10 year Broker CDs vs 10 year Treasury
- TheTimeLord
- Posts: 12130
- Joined: Fri Jul 26, 2013 2:05 pm
10 year Broker CDs vs 10 year Treasury
I was taking a look at the broker CDs being offered by Fidelity and came across a 10 yr 3.20% non-callable offering. Is there any reason I would not want this over a 10 year Treasury if I was going to make my purchase July 1?
IMHO, Investing should be about living the life you want, not avoiding the life you fear. |
Run, You Clever Boy! [9085]
Re: 10 year Broker CDs vs 10 year Treasury
Liquidity.
Though under FDIC insurance limits this is for most individuals probably a much better deal.
Though under FDIC insurance limits this is for most individuals probably a much better deal.
-
- Posts: 9883
- Joined: Mon Sep 07, 2009 2:57 pm
- Location: Milky Way
Re: 10 year Broker CDs vs 10 year Treasury
Depends upon your goals for this money. There are two risks that non-callable CD's have compared to treasuries of the same maturity - reduced liquidity and future interest is not guaranteed (which is actually a form of call risk). Also, the CD's are taxed by the state whereas the treasuries are not. It you plan to hold until maturity and especially in a tax-advantaged account, the brokerage CD is a fine choice relative to the treasury.
Best regards, -Op |
|
"In the middle of difficulty lies opportunity." Einstein
- TheTimeLord
- Posts: 12130
- Joined: Fri Jul 26, 2013 2:05 pm
Re: 10 year Broker CDs vs 10 year Treasury
But as Broker CDs they can be traded on the secondary market. So are you just pointing out is may be a smaller less liquid market than treasuries? This is a very meaningful question for me since I have 2 buckets for my money, one pre-SS and one post-SS. Since post-SS is over 10 years away these might fit nicely into that portfolio.lack_ey wrote:Liquidity.
Though under FDIC insurance limits this is for most individuals probably a much better deal.
IMHO, Investing should be about living the life you want, not avoiding the life you fear. |
Run, You Clever Boy! [9085]
- TheTimeLord
- Posts: 12130
- Joined: Fri Jul 26, 2013 2:05 pm
Re: 10 year Broker CDs vs 10 year Treasury
I should have mentioned I am planning to hold these in a tax advantaged account that if all goes to plan won't be accessed until after the CD matures.Call_Me_Op wrote:Depends upon your goals for this money. There are two risks that non-callable CD's have compared to treasuries of the same maturity - reduced liquidity and future interest is not guaranteed (which is actually a form of call risk). Also, the CD's are taxed by the state whereas the treasuries are not. It you plan to hold until maturity and especially in a tax-advantaged account, the brokerage CD is a fine choice relative to the treasury.
IMHO, Investing should be about living the life you want, not avoiding the life you fear. |
Run, You Clever Boy! [9085]
-
- Posts: 9883
- Joined: Mon Sep 07, 2009 2:57 pm
- Location: Milky Way
Re: 10 year Broker CDs vs 10 year Treasury
It may be a lot less liquid; the secondary market for them is much smaller relative to treasuries. When you want to sell, buyers may be few and you may need to slash the price considerably. I would not buy a brokered CD with the hope to sell prior to maturity.TheTimeLord wrote:But as Broker CDs they can be traded on the secondary market. So are you just pointing out is may be a smaller less liquid market than treasuries? This is a very meaningful question for me since I have 2 buckets for my money, one pre-SS and one post-SS. Since post-SS is over 10 years away these might fit nicely into that portfolio.lack_ey wrote:Liquidity.
Though under FDIC insurance limits this is for most individuals probably a much better deal.
US treasuries are the most liquid securities in the world. This is partly why demand is so high - and yields relatively low.
Best regards, -Op |
|
"In the middle of difficulty lies opportunity." Einstein
Re: 10 year Broker CDs vs 10 year Treasury
From a market timing perspective, no. 10 year CDs regularly yield ~1% more than a 10 year Treasury. Right now that gap is only about 70 basis points.
Brokered CD rates tend to lag changes in Treasury rates somewhat.
Brokered CD rates tend to lag changes in Treasury rates somewhat.
Re: 10 year Broker CDs vs 10 year Treasury
10 years is a long time. If I were going to lock up a maturity that long I'd be inclined to look at a Jan 2026 Tip - or maybe stretch to 27. Or ladder 26-31.
I always wanted to be a procrastinator.
Re: 10 year Broker CDs vs 10 year Treasury
Usually, especially for retirement allocations, one does not need all their money on hand with immediacy, and trading some liquidity for some part of it (i.e. don't go all in, but for a slice) for higher returns may be useful. In any case, it's not like you're locking this up in real estate, collectibles, private equity, or something like that. The reduced liquidity is a concern, but you are not going way down the spectrum to serious illiquidity. If you want the extra 70 bp or so, go for it.
All kinds of other nominal fixed income are also in trouble (regardless of whether or not you sell or want to) if inflation spikes, so this is not especially a problem with this instrument.
All kinds of other nominal fixed income are also in trouble (regardless of whether or not you sell or want to) if inflation spikes, so this is not especially a problem with this instrument.
Re: 10 year Broker CDs vs 10 year Treasury
Since you are holding for the "long haul" (as you mentioned), a ten-year ladder of ten-year brokered CDs is optimal. Buy one this year, another next year, and so on. Brokered CDs at ten years are about as good as it gets these days.
-
- Posts: 9883
- Joined: Mon Sep 07, 2009 2:57 pm
- Location: Milky Way
Re: 10 year Broker CDs vs 10 year Treasury
That approach is OK for new money, but may not be so good if you currently have money in cash you'd like to invest.john94549 wrote:Since you are holding for the "long haul" (as you mentioned), a ten-year ladder of ten-year brokered CDs is optimal. Buy one this year, another next year, and so on. Brokered CDs at ten years are about as good as it gets these days.
Best regards, -Op |
|
"In the middle of difficulty lies opportunity." Einstein
- TheTimeLord
- Posts: 12130
- Joined: Fri Jul 26, 2013 2:05 pm
Re: 10 year Broker CDs vs 10 year Treasury
Could you expand on your reasoning.Call_Me_Op wrote: That approach is OK for new money, but may not be so good if you currently have money in cash you'd like to invest.
IMHO, Investing should be about living the life you want, not avoiding the life you fear. |
Run, You Clever Boy! [9085]
Re: 10 year Broker CDs vs 10 year Treasury
Some very good points made above.
Let me expand/elaborate on "Call Risk" of Brokered CDs. If the issuing bank fails, or is acquired/merged into another bank - the CD may be redeemed before maturity or, in some cases, allowed to continue - but at a lower rate.
Let me expand/elaborate on "Call Risk" of Brokered CDs. If the issuing bank fails, or is acquired/merged into another bank - the CD may be redeemed before maturity or, in some cases, allowed to continue - but at a lower rate.
-
- Posts: 9883
- Joined: Mon Sep 07, 2009 2:57 pm
- Location: Milky Way
Re: 10 year Broker CDs vs 10 year Treasury
Sure. If this approach is applied to existing funds, those funds will not be fully invested for 9 years.TheTimeLord wrote:Could you expand on your reasoning.Call_Me_Op wrote: That approach is OK for new money, but may not be so good if you currently have money in cash you'd like to invest.
Best regards, -Op |
|
"In the middle of difficulty lies opportunity." Einstein
Re: 10 year Broker CDs vs 10 year Treasury
Seeing that these will be in tax deferred accounts and that these instruments will be held to maturity, I would buy the brokered CDs. The biggest risk that I see is that the bank issuing the CD could run into trouble and be taken over by another bank. In this case, you may find the rate on your CD being cut. The second biggest risk is a liquidity risk, you would get a better price on a Treasury than on a brokered CD if you needed to sell for some reason.TheTimeLord wrote:I was taking a look at the broker CDs being offered by Fidelity and came across a 10 yr 3.20% non-callable offering. Is there any reason I would not want this over a 10 year Treasury if I was going to make my purchase July 1?
The 10 year treasury yield right now is 2.48%. You are picking up 72 basis points on a CD which still has the government guarantee. You could also check into 10 year TIPS too.
A fool and his money are good for business.
-
- Posts: 15371
- Joined: Fri Apr 10, 2015 12:29 am
Re: 10 year Broker CDs vs 10 year Treasury
deleted
Last edited by Northern Flicker on Thu Mar 31, 2022 2:49 pm, edited 1 time in total.
-
- Posts: 1116
- Joined: Tue Jul 29, 2014 11:29 am
Re: 10 year Broker CDs vs 10 year Treasury
Understatement of the year. A brokered CD is a UFO (you friggin’ own it). It's bought to be held to maturity.Call_Me_Op wrote:It may be a lot less liquid; the secondary market for them is much smaller relative to treasuries
The argument for Treasuries is the yield curve roll down: the closer the issue gets to maturity it may increase in value, maintain value, or not significantly lose value. Also, Treasuries are state tax free and, if you’re so inclined, are excellent to use as margin.
Ten years is a long time.
Re: 10 year Broker CDs vs 10 year Treasury
Actually, it isn't. We're 68, and have been investing since our 20's (roughly 45 years).skepticalobserver wrote:
Ten years is a long time.
-
- Posts: 331
- Joined: Mon Sep 22, 2008 2:03 pm
Re: 10 year Broker CDs vs 10 year Treasury
*** "Is there any reason I would not want this over a 10 year Treasury if I was going to make my purchase July 1?" ***
Full disclosure. I am perhaps the biggest fan of FDIC insured brokerage firms CD's on this board. The answer to your question is no. Only make sure you are within FDIC insurance limits. (Schwab only offers CD's from FDIC insured institutions. Should be the same with the other brokers - but, check.)
Full disclosure. I am perhaps the biggest fan of FDIC insured brokerage firms CD's on this board. The answer to your question is no. Only make sure you are within FDIC insurance limits. (Schwab only offers CD's from FDIC insured institutions. Should be the same with the other brokers - but, check.)
- TheTimeLord
- Posts: 12130
- Joined: Fri Jul 26, 2013 2:05 pm
Re: 10 year Broker CDs vs 10 year Treasury
Am I correct to assume FDIC limits apply to holdings of a specific institutions CDs and not my total brokerage CD holdings?muddlehead wrote:*** "Is there any reason I would not want this over a 10 year Treasury if I was going to make my purchase July 1?" ***
Full disclosure. I am perhaps the biggest fan of FDIC insured brokerage firms CD's on this board. The answer to your question is no. Only make sure you are within FDIC insurance limits. (Schwab only offers CD's from FDIC insured institutions. Should be the same with the other brokers - but, check.)
IMHO, Investing should be about living the life you want, not avoiding the life you fear. |
Run, You Clever Boy! [9085]
-
- Posts: 2365
- Joined: Tue May 27, 2014 3:50 pm
Re: 10 year Broker CDs vs 10 year Treasury
You are correct.TheTimeLord wrote: Am I correct to assume FDIC limits apply to holdings of a specific institutions CDs and not my total brokerage CD holdings?
Re: 10 year Broker CDs vs 10 year Treasury
I think the "long" refers to duration of exposure to inflation risk for a nominal security, not personal duration (lifespan).john94549 wrote:Actually, it isn't. We're 68, and have been investing since our 20's (roughly 45 years).skepticalobserver wrote:
Ten years is a long time.
I always wanted to be a procrastinator.
Re: 10 year Broker CDs vs 10 year Treasury
To the OP: I would buy the CD.
"The two most important days in someone's life are the day that they are born and the day they discover why." -John Maxwell
Re: 10 year Broker CDs vs 10 year Treasury
Yes - this is true. The one, very unlikely, exception would be if you held the FDIC limit at two different banks, and those banks merged (or similar) - you could then be over the limit. There is some kind of "grace period" in such a case. This possibility, however, is so unlikely that I would not worry about it.trueblueky wrote:You are correct.TheTimeLord wrote: Am I correct to assume FDIC limits apply to holdings of a specific institutions CDs and not my total brokerage CD holdings?
Re: 10 year Broker CDs vs 10 year Treasury
I own some 10 year brokered CDs (now 9 ytm). I intend to buy some more once some other CDs mature later this year.
Consider buying some secondary market CDs. New issue CDs (at Vanguard) are available for 1-5, 7 and 10 year (not sure of some of shorter maturities) but 5, 7 and 10 for sure.
You can also buy secondary market CDs with ytm 6-9 years. The only caveat I am aware of is that if the issuer is taken over by FDIC, the CDs will not be paid/redeemed by FDIC above par value. So, if you pay above 100, you can lose principle. There have been posts about this which likely use better language so do a bit of research to confirm this.
I have never tried secondary market CDs bidding. I have bought secondary market CDs where the seller lists the price /ytm that is acceptable with no opportunity to buy at less than that price.
10 years is a long time, imo but rates are what they are. The last i looked (months ago) the feds inflation expectation was 1.7/1.8%, with a target of 2%.
Of course, if interest rates go to 5% on a 10 year treasury in 5 years, I will have some regrets but who knows what will happen.
jim
Consider buying some secondary market CDs. New issue CDs (at Vanguard) are available for 1-5, 7 and 10 year (not sure of some of shorter maturities) but 5, 7 and 10 for sure.
You can also buy secondary market CDs with ytm 6-9 years. The only caveat I am aware of is that if the issuer is taken over by FDIC, the CDs will not be paid/redeemed by FDIC above par value. So, if you pay above 100, you can lose principle. There have been posts about this which likely use better language so do a bit of research to confirm this.
I have never tried secondary market CDs bidding. I have bought secondary market CDs where the seller lists the price /ytm that is acceptable with no opportunity to buy at less than that price.
10 years is a long time, imo but rates are what they are. The last i looked (months ago) the feds inflation expectation was 1.7/1.8%, with a target of 2%.
Of course, if interest rates go to 5% on a 10 year treasury in 5 years, I will have some regrets but who knows what will happen.
jim
-
- Posts: 88
- Joined: Sun Mar 01, 2015 7:46 pm
Re: 10 year Broker CDs vs 10 year Treasury
Because of this lag, there is a 100 bp spread on 10 year CDs/treasuries at Schwab at the moment, and about a 60 bp spread on the 5 year. Today is a pretty good day to buy brokered CDs.stlutz wrote:From a market timing perspective, no. 10 year CDs regularly yield ~1% more than a 10 year Treasury. Right now that gap is only about 70 basis points.
Brokered CD rates tend to lag changes in Treasury rates somewhat.
Re: 10 year Broker CDs vs 10 year Treasury
Liquidity is the key concern - if interest rates go up a few percentages you might find it harder or more expensive to sell the brokerage CD vs the Treasury. I use VG brokerage CDs as part of my TIRA fixed income allocation. They are the last products I will tap when RMDs hit -- in fact I will make sure that I won't own any if they are in danger of being tapped for RMD.
So, you have to go into Brokerage CDs with eyes wide open. You are getting a better yield but there is a reason. Another issue is that you can't reinvest the Brokerage CD interest in that CD like you can with CDs bought directly from a bank. This can be fine in a rising interest rate environment since the normal "reinvestment risk" can become a gain. e.g. you can invest the interest in bond fund that might be taking a value hit due to the rising rates or buy a higher yielding CD.
Treasuries offer an excellent advantage when there is a flight to quality - e.g. all this fuss about Greece. While Brokerage CDs can benefit somewhat during these times Treasuries is a much better place to be. Foreign governments, large corporations, and wealthy individuals, etc can't really put large dollars to work in CDs and probably favor Treasury's liquidity much more than a bit better yield.
So, you have to go into Brokerage CDs with eyes wide open. You are getting a better yield but there is a reason. Another issue is that you can't reinvest the Brokerage CD interest in that CD like you can with CDs bought directly from a bank. This can be fine in a rising interest rate environment since the normal "reinvestment risk" can become a gain. e.g. you can invest the interest in bond fund that might be taking a value hit due to the rising rates or buy a higher yielding CD.
Treasuries offer an excellent advantage when there is a flight to quality - e.g. all this fuss about Greece. While Brokerage CDs can benefit somewhat during these times Treasuries is a much better place to be. Foreign governments, large corporations, and wealthy individuals, etc can't really put large dollars to work in CDs and probably favor Treasury's liquidity much more than a bit better yield.
Re: 10 year Broker CDs vs 10 year Treasury
At 59 years old, I don't see 10 years as all that long of horizon, but if I was 84 years old I would.john94549 wrote:Actually, it isn't. We're 68, and have been investing since our 20's (roughly 45 years).skepticalobserver wrote:
Ten years is a long time.
So age is a huge factor here for older people. 10 years of 3.2% is very stable at the least.
Even educators need education. And some can be hard headed to the point of needing time out.