Ahh...thanks for this insight lakpr!
Search found 78 matches
- Tue Jan 24, 2023 6:17 pm
- Forum: Personal Investments
- Topic: Changing 403b funds for another 403b fund
- Replies: 6
- Views: 285
Re: Changing 403b funds for another 403b fund
- Tue Jan 24, 2023 5:26 pm
- Forum: Personal Investments
- Topic: Changing 403b funds for another 403b fund
- Replies: 6
- Views: 285
Re: Changing 403b funds for another 403b fund
Thank you Runninginvestor and Fposte!
I will reach out to my employer to see how this is handled.
Otherwise, it seems very straightforward.
I will reach out to my employer to see how this is handled.
Otherwise, it seems very straightforward.
- Tue Jan 24, 2023 4:31 pm
- Forum: Personal Investments
- Topic: Changing 403b funds for another 403b fund
- Replies: 6
- Views: 285
Changing 403b funds for another 403b fund
Hello,
At the moment, we are contributing to a 403b 2030 Target Retirement Fund using Vanguard.
We would like to change our 403b 2030 Target Retirement Fund to a 2035 Target Retirement Fund.
What is involved in making this transaction? Is it allowed? Any IRS considerations?
We are just going from one Vanguard fund to another Vanguard fund.
Thanks in advance.
At the moment, we are contributing to a 403b 2030 Target Retirement Fund using Vanguard.
We would like to change our 403b 2030 Target Retirement Fund to a 2035 Target Retirement Fund.
What is involved in making this transaction? Is it allowed? Any IRS considerations?
We are just going from one Vanguard fund to another Vanguard fund.
Thanks in advance.
- Tue Nov 30, 2021 6:30 pm
- Forum: Personal Investments
- Topic: Splitting Between 403b and 457 ROTH
- Replies: 23
- Views: 1657
Re: Splitting Between 403b and 457 ROTH
Thanks for the reply.Charon wrote: ↑Tue Nov 30, 2021 4:49 pmNo. At worst your tax bracket will be the same in retirement, so Roth vs. trad is a wash. At best your bracket will be substantially lower, so trad is better. The wiki page discusses subtleties around this, but that's the basic comparison to do.maestro1868 wrote: ↑Mon Nov 29, 2021 2:06 pm This is the confusion I have at this time. "I'm close to both boundaries".
So you recommend redirecting more contributions toward the 457b Roth and less toward the 403b?
- Mon Nov 29, 2021 2:06 pm
- Forum: Personal Investments
- Topic: Splitting Between 403b and 457 ROTH
- Replies: 23
- Views: 1657
Re: Splitting Between 403b and 457 ROTH
Charon,Charon wrote: ↑Mon Nov 29, 2021 2:00 pmSo I think your question boils down to ye olde Roth vs. traditional, which is well covered on the forum and in the wiki: https://www.bogleheads.org/wiki/Traditional_versus_Roth . The numbers you've provided suggest you're currently in the 35% bracket and could be in the 24% bracket in retirement, which make it a very easy decision. But you're close to both boundaries.maestro1868 wrote: ↑Mon Nov 29, 2021 1:50 pm No, I'm not planning on withdrawing money prior to age 59.5.
Thanks for the reply.
This is the confusion I have at this time. "I'm close to both boundaries".
So you recommend redirecting more contributions toward the 457b Roth and less toward the 403b?
Thanks again.
- Mon Nov 29, 2021 2:03 pm
- Forum: Personal Investments
- Topic: Splitting Between 403b and 457 ROTH
- Replies: 23
- Views: 1657
Re: Splitting Between 403b and 457 ROTH
Will you also be getting SS? What age(s) will you be in 2031?
[/quote]
I will be 59 in 2031.
[/quote]
I will be 59 in 2031.
- Mon Nov 29, 2021 2:02 pm
- Forum: Personal Investments
- Topic: Splitting Between 403b and 457 ROTH
- Replies: 23
- Views: 1657
Re: Splitting Between 403b and 457 ROTH
retire2022 wrote: ↑Sun Nov 28, 2021 10:46 pmThanks for the reply Retire2022.
At this time, we need to make some decisions about how much we are going to allocate toward the 403b and 457b Roth. Initially, our goal was to max out both plans. However, we realized that perhaps allocating less to the 403b and more toward the 457b Roth is a better strategy for the long term.
- Mon Nov 29, 2021 1:50 pm
- Forum: Personal Investments
- Topic: Splitting Between 403b and 457 ROTH
- Replies: 23
- Views: 1657
Re: Splitting Between 403b and 457 ROTH
Thank you for the reply.Charon wrote: ↑Sun Nov 28, 2021 10:32 pm Are you planning on withdrawing money prior to age 59 1/2? You don't post your age, but you say you'll retire in 9 years and imply you haven't yet hit 50.
If so, go with the 457, but I agree with pizzy that you should use traditional. Your income will be lower in retirement. If you want some Roth, do a Roth IRA (backdoor, at your income level).
No, I'm not planning on withdrawing money prior to age 59.5.
- Sun Nov 28, 2021 8:12 pm
- Forum: Personal Investments
- Topic: Splitting Between 403b and 457 ROTH
- Replies: 23
- Views: 1657
Re: Splitting Between 403b and 457 ROTH
Thanks for highlighting the Roth 457 drawback. I haven't heard of that one.Nate7out wrote: ↑Sun Nov 28, 2021 7:42 pm See post linked below. It notes the 1 drawback of Roth 457.
viewtopic.php?p=5541684#p5541684
- Sun Nov 28, 2021 7:24 pm
- Forum: Personal Investments
- Topic: Splitting Between 403b and 457 ROTH
- Replies: 23
- Views: 1657
Re: Splitting Between 403b and 457 ROTH
Thanks for the reply.
Unfortunately, at this time I can't max out both plans. So, I was thinking of contributing less to my 403b and more to my 457b Roth. Since I'm only 9 years away from retirement, I was thinking of shifting contribution strategy.
However, I'm not sure if this makes any difference in my situation.
Thanks for your perspective. Much appreciated.
- Sun Nov 28, 2021 6:47 pm
- Forum: Personal Investments
- Topic: Splitting Between 403b and 457 ROTH
- Replies: 23
- Views: 1657
- Sun Nov 28, 2021 6:36 pm
- Forum: Personal Investments
- Topic: Splitting Between 403b and 457 ROTH
- Replies: 23
- Views: 1657
Splitting Between 403b and 457 ROTH
Hello all, I hope everyone had a great Thanksgiving with friends and family. We are trying to determine how to split 403b and 457 ROTH (New York State Deferred Compensation Plan) contributions. The plan is to retire in 9 years from our professions in education. The details: His Income: $126K + $20K (moonlighting gig) = $146K Her Income: $132K His future pension: 90k (2031) Her future pension: 98k (2031) His/Her Yearly 403b contributions: $39k His/Her Yearly 457 Roth Contributions: $34K His/Her 403b Nest Egg: $416K His/Her 457 Roth Nest Egg: $40K Should we redirect all our energy to the maximizing the ROTH contributions. At 50 years of age, we can increase our ROTH contributions to $26K per year. Our thinking is to contribute less to the 403...
- Sat Mar 27, 2021 7:48 pm
- Forum: Personal Finance (Not Investing)
- Topic: 2.5 mil house with 5 mil net worth, too much?
- Replies: 74
- Views: 10017
Re: 2.5 mil house with 5 mil net worth, too much?
Check out the book titled, "Your Money or Your Life".
- Wed Jan 06, 2021 7:08 pm
- Forum: Personal Investments
- Topic: Happy New Year! 365 New Chances!
- Replies: 5
- Views: 1343
Re: Just Because...
You're right...I changed it.Sandtrap wrote: ↑Tue Jan 05, 2021 9:30 am "A Hau'ole Makahiki Hou"!
Happy New Year fellow bogleheads!
Aloha
j![]()
OP: suggest you edit your original post title to include something like: "Happy New Year" using the pencil icon.
Many will not "click" on a title that reads: "Just Because. . . " and nothing else. Thanks.![]()
Thank you.
- Sun Jan 03, 2021 3:52 pm
- Forum: Personal Investments
- Topic: Happy New Year! 365 New Chances!
- Replies: 5
- Views: 1343
Happy New Year! 365 New Chances!
Happy New Year Bogleheads!
I want to thank all those folks who graciously gave of their time to help me understand my financial picture.
You guys gave me the tools to achieve more awareness and more control of my personal investments.
Lastly, thank you to the administrators that keep this website going.
Happy New Year.
I want to thank all those folks who graciously gave of their time to help me understand my financial picture.
You guys gave me the tools to achieve more awareness and more control of my personal investments.
Lastly, thank you to the administrators that keep this website going.
Happy New Year.
- Sat Nov 07, 2020 7:17 am
- Forum: Personal Finance (Not Investing)
- Topic: Oversized mortgage- worth the lost sleep?
- Replies: 38
- Views: 3702
Re: Oversized mortgage- worth the lost sleep?
Consider reading the book "Your Money or Your Life".
Ask yourself the real hard questions:
1. Who is actually winning if you buy this massive house? You? Your family? All the players that stand to make a killing on the transaction? Local government (property taxes)?
2. Can you and your family live a healthy productive life with a house that is half the cost?
3. How much "life energy" do you and your family need to give up to live in a nice "box"? Your time and your sacrifice to generate income = life energy.
In the end, when your time is up...you won't take the house with you.
Stay focused on what matters: your health, your family, your financial independence, and your contributions to community.
Ask yourself the real hard questions:
1. Who is actually winning if you buy this massive house? You? Your family? All the players that stand to make a killing on the transaction? Local government (property taxes)?
2. Can you and your family live a healthy productive life with a house that is half the cost?
3. How much "life energy" do you and your family need to give up to live in a nice "box"? Your time and your sacrifice to generate income = life energy.
In the end, when your time is up...you won't take the house with you.
Stay focused on what matters: your health, your family, your financial independence, and your contributions to community.
- Mon Oct 19, 2020 8:23 pm
- Forum: Personal Investments
- Topic: Income Streams Spreadsheet - Help
- Replies: 13
- Views: 1588
Re: Income Streams Spreadsheet - Help
I will probably need to take a video course online. I have a young family to raise and being absent for even a few hours is toughretired@50 wrote: ↑Mon Oct 19, 2020 8:16 pmIf you're truly curious about learning Excel, you might be able to find a course at a community college or continuing education center for adults. Once you start to get the hang of formulas and the "help" in Excel, you can usually muddle through. At least if you take a class, you'll have a teacher to ask for assistance.
Regards,

Thanks for the reply.
- Mon Oct 19, 2020 8:11 pm
- Forum: Personal Investments
- Topic: Income Streams Spreadsheet - Help
- Replies: 13
- Views: 1588
Re: Income Streams Spreadsheet - Help
During retirement, I think our tax rate will be high :( I use this type of spreadsheet to map out income streams. You can make a copy and modify to fit your details. I've begun with both spouses 43 years of age and retiring at age 55. Current income 150,000 increasing at 2% per year. One spouse begins SS at 62. The second spouse begins SS at 70. See https://opensocialsecurity.com/ for further resources. 85% of Social Security income taxable. 403b balance of 360,000 with annual contributions of 19,500 through age 55 and 5% return through age 55. Using the 2021 Proposed RMD Table. Keep in mind tax brackets are scheduled to revert to pre TCJA levels in 2026. And, brackets have historically been indexed, so the top of the 24% bracket should be...
- Thu Oct 15, 2020 5:56 pm
- Forum: Personal Investments
- Topic: Income Streams Spreadsheet - Help
- Replies: 13
- Views: 1588
Re: Income Streams Spreadsheet - Help
During retirement, I think our tax rate will be high :( I use this type of spreadsheet to map out income streams. You can make a copy and modify to fit your details. I've begun with both spouses 43 years of age and retiring at age 55. Current income 150,000 increasing at 2% per year. One spouse begins SS at 62. The second spouse begins SS at 70. See https://opensocialsecurity.com/ for further resources. 85% of Social Security income taxable. 403b balance of 360,000 with annual contributions of 19,500 through age 55 and 5% return through age 55. Using the 2021 Proposed RMD Table. Keep in mind tax brackets are scheduled to revert to pre TCJA levels in 2026. And, brackets have historically been indexed, so the top of the 24% bracket should be...
- Thu Oct 15, 2020 5:53 pm
- Forum: Personal Investments
- Topic: Income Streams Spreadsheet - Help
- Replies: 13
- Views: 1588
Re: Income Streams Spreadsheet - Help
During retirement, I think our tax rate will be high :( I use this type of spreadsheet to map out income streams. You can make a copy and modify to fit your details. I've begun with both spouses 43 years of age and retiring at age 55. Current income 150,000 increasing at 2% per year. One spouse begins SS at 62. The second spouse begins SS at 70. See https://opensocialsecurity.com/ for further resources. 85% of Social Security income taxable. 403b balance of 360,000 with annual contributions of 19,500 through age 55 and 5% return through age 55. Using the 2021 Proposed RMD Table. Keep in mind tax brackets are scheduled to revert to pre TCJA levels in 2026. And, brackets have historically been indexed, so the top of the 24% bracket should be...
- Thu Oct 15, 2020 5:50 pm
- Forum: Personal Investments
- Topic: Income Streams Spreadsheet - Help
- Replies: 13
- Views: 1588
Re: Income Streams Spreadsheet - Help
Hello everyone, I need some help developing an excel spreadsheet for income streams...for two people. Sahara provided me with one a few weeks ago which was terrific. Unfortunately, I tried to manipulate the spreadsheet but I failed miserably. I don't know anything about formulas and excel. I need a spread sheet that considers the following: a. Year b. age c. Two incomes streams with salary increases of 1% each year d. Two pensions e. Two social securities incomes f. Two 403bs g. Two 457b roths h. RMD i. RMD factor j. tax brackets I'm hoping someone can help me. Thank you. Maybe this will help: https://www.bogleheads.org/wiki/Retiree_Portfolio_Model Thank you for the reply. Wow...that is too complicated for me at this time :shock:
- Thu Oct 15, 2020 5:49 pm
- Forum: Personal Investments
- Topic: Income Streams Spreadsheet - Help
- Replies: 13
- Views: 1588
Re: Income Streams Spreadsheet - Help
Hello,
Thank you for the reply.
I clearer picture of what retirement will look like with different streams of income.
Sahara gave me a really good excel spreadsheet. I just don't know how to manipulate it for my purposes.
Unfortunately, I can't attached anything. Don't see options for attachment.
- Thu Oct 15, 2020 3:30 pm
- Forum: Personal Investments
- Topic: Income Streams Spreadsheet - Help
- Replies: 13
- Views: 1588
Income Streams Spreadsheet - Help
Hello everyone,
I need some help developing an excel spreadsheet for income streams...for two people.
Sahara provided me with one a few weeks ago which was terrific. Unfortunately, I tried to manipulate the spreadsheet but I failed miserably. I don't know anything about formulas and excel.
I need a spread sheet that considers the following:
a. Year
b. age
c. Two incomes streams with salary increases of 1% each year
d. Two pensions
e. Two social securities incomes
f. Two 403bs
g. Two 457b roths
h. RMD
i. RMD factor
j. tax brackets
I'm hoping someone can help me.
Thank you.
I need some help developing an excel spreadsheet for income streams...for two people.
Sahara provided me with one a few weeks ago which was terrific. Unfortunately, I tried to manipulate the spreadsheet but I failed miserably. I don't know anything about formulas and excel.
I need a spread sheet that considers the following:
a. Year
b. age
c. Two incomes streams with salary increases of 1% each year
d. Two pensions
e. Two social securities incomes
f. Two 403bs
g. Two 457b roths
h. RMD
i. RMD factor
j. tax brackets
I'm hoping someone can help me.
Thank you.
- Wed Sep 30, 2020 3:40 pm
- Forum: Personal Investments
- Topic: What is the best investment you made in your children's/a child's life?
- Replies: 27
- Views: 2437
Re: What is the best investment you made in your children's/a child's life?
Excellent question.
The best investment we ever made in our children's lives was TIME.
1. Made it a priority to place family over career ambitions
2. Used our sick time to attend school functions
3. Kept sacred family dinner time
4. Made it a priority to create long lasting memories with road trips in the summer
5. Never purchased new cars...used the money instead for enrichment education, music lessons, etc.
6. Reminded our kids to work hard, to be tolerant, to be kind & respectful, to love family, to find passion, to help others, etc.
Regardless of any life challenges that surfaced in the family, we ALWAYS made TIME for the above.
The best investment we ever made in our children's lives was TIME.
1. Made it a priority to place family over career ambitions
2. Used our sick time to attend school functions
3. Kept sacred family dinner time
4. Made it a priority to create long lasting memories with road trips in the summer
5. Never purchased new cars...used the money instead for enrichment education, music lessons, etc.
6. Reminded our kids to work hard, to be tolerant, to be kind & respectful, to love family, to find passion, to help others, etc.
Regardless of any life challenges that surfaced in the family, we ALWAYS made TIME for the above.
- Wed Sep 30, 2020 2:47 pm
- Forum: Personal Investments
- Topic: Investing Beyond 403bs Options?
- Replies: 105
- Views: 4606
Re: Investing Beyond 403bs Options?
Thank you for this information it was very helpful. I did the Vanguard Questionnaire. It give me a 60% stock and 40% bond fund allocation strategy? I'm still struggling with my fund allocation strategy. Initially I had the following: 64% in NYSDCB Equity Index U/A (CIT) - Large Cap Funds 20% in NYSDCB US Debt Index U/A (CIT) - Bonds 16% in NYSDCP International Equity Fund - Passive Maybe I should consider this approach: Large Cap Fund 84% NYSDCB Equity Index - ER 0.01 International Fund 16% International Fund - ER 0.15 As a teacher you should review your pension tier and see what the projected payout will be. Since I am Civil Service under ERS, my retirement payout is slightly different from teacher. https://www.osc.state.ny.us/retirement/...
- Wed Sep 30, 2020 2:45 pm
- Forum: Personal Investments
- Topic: Investing Beyond 403bs Options?
- Replies: 105
- Views: 4606
Re: Investing Beyond 403bs Options?
Hello Boggleheads - new poster here. Love this site. Trying to put together a 3 fund portfolio within the New York State Deferred Compensation Plan. I don’t see the commonly recommended funds such as those in Taylor Larimore’s book and was hoping for some Bogglehead advice to get as close as possible to the 3 fund approach with what is there. Here is what I am looking at because they have the lowest net cost. NYSDCB US Debt Index Unitized Account (Invests in a portfolio of assets whose performance seeks to match the performance of the Barclays U.S. Aggregate Bond Index.) Net cost per $1,000: $0.20/$1,000 NYSDCB Equity Index Unitized Account (CIT) (A passive large-cap equity option that invests in a portfolio of assets whose performance see...
- Tue Sep 29, 2020 8:27 pm
- Forum: Personal Investments
- Topic: Investing Beyond 403bs Options?
- Replies: 105
- Views: 4606
Re: Investing Beyond 403bs Options?
I would not bother with the bond fund since you have a pension and it functions like a bond. Additionally you could contribute to both 457 & 403b and be a oversaver. I maxed out my 457 contributions and Roth IRA hence is why I have a large balance in 457 ie 1.9 million as of today’s closing price, 1.29 million in 457 and 550k in Roth IRA. I will be hit with large tax bill filing Single at 72 with RMD. Best Retire2022 Thank you Retire 2020 for you reply and insight. Currently, my wife and I both max out our 403bs each year. What kind of allocation percentages do you recommend using the NYSDCP? My wife and I have about 12 years to retirement. Everything I read said it's a good idea to include bonds in your allocation strategy. I'm still ...
- Tue Sep 29, 2020 6:06 pm
- Forum: Personal Investments
- Topic: Investing Beyond 403bs Options?
- Replies: 105
- Views: 4606
Re: Investing Beyond 403bs Options?
That link doesn't include expense ratios, so you probably want to try to track those down, but the the investments you've selected are the ones I would think are the most likely candidates. If you're happy using the target date fund in your 403(b) that could also be a good option too, though you'd want to see if you can find the expense ratio and how it's invested. The idea with bonds is that they provide good base that's unlikely to lose value so they can provide for your basic spending even if the markets are doing well. With substantial pensions and social security you may not need that. Will your pensions start as soon as you retire? How does your basic/necessary spending (if you cut out some luxuries) compare to what your pensions and...
- Tue Sep 29, 2020 5:26 pm
- Forum: Personal Investments
- Topic: Investing Beyond 403bs Options?
- Replies: 105
- Views: 4606
Re: Investing Beyond 403bs Options?
Agreed, I would consider your pension to be your bond allocation, but otherwise seems reason. I might have missed it, but how are your 403(b) and any other accounts invested? Your asset allocation should be consider across accounts to make sure everything is working together. Thank you Terran for your input. My wife and I both max out our 403b in a Vanguard Target Retirement Fund: Vanguard Total Stock Market Index Fund Investor Shares 41.40% Vanguard Total International Stock Index Fund Investor Shares 27.00% Vanguard Total Bond Market II Index Fund Investor Shares† 22.10% Vanguard Total International Bond Index Fund Investor Shares 9.50% Now I'm trying to put together a plan for my 457b Roth. Here are the options I currently have under th...
- Tue Sep 29, 2020 5:19 pm
- Forum: Personal Investments
- Topic: Investing Beyond 403bs Options?
- Replies: 105
- Views: 4606
Re: Investing Beyond 403bs Options?
I would not bother with the bond fund since you have a pension and it functions like a bond. Additionally you could contribute to both 457 & 403b and be a oversaver. I maxed out my 457 contributions and Roth IRA hence is why I have a large balance in 457 ie 1.9 million as of today’s closing price, 1.29 million in 457 and 550k in Roth IRA. I will be hit with large tax bill filing Single at 72 with RMD. Best Retire2022 Thank you Retire 2020 for you reply and insight. Currently, my wife and I both max out our 403bs each year. What kind of allocation percentages do you recommend using the NYSDCP? My wife and I have about 12 years to retirement. Everything I read said it's a good idea to include bonds in your allocation strategy. I'm still ...
- Tue Sep 29, 2020 3:08 pm
- Forum: Personal Investments
- Topic: Investing Beyond 403bs Options?
- Replies: 105
- Views: 4606
Re: Investing Beyond 403bs Options?
Hello all,
I'm finally ready to enroll in the 457b Roth option in my school district.
I'm hoping that some of you can give me some feedback on my allocation percentages. Where did I get these numbers from? Boglehead Guide to Investing and The Coffee House Investor.
64% in NYSDCB Equity Index U/A (CIT) - Large Cap Funds
20% in NYSDCB US Debt Index U/A (CIT) - Bonds
16% in NYSDCP International Equity Fund - Passive
The passive fund has a cheaper ER. I did read that there is considerable debate on the topic of active and passive funds. I want to keep things simple
As always, your feedback and insight is always appreciated
I'm finally ready to enroll in the 457b Roth option in my school district.
I'm hoping that some of you can give me some feedback on my allocation percentages. Where did I get these numbers from? Boglehead Guide to Investing and The Coffee House Investor.
64% in NYSDCB Equity Index U/A (CIT) - Large Cap Funds
20% in NYSDCB US Debt Index U/A (CIT) - Bonds
16% in NYSDCP International Equity Fund - Passive
The passive fund has a cheaper ER. I did read that there is considerable debate on the topic of active and passive funds. I want to keep things simple

As always, your feedback and insight is always appreciated

- Sun Sep 27, 2020 11:58 am
- Forum: Personal Investments
- Topic: NYSDCP and the 3 fund portfolio
- Replies: 28
- Views: 3103
Re: NYSDCP and the 3 fund portfolio
Retire2022, So sorry...I didn't mean to derail the original post. I'm a newbie still learning the etiquette of this community. Again, my sincere apologies :( No worries no need to apologize I’m a direct communicating person. If you have additional questions to your particular situation you could always private message me on my profile. Additionally you and others could also search through my previous discussions on 457 on my profile. There are others here who I feel knows more about 457 plans in general such as krow36 and ruralavalon. We all learn from each other. I must state nationwide runs the NYSDCP website and it is worst than Vanguard website. The literature is hard to search for and navigate and locate. The plan rules are hidden as ...
- Sun Sep 27, 2020 10:02 am
- Forum: Personal Investments
- Topic: NYSDCP and the 3 fund portfolio
- Replies: 28
- Views: 3103
Re: NYSDCP and the 3 fund portfolio
Retire2022,
So sorry...I didn't mean to derail the original post.
I'm a newbie still learning the etiquette of this community.
Again, my sincere apologies
So sorry...I didn't mean to derail the original post.
I'm a newbie still learning the etiquette of this community.
Again, my sincere apologies

- Sat Sep 26, 2020 6:08 pm
- Forum: Personal Investments
- Topic: NYSDCP and the 3 fund portfolio
- Replies: 28
- Views: 3103
Re: NYSDCP and the 3 fund portfolio
Hello Boggleheads - new poster here. Love this site. Trying to put together a 3 fund portfolio within the New York State Deferred Compensation Plan. I don’t see the commonly recommended funds such as those in Taylor Larimore’s book and was hoping for some Bogglehead advice to get as close as possible to the 3 fund approach with what is there. Here is what I am looking at because they have the lowest net cost. NYSDCB US Debt Index Unitized Account (Invests in a portfolio of assets whose performance seeks to match the performance of the Barclays U.S. Aggregate Bond Index.) Net cost per $1,000: $0.20/$1,000 NYSDCB Equity Index Unitized Account (CIT) (A passive large-cap equity option that invests in a portfolio of assets whose performance see...
- Sat Sep 26, 2020 8:15 am
- Forum: Personal Investments
- Topic: NYSDCP and the 3 fund portfolio
- Replies: 28
- Views: 3103
Re: NYSDCP and the 3 fund portfolio
Thank you both. I took a look at the rollover chart in IRS 590a and it appears to confirm that this action would not be counted as income (so that's good to confirm). And very good to know that there would be no RMDs. Thanks so much for this discussion. You are very welcomed of course RMDs could change as well as tax rates. The 2017 tax rate will expire in 2025, so lots of things could change by the time you retire. One more thing, with pretax 457 you could elect to convert some of the pretax in service to Roth 457. If you should elect to do so you will be paying tax on the converted amount. Here is the literature on this: https://www.nysdcp.com/tcm/nysdcp/static/Roth_457_InPlan_Conversions.pdf?r=1 Beware if you are a NJ resident your Roth...
- Sat Sep 26, 2020 7:48 am
- Forum: Personal Investments
- Topic: Investing Beyond 403bs Options?
- Replies: 105
- Views: 4606
Re: Investing Beyond 403bs Options?
Well, it looks like we received some pretty good news. Our district will now offer a 457b (pre tax) and a 457b Roth (after tax) option with a max contribution of 19k for each option. No income limitations on either option. At the moment, my wife and I currently max out our 403bs to lower our taxable income. Should we consider contributing the max amount for the 457b Roth? Am I concerned about what our tax liability will look like upon retirement. As always, thanks for your input. Congratulations! When I suggested opening our 457 to all staff the superintendent laughed and said "you're the only one here who has any money!" I noticed some suggestions in another post relative to a Schwab option (as opposed to the CIT funds) offered ...
- Mon Sep 21, 2020 8:31 pm
- Forum: Personal Investments
- Topic: Investing Beyond 403bs Options?
- Replies: 105
- Views: 4606
Re: Investing Beyond 403bs Options?
Should I consider funding my 403b less and funding my 457b Roth more? Or should I try to max both? If you can max both, that appears best. Now that the powers that be have seen the benefit of a Roth 457, might they likewise add a Roth option to the 403b? If nothing has changed, the following still applies: Question is "do you understand why 'Roth > Traditional > Taxable' is likely correct for the situation you describe?" The ">" means "is preferable to". Ahh...yes. :happy Thank you Five K for the reply. Yes, I will do my best to try to convince the powers that be for a Roth option on the 403b :D In the meantime, should we consider splitting up our combined annual retirement contributions into two halves? 50% p...
- Mon Sep 21, 2020 7:09 pm
- Forum: Personal Investments
- Topic: Investing Beyond 403bs Options?
- Replies: 105
- Views: 4606
Re: Investing Beyond 403bs Options?
Required Minimum Distributions. You should read up on them and be aware of them, in your situation, because they could very well become an issue for you someday. Basically, starting at age 72 any tax-deferred accounts (tIRA, 401k, 403b, etc) have annual withdrawal requirements, because the government doesn't let you defer your income taxes forever. These withdrawals are all taxable ordinary income. If you have 200K+ of pension and SS income at that time, those RMDs will all come out in a high tax bracket, possibly even higher than the amount you're avoiding today. It's possible to be "too good" at tax deferral. Edit: Roth savings complement a pension really well. [/quote] Okay, so I did some homework on RMDs. My first reaction was...
- Mon Sep 21, 2020 4:00 pm
- Forum: Personal Investments
- Topic: Investing Beyond 403bs Options?
- Replies: 105
- Views: 4606
Re: Investing Beyond 403bs Options?
Our district recently informed me that we now have a 457b Roth option. Max 19k and no income limitations.UpsetRaptor wrote: ↑Mon Sep 21, 2020 3:56 pm If you'll have two pensions, plus SS, and have been maxing out two pre-tax 403(b) plans, you may be setting yourself up for some rough RMDs. I'd consider trying to do as much Roth as you can, wherever you can find some Roth space: Backdoor Roth IRA, find out if any of your 403b/457 has a Roth option you could switch some of your moving-forward savings to, etc.
Sorry, but what exactly is an RMD?
- Mon Sep 21, 2020 3:38 pm
- Forum: Personal Investments
- Topic: Investing Beyond 403bs Options?
- Replies: 105
- Views: 4606
Re: Investing Beyond 403bs Options?
[/quote]
Will you be eligible for pensions in addition to Social Security? About how much do you currently have in traditional tax-deferred accounts?
[/quote]
Hello Ruralavalon,
If you scroll to the top of this thread...I gradually spill my financial guts
Looking forward to your perspective
Will you be eligible for pensions in addition to Social Security? About how much do you currently have in traditional tax-deferred accounts?
[/quote]
Hello Ruralavalon,
If you scroll to the top of this thread...I gradually spill my financial guts

Looking forward to your perspective

- Mon Sep 21, 2020 2:51 pm
- Forum: Personal Investments
- Topic: Investing Beyond 403bs Options?
- Replies: 105
- Views: 4606
Re: Investing Beyond 403bs Options?
Well, it looks like we received some pretty good news.
Our district will now offer a 457b (pre tax) and a 457b Roth (after tax) option with a max contribution of 19k for each option. No income limitations on either option.
At the moment, my wife and I currently max out our 403bs to lower our taxable income.
Should we consider contributing the max amount for the 457b Roth? Am I concerned about what our tax liability will look like upon retirement.
As always, thanks for your input.
Our district will now offer a 457b (pre tax) and a 457b Roth (after tax) option with a max contribution of 19k for each option. No income limitations on either option.
At the moment, my wife and I currently max out our 403bs to lower our taxable income.
Should we consider contributing the max amount for the 457b Roth? Am I concerned about what our tax liability will look like upon retirement.
As always, thanks for your input.
- Sun Sep 13, 2020 6:44 pm
- Forum: Personal Investments
- Topic: How much are your 529 Contributions
- Replies: 133
- Views: 10707
Re: How much are your 529 Contributions
Here are some things to consider with a 529 account: 1. How do financial aid calculations factor in your 529 fund balance and your contributions? Yes, there is a mechanism by which the financial aid department will penalize or reduce your expected family contribution. "The 529 plans owned by college students or their parents count as assets and reduce need-based aid by a maximum of 5.64 percent of the asset's value". 2. Will something like a Roth account be better suited for college savings? Most higher education institutions, don't take into account your retirement fund balance...only the contributions you make to retirement accounts. 3. Can you finance your retirement? Can you finance college? My take on college savings is the f...
- Wed Sep 09, 2020 5:16 pm
- Forum: Personal Investments
- Topic: Investing Beyond 403bs Options?
- Replies: 105
- Views: 4606
Re: Investing Beyond 403bs Options?
Question: Is there a local advisory firm coordinating with the 457 plan or does your district have you going directly to a “generic” NYSDCP account person? You can also access fund info and more here: https://www.nysdcp.com/iApp/tcm/nysdcp/about/index.jsp I believe the NYSDCB U.S. Debt Index Unitized Account (CIT) would be your bond index and NYSDCB Equity Index Unitized Account (CIT) your S&P 500 Index. It originally sounded like you were talking about investing an additional 6,000 per spouse. I still like previous option #2 if that’s the case. The 403b and 457 would allow for 19,500 for each spouse = 78,000 in total. Your options are now wide open. Well, after reaching out to my school district they informed me that the 457b option i...
- Wed Sep 09, 2020 5:00 pm
- Forum: Personal Investments
- Topic: Investing Beyond 403bs Options?
- Replies: 105
- Views: 4606
- Tue Sep 08, 2020 7:01 pm
- Forum: Personal Investments
- Topic: Investing Beyond 403bs Options?
- Replies: 105
- Views: 4606
Re: Investing Beyond 403bs Options?
I'm sorry FiveK, I not clear on the question...
[/quote]
Question is "do you understand why 'Roth > Traditional > Taxable' is likely correct for the situation you describe?" The ">" means "is preferable to".
[/quote]
Ahh...yes.
I'm trying to teach myself to look at the years in my retirement with a different lens. I need to think about how the financial mechanisms of our government will impact my retirement nest egg in the years of retirement.
Thanks again FiveK
[/quote]
Question is "do you understand why 'Roth > Traditional > Taxable' is likely correct for the situation you describe?" The ">" means "is preferable to".
[/quote]
Ahh...yes.
I'm trying to teach myself to look at the years in my retirement with a different lens. I need to think about how the financial mechanisms of our government will impact my retirement nest egg in the years of retirement.
Thanks again FiveK

- Tue Sep 08, 2020 6:19 pm
- Forum: Personal Investments
- Topic: Investing Beyond 403bs Options?
- Replies: 105
- Views: 4606
Re: Investing Beyond 403bs Options?
I'm sorry FiveK, I not clear on the question...FiveK wrote: ↑Tue Sep 08, 2020 6:06 pmPreviously you mentioned also being in the 24% bracket now.
For a 24% marginal tax rate now and later, and making the maximum allowable contributions to traditional or Roth now, probably
- Roth is best
- Traditional (along with a taxable "side account" for the pre-tax amount above the contribution limit) is second best
- Taxable (instead of either traditional or Roth) is last.
Is it clear why that is likely the situation?
- Tue Sep 08, 2020 6:04 pm
- Forum: Personal Investments
- Topic: Investing Beyond 403bs Options?
- Replies: 105
- Views: 4606
Re: Investing Beyond 403bs Options?
The plan is to retire at 61 or 62.terran wrote: ↑Tue Sep 08, 2020 6:00 pmOne thing to note about the Roth 457(b) is that it negates the early withdrawal benefit that a 457(b) normally has. That might not be a problem if you plan to retire after 59.5, but if you plan to retire early the penalty free early withdrawal is a nice feature.
- Tue Sep 08, 2020 6:01 pm
- Forum: Personal Investments
- Topic: Investing Beyond 403bs Options?
- Replies: 105
- Views: 4606
Re: Investing Beyond 403bs Options?
Here are the options for my district's new 457b plan:
a. Option 1 is titled "Do it for Me" -
T. Rowe Price Retirement Date Trusts. The are all Target Date Retirement Funds
b. Option 2 is titled (Do it Yourself)
c. Option 3 is title (Specialty Options)
I tried to copy and paste some of the funds listed, but the formatting was a bit wacky.
Here is the pdf link: https://www.nysdcp.com/tcm/nysdcp/stati ... 20.pdf?r=1
a. Option 1 is titled "Do it for Me" -
T. Rowe Price Retirement Date Trusts. The are all Target Date Retirement Funds
b. Option 2 is titled (Do it Yourself)
c. Option 3 is title (Specialty Options)
I tried to copy and paste some of the funds listed, but the formatting was a bit wacky.
Here is the pdf link: https://www.nysdcp.com/tcm/nysdcp/stati ... 20.pdf?r=1
- Tue Sep 08, 2020 5:50 pm
- Forum: Personal Investments
- Topic: Investing Beyond 403bs Options?
- Replies: 105
- Views: 4606
Re: [403b contribution questions]
Look to see if Roth contributions are permitted.
[/quote]
Yes, I'm getting more details. Just got the news today.
[/quote]
Yes, I'm getting more details. Just got the news today.
- Tue Sep 08, 2020 5:50 pm
- Forum: Personal Investments
- Topic: Investing Beyond 403bs Options?
- Replies: 105
- Views: 4606