, 2007 7:32 pm
Re: Tesla Motors Stock
How much are you thinking of investing? ShareBuilder has some good bonuses for smaller deposits. See: http://www.hustlermoneyblog.com/best-brokerage-bonuses/
Brian
Brian
- fatlittlepig
- Posts: 204
- Joined: Wed May 22, 2013 4:23 pm
Re: Tesla Motors Stock
go for it. buy some now then wait for a pullback and buy more.
oragne lovre wrote:Thank you pointing me towards Fidelity, Scottrade, etc.SHB wrote:Posts like this are like nails on a chalk board to me. I cringe every time.
To answer your question you can get Tesla stock by opening any normal taxable brokerage account. Examples are Fidelity, Tradeking, Scottrade etc.
Now that I've answered the question can I please ask why you are going to buy Tesla? I was on vacation last week and I kid you not I talked to at least 4 different people all of whom said they were thinking about buying Tesla. Yes its had big gains buy what makes you think you've divined anything that the thousands of other people (including professional money managers) havn't yet with such a widely publicized company that will give you positive risk adjusted returns.
If you want to gamble on the next stock "pop" you'll probably have a better chance randomly investing in something that hasn't gotten so much publicity in the last 3 months.
If you want a pure high risk high reward play you can at least make a portfolio of high beta stocks to at least work in some semblance of diversification.
To answer your question as to why Tesla Motors, I just want to do something fun to celebrate my achievement of financial goal by sticking to boglehead way for past 10 years. I want to feel what it is like to own a "hot" individual stock share, which I have never had in my investing years, then experience the exciting roller-coaster ride it may offer. In addition, I can also have a bragging right as an owner of a "most-talked-about" stock![]()
I appreciate your well-intended warning about stock gambling. No, I do not intend to gamble. I'm going to buy ONE share of Tesla Motors instead of a bottle of excellent wine, then sit back and enjoy its ride
fatlittlepig
Re: Tesla Motors Stock
http://www.reuters.com/article/2013/07/ ... FQ20130709
Tesla Motors to replace Oracle Corp on Nasdaq 100 Index.
Currently the stock has all the momo. If one is desperate to own the stock, best way to own is to sell puts below. Atleast one can capture 85% volatility with put selling.
Tesla Motors to replace Oracle Corp on Nasdaq 100 Index.
Currently the stock has all the momo. If one is desperate to own the stock, best way to own is to sell puts below. Atleast one can capture 85% volatility with put selling.
Re: Tesla Motors Stock
Go back and check the threads on the Facebook IPO. I understand fun money investing, but not sure that this will be fun for you. When the hype is through the roof on a stock, why buy into it? Perhaps Tesla will be what Ford or GM were during the golden age of American autos. Perhaps Ford and GM will be the kings of electric...
Re: Tesla Motors Stock
You already own Tesla if you have the Total Stock Market Index Fund. I got lucky with my play money and bought Tesla last December. But they could have easily turned out like Fiskeroragne lovre wrote: To answer your question as to why Tesla Motors, I just want to do something fun to celebrate my achievement of financial goal by sticking to boglehead way for past 10 years. I want to feel what it is like to own a "hot" individual stock share, which I have never had in my investing years, then experience the exciting roller-coaster ride it may offer. In addition, I can also have a bragging right as an owner of a "most-talked-about" stock![]()

Re: Tesla Motors Stock
I own the car (Model S) and the stock. Very happy with both to date. At current valuation would recommend buying the car. Hoping that stock goes down so can buy more.
Re: Tesla Motors Stock
I bought Tesla after reading the article in Consumer Reports. Got lucky and made ~40% and sold (Roth).
When travelling from Seattle to LA on my motorcycle, I came to my senses and thought, they can't even make a motorcycle to run long trips via batteries, how will they make cars?". So I sold it.
I hope I'm wrong and Tesla does indeed live up to its dream.
When travelling from Seattle to LA on my motorcycle, I came to my senses and thought, they can't even make a motorcycle to run long trips via batteries, how will they make cars?". So I sold it.
I hope I'm wrong and Tesla does indeed live up to its dream.
Re: Tesla Motors Stock
I agree.michaelcross wrote: When travelling from Seattle to LA on my motorcycle, I came to my senses and thought, they can't even make a motorcycle to run long trips via batteries, how will they make cars?". So I sold it.
Henry Ford's wife Clara drove an electric car. We face the same limitations today that they faced back then; not much has really changed.
I'll say it again, there is nothing magical about Tesla. The laws of physics have not been overcome, nor will they soon.
"Build it and they will come" does not apply to electric cars.
Everyone makes the mistake of wanting their electric car to perform just like their gasoline car (same range, acceleration, size, cost, safety, comfort). If electric cars become commonplace it will only be the result of the paradigm of our lives, society, and cities being altered. Everything else will have to be adapted to an electric (or more likely, hydrogen-based electric) vehicle system.
This will result in long-term seismic shifts in the world's economies, which will offer plenty of other opportunities for investing.
"The tyranny of compounding expenses is the eighth deadly sin." - George Sisti
-
- Posts: 60
- Joined: Mon Feb 11, 2013 1:37 pm
Re: Tesla Motors Stock
I noticed on Y!Finance the founder Elon Musk put his own $$ and bought Tesla shares @ $92
Re: Tesla Motors Stock
[quote="Stan DupEveryone makes the mistake of wanting their electric car to perform just like their gasoline car (same range, acceleration, size, cost, safety, comfort). If electric cars become commonplace it will only be the result of the paradigm of our lives, society, and cities being altered. Everything else will have to be adapted to an electric (or more likely, hydrogen-based electric) vehicle system.
This will result in long-term seismic shifts in the world's economies, which will offer plenty of other opportunities for investing.[/quote]
This is a site devoted to question of buying TSLA stock (which I do not recommend at current valuation), not the car. But since I am apparently only Boglehead participating on this forum with Tesla Model S wanted to respond to your points about car. in fact, the Model S exceeds ICE cars in every respect but one. Acceleration: Think of a big four door sedan beating a non turbo Porsche 911 in quarter mile acceleration from stop. Handling: again, think of four door sedan with very low center of gravity handling slalom better than most 2 door sports cars. Size: Easily seats five adults, with more storage space than any ICE sedan due to additional trunk in front ('frunk") where normally an engine would sit. Comfort: Think Audi A8 or Mercedes S Class. Safety: Probably safest car ever produced due to very low center of gravity, 1,000 pound steel encased battery under car, and no gas tank. Purchase Cost: It is a luxury car. But probably less expensive than comparables like Mercedes S Class and Audi A8 and Porsche Panamera due to $7500 tax credit. Certainly not more expensive. Operating Cost: Much cheaper to operate. I refuel every evening in my garage, costs less than $10 per week in electrical charge, vs. fill up every week in my ICE at cost of about $65 for same range. Range: yes, that is difference. I get about 230 miles daily range driving 70mph or so on freeways. But that is more than my daily needs. By time get Model X in 2015 plan to be making long trips with superchargers. The paradigm has occured, Tesla is causing the seismic shift as recognized by market in TSLA stock valuation. Just need to get used to it. and if have chance try a test drive.
This will result in long-term seismic shifts in the world's economies, which will offer plenty of other opportunities for investing.[/quote]
This is a site devoted to question of buying TSLA stock (which I do not recommend at current valuation), not the car. But since I am apparently only Boglehead participating on this forum with Tesla Model S wanted to respond to your points about car. in fact, the Model S exceeds ICE cars in every respect but one. Acceleration: Think of a big four door sedan beating a non turbo Porsche 911 in quarter mile acceleration from stop. Handling: again, think of four door sedan with very low center of gravity handling slalom better than most 2 door sports cars. Size: Easily seats five adults, with more storage space than any ICE sedan due to additional trunk in front ('frunk") where normally an engine would sit. Comfort: Think Audi A8 or Mercedes S Class. Safety: Probably safest car ever produced due to very low center of gravity, 1,000 pound steel encased battery under car, and no gas tank. Purchase Cost: It is a luxury car. But probably less expensive than comparables like Mercedes S Class and Audi A8 and Porsche Panamera due to $7500 tax credit. Certainly not more expensive. Operating Cost: Much cheaper to operate. I refuel every evening in my garage, costs less than $10 per week in electrical charge, vs. fill up every week in my ICE at cost of about $65 for same range. Range: yes, that is difference. I get about 230 miles daily range driving 70mph or so on freeways. But that is more than my daily needs. By time get Model X in 2015 plan to be making long trips with superchargers. The paradigm has occured, Tesla is causing the seismic shift as recognized by market in TSLA stock valuation. Just need to get used to it. and if have chance try a test drive.
Re: Tesla Motors Stock
Your details make my point. But I will take this offline. Otto Benz did not create the paradigm shift by selling expensive cars, Henry Ford created it by selling inexpensive cars.
I applaud what he is doing but we all have a long way to go. A very long way.
Edit: I tried to contact you but you do not have any way of reaching you here. Feel free to contact me.
I applaud what he is doing but we all have a long way to go. A very long way.
Edit: I tried to contact you but you do not have any way of reaching you here. Feel free to contact me.
"The tyranny of compounding expenses is the eighth deadly sin." - George Sisti
Re: Tesla Motors Stock
As another comment on the Tesla S. My father got one three weeks ago. He is (as well as my entire family) a very big car guy. Owns several classic cars, a few modern muscle/super cars, drag races a 900 CI Top Sportsman car, etc. He over and over the past few weeks has said "Steve, that Tesla S is one hell of a car, I caint wait for you to drive it" Shoot he didn't even say that about his 67 Corvette!
Take it for what its worth but even a die hard petrol head cant get over that car.
Take it for what its worth but even a die hard petrol head cant get over that car.
Re: Tesla Motors Stock
Why not keep it online? We may all learn something or gain a different perspective. There is no doubt that range for longer driving is a real problem and on this thread and others fans of the company keep bringing up the supercharger network. It seems to me that they are better than nothing certainly but even when they finally cover a decent section of the US there will still be only a handful of charging bays. So on a map it says there is a supercharger in Normal, IL. Its one thing to say that I am leaving Thursday night from Chicago to drive to St. Louis (or vice versa) and plan on charging there. Say 30-45 minutes. It is another to get there and be greeted by a line of other Teslas trying to do the same thing. The Normal, IL supercharger has 4 stalls. That supply and demand ratio is unknown to me but I could see it being a real problem in 2 years.Stan Dup wrote:Your details make my point. But I will take this offline. Otto Benz did not create the paradigm shift by selling expensive cars, Henry Ford created it by selling inexpensive cars.
I applaud what he is doing but we all have a long way to go. A very long way.
Edit: I tried to contact you but you do not have any way of reaching you here. Feel free to contact me.
A man is rich in proportion to the number of things he can afford to let alone.
Re: Tesla Motors Stock
This is where investment opportunities will arise, but only for entrepeneurs.
Battery changing, not charging, stations will need to happen to mimic the convenience of a gasoline fill up. Others are working on this.
Running the air conditioner consumes about the same amount of energy as it takes to propel the vehicle. Try changing that behavior.
I could go on.
Remember, it did not just take the Model T to make cars commonplace, there also had to be service stations and a road network to be built to support them. It did not happen overnight. This is the key (investing) point I am making about electrification, it is going to take a long time. Invest accordingly.
Many manufacturers have electric or hybrid-electric vehicles. They have been greeted with a collective yawn. Enthusiastic early adopters do not make a big difference overall.
Battery changing, not charging, stations will need to happen to mimic the convenience of a gasoline fill up. Others are working on this.
Running the air conditioner consumes about the same amount of energy as it takes to propel the vehicle. Try changing that behavior.
I could go on.
Remember, it did not just take the Model T to make cars commonplace, there also had to be service stations and a road network to be built to support them. It did not happen overnight. This is the key (investing) point I am making about electrification, it is going to take a long time. Invest accordingly.
Many manufacturers have electric or hybrid-electric vehicles. They have been greeted with a collective yawn. Enthusiastic early adopters do not make a big difference overall.
"The tyranny of compounding expenses is the eighth deadly sin." - George Sisti
Re: Tesla Motors Stock
Agree. I really liked the concept of Better Place with their battery switch but they just went bust. Couldn't make it work in Israel and Denmark. http://www.betterplace.com/Stan Dup wrote:This is where investment opportunities will arise, but only for entrepeneurs.
Battery changing, not charging, stations will need to happen to mimic the convenience of a gasoline fill up. Others are working on this.
Running the air conditioner consumes about the same amount of energy as it takes to propel the vehicle. Try changing that behavior.
I could go on.
Remember, it did not just take the Model T to make cars commonplace, there also had to be service stations and a road network to be built to support them. It did not happen overnight. This is the key (investing) point I am making about electrification, it is going to take a long time. Invest accordingly.
Many manufacturers have electric or hybrid-electric vehicles. They have been greeted with a collective yawn. Enthusiastic early adopters do not make a big difference overall.
A man is rich in proportion to the number of things he can afford to let alone.
Re: Tesla Motors Stock
Not as an argument to your overall point, but just to add a couple things:Stan Dup wrote:This is where investment opportunities will arise, but only for entrepeneurs.
Battery changing, not charging, stations will need to happen to mimic the convenience of a gasoline fill up. Others are working on this.
Running the air conditioner consumes about the same amount of energy as it takes to propel the vehicle. Try changing that behavior.
I could go on.
Remember, it did not just take the Model T to make cars commonplace, there also had to be service stations and a road network to be built to support them. It did not happen overnight. This is the key (investing) point I am making about electrification, it is going to take a long time. Invest accordingly.
Many manufacturers have electric or hybrid-electric vehicles. They have been greeted with a collective yawn. Enthusiastic early adopters do not make a big difference overall.
Regarding the bolded section, I'd love to see those numbers. Here are Tesla's, below. Note the sliver represented by HVAC. To look at it another way, it looks like the car has about an average consumption of 12.6 kW at 60 mph. That'd be a chilly AC.

You can already hot swap batteries in the Tesla. Who knows if that will take off, but it's really quite impressive that they had the foresight to build their vehicles that way, and sort of announced the capability after the fact.
http://www.edmunds.com/car-news/tesla-t ... twork.html
As to your greater point, from an investment perspective, I'd agree. There is a big upside for Tesla, but it's a huge gamble. The biggest I could think of would that their technology gets widely adopted and utilized by others. Since they're way out ahead in battery design, fast charging, battery swapping, and infrastructure, it's conceivable that other EV could just decide to get in on this. And Tesla may decide that it's sufficiently lucrative for them to do it that way. There also could be a technological breakthrough in energy storage and they could be best positioned to take advantage of it. Those definitely seem like long shots to me, but I can at least see the upside of what people are gambling on, which isn't always the case with hot stocks.
An inconvenience is only an adventure wrongly considered; an adventure is an inconvenience rightly considered. -- GK Chesterton
-
- Posts: 894
- Joined: Tue Feb 14, 2012 12:31 pm
Re: Tesla Motors Stock
I rather buy the car than the stock.
Re: Tesla Motors Stock
I do not mean for these responses to sound like I am attacking you.
We, as a global society, will need to change the way our societies are structured for electric vehicles to be a success. We all want them to just be a direct replacement for ICE vehicles. Instead, we will have to adapt our ways to them.
I think Elon is moving closer, which I think is a good thing. But it is not there yet.
BTW: The Chinese are pouring huge amounts of money into every stage of electric vehicle development.
- "Since they're way out ahead in battery design" No, they are not. Nothing proprietary about what they do.
- "fast charging" No, fast charging is not new or unique to Tesla.
- "battery swapping" The company that promoted this just filed for bankruptcy after several years of trying to get it going.
- "and infrastructure" Charging stations already exist all over the country as a result of cooperative agreements with local power companies. Has not seemed to cause buyers to flock to electric vehicles.
- "it's conceivable that other EV could just decide to get in on this." All of them have been talking with one another, and the goverment, and the universities, for years.
- "There also could be a technological breakthrough in energy storage and they could be best positioned to take advantage of it." I was talking with a leading expert in battery technology ( a professor) and he said that it takes approximately 18 years to bring a new battery chemistry to market (all the basic chemical research and real life fundamental research). They are currently working on the next generation battery chemistries, but nothing big is coming down the pike.
We, as a global society, will need to change the way our societies are structured for electric vehicles to be a success. We all want them to just be a direct replacement for ICE vehicles. Instead, we will have to adapt our ways to them.
I think Elon is moving closer, which I think is a good thing. But it is not there yet.
BTW: The Chinese are pouring huge amounts of money into every stage of electric vehicle development.
"The tyranny of compounding expenses is the eighth deadly sin." - George Sisti
Re: Tesla Motors Stock
Stan Dup seems to have missed the main point I was trying to communicate. One needs to read the Consumer Reports article about Tesla Model S which gave it 99 out of 100. Then beg or borrow a test drive. It is without a doubt the most exciting new car in past generation. Made by an American company with American technology. We early adopters will probably never buy another ICE vehicle. Looking forward to delivery of the AWD Model X in 2015 and in meantime very glad that within few weeks after delivery last year invested in the company stock after realizing that the car far exceeded expectations. And still does.Stan Dup wrote: Again, Tesla does not have any technology that is unique to them; there is nothing magical about them. But, as can be seen on many forums, they have tremendous amounts of goodwill. So did Bernie Madoff.
We, as a global society, will need to change the way our societies are structured for electric vehicles to be a success. We all want them to just be a direct replacement for ICE vehicles. Instead, we will have to adapt our ways to them.
I think Elon is moving closer, which I think is a good thing. But it is not there yet.
BTW: The Chinese are pouring huge amounts of money into every stage of electric vehicle development.
Re: Tesla Motors Stock
JDB I have a quick question. In looking at the power consumption chart above I realize how the aero really takes its toll as you increase speed. Chart stops at 70. Not sure of your driving habits or requirements but for me it is not unusual to be going 75-85 for very long stretches when on the highway. Have you noticed what that type of driving does to your range?
A man is rich in proportion to the number of things he can afford to let alone.
Re: Tesla Motors Stock
matjen wrote:JDB I have a quick question. In looking at the power consumption chart above I realize how the aero really takes its toll as you increase speed. Chart stops at 70. Not sure of your driving habits or requirements but for me it is not unusual to be going 75-85 for very long stretches when on the highway. Have you noticed what that type of driving does to your range?
A side note: aerodynamics don't help much until you get above approximately 40-45 mph. That is why the Smart Car is so blunt nosed: it is intended for city driving.
That chart would look even worse if the Tesla was not so aerodynamic.
Last edited by Stan Dup on Thu Jul 11, 2013 8:03 am, edited 1 time in total.
"The tyranny of compounding expenses is the eighth deadly sin." - George Sisti
Re: Tesla Motors Stock
jdb wrote:Stan Dup seems to have missed the main point I was trying to communicate. One needs to read the Consumer Reports article about Tesla Model S which gave it 99 out of 100. Then beg or borrow a test drive. It is without a doubt the most exciting new car in past generation. Made by an American company with American technology. We early adopters will probably never buy another ICE vehicle. Looking forward to delivery of the AWD Model X in 2015 and in meantime very glad that within few weeks after delivery last year invested in the company stock after realizing that the car far exceeded expectations. And still does.
One exciting car does not make a long lasting investment opportunity.
"The tyranny of compounding expenses is the eighth deadly sin." - George Sisti
Re: Tesla Motors Stock
I noticed that this statement was complete discredited yet you did not challenge the data posted by ryuns or issue a correction.Stan Dup wrote:Running the air conditioner consumes about the same amount of energy as it takes to propel the vehicle.
The same could have been said about Apple with respect to the iPod or iPhone - nothing magical, just good engineering and a consumer-friendly design. Ended up doing quite well for Apple, eh?Stan Dup wrote:Tesla does not have any technology that is unique to them; there is nothing magical about them.
Anyway I think you are really missing the point, this is Tesla's first attempt to make an electric sedan and they hit it out of the park (albeit not cheaply). The range issue may mean it is not suitable for long trips but the vast majority of driving in this country is not long trips. Most families have multiple cars, I'm sure Tesla would be ok with every family having one Tesla and one traditional (ICE) car in the garage.
Thinly veiled attacks with statements like "they have tremendous amounts of goodwill. So did Bernie Madoff." are completely inappropriate unless you are alleging that they are cooking the books in some way. If you want to compare them to previous up and coming tech companies that ended up falling flat on their face, fine, but comparing them to Madoff?
In terms of the stock price, yes it has gone up a lot this year but consider what would have happened if you had asked the same question about buying TSLA when it was up only 100% this year - I bet the same people would have used the same arguments about chasing a hot stock and yet look how much further it has gone since then. Not saying the stock is going to up forever but standing aside because a stock has already had a great gain is not always the smart choice.
Re: Tesla Motors Stock
An image of cars parked in neighborhood streets and apartment complexes with extension cards running across yards and parking lots pops into my head.
...I might be just beginning |
I might be near the end. Enya |
|
C'est la vie
Re: Tesla Motors Stock
You are right, I just did not feel like calling up the battery engineers I work with to get a more exact example. Let's just say it is a substantial penalty. Heating on the other hand is a benefit because the battery system generates it while in use.Pete3 wrote:I noticed that this statement was complete discredited yet you did not challenge the data posted by ryuns or issue a correction.
Pete3 wrote:
Yep, I agree.Pete3 wrote:The same could have been said about Apple with respect to the iPod or iPhone - nothing magical, just good engineering and a consumer-friendly design. Ended up doing quite well for Apple, eh?
This is one type of paradigm shift I was referring to. Everyone would like to have two cars but few can afford to.Pete3 wrote:Anyway I think you are really missing the point, this is Tesla's first attempt to make an electric sedan and they hit it out of the park (albeit not cheaply). The range issue may mean it is not suitable for long trips but the vast majority of driving in this country is not long trips. Most families have multiple cars, I'm sure Tesla would be ok with every family having one Tesla and one traditional (ICE) car in the garage.
I meant that excited people can be blind to the realities of the investement situation. This is what John Bogle refers to in his books.Pete3 wrote:Thinly veiled attacks with statements like "they have tremendous amounts of goodwill. So did Bernie Madoff." are completely inappropriate unless you are alleging that they are cooking the books in some way. If you want to compare them to previous up and coming tech companies that ended up falling flat on their face, fine, but comparing them to Madoff?
Buying individual stocks is gambling, not investing. That is one of the key points of the boglehead philosophy.Pete3 wrote:In terms of the stock price, yes it has gone up a lot this year but consider what would have happened if you had asked the same question about buying TSLA when it was up only 100% this year - I bet the same people would have used the same arguments about chasing a hot stock and yet look how much further it has gone since then. Not saying the stock is going to up forever but standing aside because a stock has already had a great gain is not always the smart choice.
I applaud Elon for what he is doing; he is generating excitement and getting people to open their wallets. Early adopters are important. But please realize, modern hybrid-electric vehicles have been around for ten years now. The problem is not the vehicles, it is the consumer. So as investors we need to be aware that the market holds enormous potential but it has very large obstacles to overcome. Even with goverment subsidies these new technology companies are failing (going bankrupt) because the buyers are not lining up. It is not a matter of human will, lots of good people want this to work.
BTW: When looking for investment opportunities in the growing electrification field, keep in mind those who rode the coat tails of the early ICE industry. People like Harvery Firestone (tires) and John D Rockefeller (oil). While everyone bids up the Tesla price, others may have more value.
Last edited by Stan Dup on Thu Jul 11, 2013 11:56 am, edited 1 time in total.
"The tyranny of compounding expenses is the eighth deadly sin." - George Sisti
Re: Tesla Motors Stock
Hi Matjen. Good question. Yes, about once a week I do freeway trip of around 150 miles round trip. The Model S begs to go 75 or more on open road with air suspension that lowers suspension at speed, it is only the regenerative braking that starts moment foot is off accelerator that has kept me from tickets. There is a fall off of range at speed especially with sudden acceleration. Car can go from 60 to 90 in less than 3 seconds and that affects range probably more than higher constant speed. My best unscientific guesstimate based on 8 months driving is around 5-7 percent, so with my daily range of about 230 then with freeway driving at speed would get around 215. This is not stop and go freeway but the open road driving. As practical matter my daily slogs never require more than 200 miles before arriving back at refueling station (my garage).matjen wrote:JDB I have a quick question. In looking at the power consumption chart above I realize how the aero really takes its toll as you increase speed. Chart stops at 70. Not sure of your driving habits or requirements but for me it is not unusual to be going 75-85 for very long stretches when on the highway. Have you noticed what that type of driving does to your range?
Re: Tesla Motors Stock
Few?Stan Dup wrote:This is one type of paradigm shift I was referring to. Everyone would like to have two cars but few can afford to.Pete3 wrote:Anyway I think you are really missing the point, this is Tesla's first attempt to make an electric sedan and they hit it out of the park (albeit not cheaply). The range issue may mean it is not suitable for long trips but the vast majority of driving in this country is not long trips. Most families have multiple cars, I'm sure Tesla would be ok with every family having one Tesla and one traditional (ICE) car in the garage.

Experian Automotive found single- and two-vehicle households are almost neck and neck, at nearly 34 percent and 31 percent, respectively.
However, households with three or more vehicles maintain the single largest category, at nearly 35 percent.
Re: Tesla Motors Stock
Tesla has $14 billion in capitalization. When will it be in the 500?Ranger wrote:http://www.reuters.com/article/2013/07/ ... FQ20130709
Tesla Motors to replace Oracle Corp on Nasdaq 100 Index.
Currently the stock has all the momo. If one is desperate to own the stock, best way to own is to sell puts below. Atleast one can capture 85% volatility with put selling.
Public School K-12 Educators: "Ask NOT what your annuity sales person can do for you, ask what you can do to be a Do-It-Yourselfer (DIY)."
Re: Tesla Motors Stock
Well to be more accurate, what do you think the percentage of families out there have 2 cars and one of those cars is in the 85k-105K range?Pete3 wrote:Few?Stan Dup wrote:This is one type of paradigm shift I was referring to. Everyone would like to have two cars but few can afford to.Pete3 wrote:Anyway I think you are really missing the point, this is Tesla's first attempt to make an electric sedan and they hit it out of the park (albeit not cheaply). The range issue may mean it is not suitable for long trips but the vast majority of driving in this country is not long trips. Most families have multiple cars, I'm sure Tesla would be ok with every family having one Tesla and one traditional (ICE) car in the garage."Study Finds Americans Own 2.28 Vehicles Per Household" http://www.autospies.com/news/Study-Fin ... old-26437/
Experian Automotive found single- and two-vehicle households are almost neck and neck, at nearly 34 percent and 31 percent, respectively.
However, households with three or more vehicles maintain the single largest category, at nearly 35 percent.

A man is rich in proportion to the number of things he can afford to let alone.
Re: Tesla Motors Stock
I understand why car enthusiasts love the Tesla. It's a cool machine. However, I will be surprised if there are enough people with both the means AND the desire to own one to justify a meaningful increase in sales. Of all my friends and family, only one person has said they would go for an electric car - a man with 4 drivers in the family who could get by with one of their three cars being a short-range machine. Perhaps 2% of all the people I know have EVER spent as much on a car as a Tesla costs.
I have the means but not the desire to pay more than $25,000 on a car. That's all I need to spend to get the type of car I need and want to own. Even if they put little wind turbines on the car so it could recharge itself from wind power as you drive to achieve a zero recharging cost, I still don't think I would spend that kind of money on a car.
The infrastructure and cultural obstacles are immense for this to become more than a niche product. An ICE car that you can drive anywhere, any time, for any distance with zero fear of being able to fully refuel in minutes at will is a tough bar to overcome.
I have the means but not the desire to pay more than $25,000 on a car. That's all I need to spend to get the type of car I need and want to own. Even if they put little wind turbines on the car so it could recharge itself from wind power as you drive to achieve a zero recharging cost, I still don't think I would spend that kind of money on a car.
The infrastructure and cultural obstacles are immense for this to become more than a niche product. An ICE car that you can drive anywhere, any time, for any distance with zero fear of being able to fully refuel in minutes at will is a tough bar to overcome.
Re: Tesla Motors Stock
Agreed, Tesla's high price puts it out of reach of most families - my point was that since most households have at least 2 cars already, having one EV (not necessarily a Tesla) and one conventional or hybrid vehicle for those rare long-trips is reasonable and does not require a paradigm shift.matjen wrote:Well to be more accurate, what do you think the percentage of families out there have 2 cars and one of those cars is in the 85k-105K range?Pete3 wrote:Few?Stan Dup wrote:This is one type of paradigm shift I was referring to. Everyone would like to have two cars but few can afford to.Pete3 wrote:Anyway I think you are really missing the point, this is Tesla's first attempt to make an electric sedan and they hit it out of the park (albeit not cheaply). The range issue may mean it is not suitable for long trips but the vast majority of driving in this country is not long trips. Most families have multiple cars, I'm sure Tesla would be ok with every family having one Tesla and one traditional (ICE) car in the garage."Study Finds Americans Own 2.28 Vehicles Per Household" http://www.autospies.com/news/Study-Fin ... old-26437/
Experian Automotive found single- and two-vehicle households are almost neck and neck, at nearly 34 percent and 31 percent, respectively.
However, households with three or more vehicles maintain the single largest category, at nearly 35 percent.
Re: Tesla Motors Stock
Thanks JDB. The Model S intrigues me because it appears to have a nice combo of being cool (early adopter battery, touchscreens, etc.), actually practical from a space and functionality perspective for this type of car, and fast/fun to drive. I would love to see some camparos by the car magazines between it and say an Audi S7 and a Porsche Panamera. If I was an editor I would be getting that type of article together.jdb wrote:Hi Matjen. Good question. Yes, about once a week I do freeway trip of around 150 miles round trip. The Model S begs to go 75 or more on open road with air suspension that lowers suspension at speed, it is only the regenerative braking that starts moment foot is off accelerator that has kept me from tickets. There is a fall off of range at speed especially with sudden acceleration. Car can go from 60 to 90 in less than 3 seconds and that affects range probably more than higher constant speed. My best unscientific guesstimate based on 8 months driving is around 5-7 percent, so with my daily range of about 230 then with freeway driving at speed would get around 215. This is not stop and go freeway but the open road driving. As practical matter my daily slogs never require more than 200 miles before arriving back at refueling station (my garage).matjen wrote:JDB I have a quick question. In looking at the power consumption chart above I realize how the aero really takes its toll as you increase speed. Chart stops at 70. Not sure of your driving habits or requirements but for me it is not unusual to be going 75-85 for very long stretches when on the highway. Have you noticed what that type of driving does to your range?
A man is rich in proportion to the number of things he can afford to let alone.