When do you invest in your Roth?
When do you invest in your Roth?
My Roth is 100% Vanguard Total Intl Stock Index Admiral. I'm planning to contribute the max to my Roth in the next week.
When do you invest in your Roth? Beginning of the year? After 'really bad days'?
Thanks,
Iced Tea
When do you invest in your Roth? Beginning of the year? After 'really bad days'?
Thanks,
Iced Tea
-
- Posts: 397
- Joined: Wed Sep 15, 2010 11:52 am
Re: When do you invest in your Roth?
I used to put in $500 a month for the first 2 months and $400 a month for the next 10 months. Now I just put it in as soon as I can.
-
- Posts: 1221
- Joined: Tue Nov 01, 2011 11:28 am
Re: When do you invest in your Roth?
As soon as I get around to it in January, without any consideration of if it is an "up" day or a "down" day. A girl could drive herself crazy worrying about that!
Re: When do you invest in your Roth?
Just put it in.
Transaction pending.
Transaction pending.
- interplanetjanet
- Posts: 2226
- Joined: Mon Jan 24, 2011 3:52 pm
- Location: the wilds of central California
Re: When do you invest in your Roth?
I contribute when my yearly bonus clears, in February. I just put a full $5k in all at once, my income tends to be bursty between bonuses, ESPP and company stock.
-janet
-janet
Re: When do you invest in your Roth?
His Roth: Monthly DCA over a year, $416.66 (Target 2035)
Her Roth: 5K at start of the year. (Target 2035/Dodge&Cox International)
Her Roth: 5K at start of the year. (Target 2035/Dodge&Cox International)
Re: When do you invest in your Roth?
As soon as we have the money, but usually $1K a month each until done. I used to think earlier is better, but after last year - when we were almost fully in by July - I'm not that bothered now. (It seems to me that a lot of new money gets invested after April 15 and there's a little bubble at the end of April.)
-
- Posts: 13356
- Joined: Tue Mar 23, 2010 1:45 pm
- Location: Reading, MA
Re: When do you invest in your Roth?
I try to put my $6K per year as soon as feasible, but I'm maxed out on my 403b funds as well and there's not a huge excess of $$ left over after paying other commitments.
So it's been taking a variable amount of time the past few years...
So it's been taking a variable amount of time the past few years...
Attempted new signature...
Re: When do you invest in your Roth?
Did my 5k last week for 2012.
Re: When do you invest in your Roth?
Put 10k in (for 2011 and 2012) a week ago and for my wife 10k today. Going to get the total bond fund.
Re: When do you invest in your Roth?
DCA monthly 416.66 each for both his/hers.
Re: When do you invest in your Roth?
I see that you have received numerous responses to "when" which was your question, but not many explainations of "why".
The general concensus is contribute as soon as possible, and I agree. Put your money to work tax free as soon as possible. And if you contirbute in January of each year, you are essentially dollar cost averaging, so don't try to time the market. Think long term.
Your allocation is another question, based on age and risk tolerance. In general it's best to put your least tax efficient holdings in a Roth. So for instance, I hold my REIT ETF (VNQ) in my Roth.
And because a Roth doesn't have a RMD (Required Minimum Distribution) that a 401k does, I view the Roth as having a longer investment horizon. My annual contribution generally goes to value tilted equity ETF's.
I hold the majority of my bond funds in my 401k, and the growth portion of my portfolio in a taxable brokerage account. Here is a link to a Boglehead discussion of tax efficient fund placement that you might find helpful:
http://www.bogleheads.org/wiki/Principl ... _Placement
The general concensus is contribute as soon as possible, and I agree. Put your money to work tax free as soon as possible. And if you contirbute in January of each year, you are essentially dollar cost averaging, so don't try to time the market. Think long term.
Your allocation is another question, based on age and risk tolerance. In general it's best to put your least tax efficient holdings in a Roth. So for instance, I hold my REIT ETF (VNQ) in my Roth.
And because a Roth doesn't have a RMD (Required Minimum Distribution) that a 401k does, I view the Roth as having a longer investment horizon. My annual contribution generally goes to value tilted equity ETF's.
I hold the majority of my bond funds in my 401k, and the growth portion of my portfolio in a taxable brokerage account. Here is a link to a Boglehead discussion of tax efficient fund placement that you might find helpful:
http://www.bogleheads.org/wiki/Principl ... _Placement
Re: When do you invest in your Roth?
We lump summed in this week, 5K me and 5K my wife. 100% Vanguard TIPs fund each.
Re: When do you invest in your Roth?
Wow, am I the only one who puts in $200 every biweekly paycheck?
Re: When do you invest in your Roth?
Usually right at the start of the year.
However, my Roth is entirely in bonds for the tax advantages of holding bonds in IRAs, and I'm currently slightly over my desired AA in bonds, so I'm going to contribute to a taxable account first this year to get my AA where I want it, then to the IRA later.
Someone stop me if this is a dumb idea.
However, my Roth is entirely in bonds for the tax advantages of holding bonds in IRAs, and I'm currently slightly over my desired AA in bonds, so I'm going to contribute to a taxable account first this year to get my AA where I want it, then to the IRA later.
Someone stop me if this is a dumb idea.
-
- Posts: 333
- Joined: Mon May 31, 2010 5:39 pm
Re: When do you invest in your Roth?
I contribute monthly by automatic transfer from my checking account. I will have to do a few contributions manually this year as I am in the process of moving my account from a mega-bank to a smaller one.
Re: When do you invest in your Roth?
I put some money today into my Roth as I got my first paycheck of 2012, so I have earned income. I do not contribute as some others do until I have the earned income.
The money went into the cash sweep account, so I will decide what to buy in the next few days. In the past, I just invested into bond ETF shares, specifically VCSH until a really bad day occurred, then I exchanged into equities. I am almost always underweighted in bonds, so I feel very comfortable adding to a bond fund with each paycheck until a ReallyBadDay occurs.
The money went into the cash sweep account, so I will decide what to buy in the next few days. In the past, I just invested into bond ETF shares, specifically VCSH until a really bad day occurred, then I exchanged into equities. I am almost always underweighted in bonds, so I feel very comfortable adding to a bond fund with each paycheck until a ReallyBadDay occurs.
- englishgirl
- Posts: 2508
- Joined: Thu Mar 01, 2007 4:34 pm
- Location: FL
-
- Posts: 333
- Joined: Mon May 31, 2010 5:39 pm
Re: When do you invest in your Roth?
Who is your IRA custodian? Mine won't do biweekly and since that's how I get paid I'd really prefer to make contributions on the same schedule.englishgirl wrote:$208 every biweekly paycheck.
+ $8 during January.
Re: When do you invest in your Roth?
I put $100 once a week - normally every Friday - until I reach the annual maximum which for me is $5,000.
Trust yourself, Break the rules, Don't be afraid to fail, Don't listen to naysayers, Work your butt off. "It is in your moments of decision that your destiny is shaped. Choose now and well"
- englishgirl
- Posts: 2508
- Joined: Thu Mar 01, 2007 4:34 pm
- Location: FL
Re: When do you invest in your Roth?
Ahh, well, now I come to think about it, it's bimonthly. I keep forgetting that the company switched from biweekly pay to bimonthly pay (meaning, two per month, not every two months! Probably should be called semi-monthly) to save money. Sorry about that! The account is at Vanguard.kyounge1956 wrote:Who is your IRA custodian? Mine won't do biweekly and since that's how I get paid I'd really prefer to make contributions on the same schedule.englishgirl wrote:$208 every biweekly paycheck.
+ $8 during January.
Sarah
Re: When do you invest in your Roth?
i set up the automatic investment of 192.30 every two weeks on payday. thanks for posting the thread since it reminded me i have to tweak one to get the last twenty cents in.
- ruralavalon
- Posts: 26352
- Joined: Sat Feb 02, 2008 9:29 am
- Location: Illinois
Re: When do you invest in your Roth?
Now retired.
When working I had extremely erratic income, and we added new money in a lump sum whenever we had the cash.
When working I had extremely erratic income, and we added new money in a lump sum whenever we had the cash.
"Everything should be as simple as it is, but not simpler." - Albert Einstein |
Wiki article link: Bogleheads® investment philosophy
Re: When do you invest in your Roth?
Usually January 1st (well, 2nd or 3rd), but waiting this year, potentially to March of 2013 (whenever taxes our taxes are "finalized") to see how Roth vs. TIRA will affect some tax credits and getting into the 15% tax bracket. An extra 14 months of tax-free growth om $10,000 isn't worth losing out on some tax credits (or free dividends).
Re: When do you invest in your Roth?
Why do you ask it this way? Isn't one of the main decisions, how much to put into Trad and how much into Roth?icedtea wrote:When do you invest in your Roth?
Re: When do you invest in your Roth?
happymob,happymob wrote:Usually January 1st (well, 2nd or 3rd), but waiting this year, potentially to March of 2013 (whenever taxes our taxes are "finalized") to see how Roth vs. TIRA will affect some tax credits and getting into the 15% tax bracket. An extra 14 months of tax-free growth om $10,000 isn't worth losing out on some tax credits (or free dividends).
I'm no expert but I have a similar situation and was thinking one could move forward now and invest in their Roth, and then if it becomes apparent when doing their 2012 taxes that it would have been more beneficial to go the TIRA route, the prior Roth contributions could then be recharacterized?
Re: When do you invest in your Roth?
That's probably true. It's a question of whether or not I want to bother with this.bpg1234 wrote:happymob,happymob wrote:Usually January 1st (well, 2nd or 3rd), but waiting this year, potentially to March of 2013 (whenever taxes our taxes are "finalized") to see how Roth vs. TIRA will affect some tax credits and getting into the 15% tax bracket. An extra 14 months of tax-free growth om $10,000 isn't worth losing out on some tax credits (or free dividends).
I'm no expert but I have a similar situation and was thinking one could move forward now and invest in their Roth, and then if it becomes apparent when doing their 2012 taxes that it would have been more beneficial to go the TIRA route, the prior Roth contributions could then be recharacterized?
In reality, with the backdoor both apparently available to us, we should probably go the TIRA route ASAP and recharacterize later to a Roth if it won't significantly hurt any tax credits (we would then get OK state tax deduction on the TIRA contribution and not have to pay it back on the recharacterization). Assuming we do TIRA now and Roth recharacterization at some later date, we potentially have to pay Federal (but not state) taxes on any gains during the gap, but that is certainly no worse than holding the money in taxable until later to begin with.
-
- Posts: 156
- Joined: Mon Jul 05, 2010 1:10 pm
Re: When do you invest in your Roth?
Vanguard deducts $416.66 for me and $416.66 for my wife from my checking account on the first of every month.
Re: When do you invest in your Roth?
We funded our Roths, both bond funds, the first day possible this year, on Jan. 3.
The fundamental things apply as time goes by -- Herman Hupfeld
Re: When do you invest in your Roth?
For the last few years, I've been lump summing everything early in the year. This year, on Jan 3, I moved $6K into her IRA VIPSX. On Jan 3, I moved $6K into my IRA money market. On Jan 4, I converted that to my roth small cap value admiral. [note - vanguard warned me about the tax consequences of this conversion and I just smiled]
- zaboomafoozarg
- Posts: 2431
- Joined: Sun Jun 12, 2011 12:34 pm
Re: When do you invest in your Roth?
Same here.RonV wrote:We funded our Roths, both bond funds, the first day possible this year, on Jan. 3.
-
- Posts: 160
- Joined: Mon Jul 07, 2008 10:15 pm
Re: When do you invest in your Roth?
Last couple years it's seem to have been "as the extra cash builds up in our regular checking accounts/online savings acct we wish to close out". Earlier this week we purchased $6200 of the $10000 for this year, half of it being the remnants of a Dollar Savings Direct account that used to be competitive but has long been beaten by our ING Direct acct. A few years ago I'd laugh at the prospect of being down to one online savings acct, but here we are. ....We'll probably top the IRAs off in a second shot here this spring.
There have been times I considered equal contributions throughout the years automatically, but with the relative percentages we wish to have there was no way to top out at the full $5k to the dollar, so I said screw it.
There have been times I considered equal contributions throughout the years automatically, but with the relative percentages we wish to have there was no way to top out at the full $5k to the dollar, so I said screw it.
-
- Posts: 1223
- Joined: Tue Jun 19, 2007 4:46 pm
Re: When do you invest in your Roth?
When we get the money during the year. Most years during the Summer after we get a lump sum distribution. Last year early because we sold a house in the last quarter of CY10 and rather than put the whole thing down on a new home put the money in the Roth early and put the lump sum towards the house. Would have been better off to have waited, but either way you pay your money and take your chances.
Re: When do you invest in your Roth?
sumac55 wrote: Your allocation is another question, based on age and risk tolerance. In general it's best to put your least tax efficient holdings in a Roth. So for instance, I hold my REIT ETF (VNQ) in my Roth.
And because a Roth doesn't have a RMD (Required Minimum Distribution) that a 401k does, I view the Roth as having a longer investment horizon. My annual contribution generally goes to value tilted equity ETF's.
I hold the majority of my bond funds in my 401k, and the growth portion of my portfolio in a taxable brokerage account. Here is a link to a Boglehead discussion of tax efficient fund placement that you might find helpful:
http://www.bogleheads.org/wiki/Principl ... _Placement
Thanks. My least tax efficient funds (my bonds) are in my 401k and Rollover IRA. I don't hold any RIETs. I posted another question with my portfolio. Maybe you (and others) could take a look?
http://www.bogleheads.org/forum/viewtop ... =1&t=88967
Re: When do you invest in your Roth?
My strategy is contribute with my bonus in Jan - full 5k. It will go to a bond fund and then steadily 1k every 3 months in to EM and small value. If I see a >5-10% hit with in a month, I will move 2k instead of 1k. Last year the last 3k went all in during august end. Overall, worked ok.
When in doubt, http://www.bogleheads.org/forum/viewtopic.php?f=1&t=79939
Re: When do you invest in your Roth?
We put a little in ours after each paycheck. I try to time it in on bad days for fun, but really just limit myself to the two week period after getting paid and put it in regardless of what the market is doing.
Never underestimate the power of the force of low cost index funds.
-
- Posts: 25625
- Joined: Thu Apr 05, 2007 8:20 pm
- Location: New York
Re: When do you invest in your Roth?
When the cashflow allows.
"One should invest based on their need, ability and willingness to take risk - Larry Swedroe" Asking Portfolio Questions
Re: When do you invest in your Roth?
Once I'm sure how much I'm allowed to contribute, if any (which is sadly late in the year).When do you invest in your Roth?
"Do not value money for any more nor any less than its worth; it is a good servant but a bad master" - Alexandre Dumas
Re: When do you invest in your Roth?
Early January.... move money from Money Market account that was funded last year through monthly contributions.
Simplicity is the ultimate sophistication. ~Leonardo DaVinci
Re: When do you invest in your Roth?
After putting 5k in at one shot in July 2008 in response to a windfall, I now DCA throughout the year, every two weeks.
Re: When do you invest in your Roth?
I tend to fund mine and my wife's Roth once my taxes are figured out.
Re: When do you invest in your Roth?
well if your savings/investments are large ( 50-100K or more ) and have cash sitting on sidelines one time 5k investment doesn't make a difference .
Last edited by manuvns on Wed Jan 18, 2012 9:54 am, edited 1 time in total.
Thanks!
-
- Posts: 41
- Joined: Sun Jun 24, 2007 5:06 am
Re: When do you invest in your Roth?
I invest it all in January every year.
Re: When do you invest in your Roth?
Vanguard's automated investment feature automatically maximizes the contribution for the year. I'm surprised at how many people are doing this manually. I set it up to maximize twice a month, and it ends up as $208.33, and 0.08 cents is added to get spot on to $5,000.
Re: When do you invest in your Roth?
This is what I use. The biweekly version is $192.30 per paycheck, with the extra $0.20 being tacked on the first contribution.4stripes wrote:Vanguard's automated investment feature automatically maximizes the contribution for the year. I'm surprised at how many people are doing this manually. I set it up to maximize twice a month, and it ends up as $208.33, and 0.08 cents is added to get spot on to $5,000.
Re: When do you invest in your Roth?
$416, once a month, for both his and hers. I don't claim it's better, it's just how we do it.
Retirement investing is a marathon.
Re: When do you invest in your Roth?
I know I should lump sum to maximize returns but my stomach just can't handle it. I DCA monthly into his and hers, both Vanguard Total International Index.
Re: When do you invest in your Roth?
We put some in monthly, but we do the final contributions after the end of the tax year so that we can decide how much to put in traditional for the deduction.
- tnhooper45
- Posts: 92
- Joined: Sun Feb 27, 2011 6:34 pm
Re: When do you invest in your Roth?
I'm 24, just started my Roth last summer, only contributed $4200 because of earned income. This year I will make over $5K although I have not earned any money as of yet. Would you advise me to go ahead and start throwing money in? Seems like I have heard that contributions made before tax date would maximize the previous year's IRA if I didn't contribute the whole $5K (which I didn't=$4200). Does that make sense?bucksfan2 wrote:I tend to fund mine and my wife's Roth once my taxes are figured out.
Re: When do you invest in your Roth?
Its my understanding that if you invest before the income taxes you can place that contribution in the prior year. For example if you invest 5K in March of 2012 that can be applied to your 2011 contributions. I started investing in a Roth in March so I continue to do it that way. I like to wait until my xmas bills, property taxes, insurance, are all paid and there isn't a tax surprise before I contribute. It may not be the best way to do things but it gives me peace of mind.tnhooper45 wrote:I'm 24, just started my Roth last summer, only contributed $4200 because of earned income. This year I will make over $5K although I have not earned any money as of yet. Would you advise me to go ahead and start throwing money in? Seems like I have heard that contributions made before tax date would maximize the previous year's IRA if I didn't contribute the whole $5K (which I didn't=$4200). Does that make sense?bucksfan2 wrote:I tend to fund mine and my wife's Roth once my taxes are figured out.
If you could only contribute $4200 due to income limits I would imagine that you can't contribute anymore to your 2011 contributions. I don't have a problem with putting in a lump sum because the returns I want are decades off. If someone else has any better advice I am sure we both would want to hear it.