Anyone should not buy I bonds?
Anyone should not buy I bonds?
Seems like most around here recommend buying I bonds every year. Assuming all tax advantaged space is filled, and putting money into taxable accounts, should everyone also invest in I bonds or are there some exceptions where it does not make sense?
Re: Anyone should not buy I bonds?
- Maybe if you need it within a year
- Already have too many bonds
- Already have too many bonds
Re: Anyone should not buy I bonds?
If you are buying for tax deferral realizing that the tax comes due at the thirty year point and the earnings also stop then. That might be one of your highest tax years. It is possible to pay off the tax as you go.
Re: Anyone should not buy I bonds?
If you want to use iBonds as part of bond allocations, you should be buying them whenever you can until you get the amount that you need. I am poor/young enough that after a few more years I will probably not need any more conservative money in ibonds and stop buying them!
70% Global Stocks / 30% Bonds
Re: Anyone should not buy I bonds?
Don't buy IBonds if you are 99 years old and don't expect to live another 30 years.
Victoria
Victoria
Inventor of the Bogleheads Secret Handshake |
Winner of the 2015 Boglehead Contest. |
Every joke has a bit of a joke. ... The rest is the truth. (Marat F)
- Mel Lindauer
- Moderator
- Posts: 35757
- Joined: Mon Feb 19, 2007 7:49 pm
- Location: Daytona Beach Shores, Florida
- Contact:
Re: Anyone should not buy I bonds?
As dbr pointed out, young investors should try to imagine where they'll be in terms of their career and tax bracket in 30 years, which is the final maturity (and tax due date). If it appears the'll be retired and in a low tax bracket, then buying makes sense. However, if they feel they'll likely be in their peak earning years and thus in a high tax bracket, then buying might not make sense, unless they feel they'll be able to take advantage of the tax-free qualifying educational benefit.
Best Regards - Mel |
|
Semper Fi
Re: Anyone should not buy I bonds?
I-bonds are currently paying 1.38%, whereas you can get a 5-year CD for 3.04%, which is more than twice that amount. Depending on how long you planned on holding it, that makes the decision a little harder.
Re: Anyone should not buy I bonds?
I don't buy I-bonds because it is impossible to deal with Treasury Direct. Not worth the efforts.
If any regular bank made it as difficult to put money in and take money out as Treas Direct does, no one would recommend them.
If any regular bank made it as difficult to put money in and take money out as Treas Direct does, no one would recommend them.
- Mel Lindauer
- Moderator
- Posts: 35757
- Joined: Mon Feb 19, 2007 7:49 pm
- Location: Daytona Beach Shores, Florida
- Contact:
Re: Anyone should not buy I bonds?
Do you have a link to that CD? I'm sure others might be interested.surfer1 wrote:I-bonds are currently paying 1.38%, whereas you can get a 5-year CD for 3.04%, which is more than twice that amount. Depending on how long you planned on holding it, that makes the decision a little harder.
Best Regards - Mel |
|
Semper Fi
Re: Anyone should not buy I bonds?
Hi Mel,Mel Lindauer wrote:Do you have a link to that CD? I'm sure others might be interested.surfer1 wrote:I-bonds are currently paying 1.38%, whereas you can get a 5-year CD for 3.04%, which is more than twice that amount. Depending on how long you planned on holding it, that makes the decision a little harder.
It's in this thread: http://www.bogleheads.org/forum/viewtop ... 0&t=127430 .
Victoria
Inventor of the Bogleheads Secret Handshake |
Winner of the 2015 Boglehead Contest. |
Every joke has a bit of a joke. ... The rest is the truth. (Marat F)
- Mel Lindauer
- Moderator
- Posts: 35757
- Joined: Mon Feb 19, 2007 7:49 pm
- Location: Daytona Beach Shores, Florida
- Contact:
Re: Anyone should not buy I bonds?
Thanks, Victoria. One of the problems of being a forum Moderator is that we don't have as much time as we'd like to read more of the posts, so we often miss informative posts like that.VictoriaF wrote:Hi Mel,Mel Lindauer wrote:Do you have a link to that CD? I'm sure others might be interested.surfer1 wrote:I-bonds are currently paying 1.38%, whereas you can get a 5-year CD for 3.04%, which is more than twice that amount. Depending on how long you planned on holding it, that makes the decision a little harder.
It's in this thread: http://www.bogleheads.org/forum/viewtop ... 0&t=127430 .
Victoria
Best Regards - Mel |
|
Semper Fi
- HawaiiBrewer
- Posts: 72
- Joined: Mon Sep 30, 2013 10:50 pm
- Location: Hawaii
Re: Anyone should not buy I bonds?
I bought some of the 5yr CD's but also will be buying the I Bonds for inflation protection, conservative preservation of our nest egg. As Igglesman said, Treasury direct is not too easy..they kicked out my wife's application and are requiring an "authorization" form be filled out and certified by a financial institution because they couldn't verify her identity My application on line went thru easily.....go figure.surfer1 wrote:I-bonds are currently paying 1.38%, whereas you can get a 5-year CD for 3.04%, which is more than twice that amount. Depending on how long you planned on holding it, that makes the decision a little harder.
If you don't know where you are going, any road will get you there
Re: Anyone should not buy I bonds?
How does that 5 year CD, with a 1 year penalty, look 2 years into a 5 year stretch of 5%+ inflation? Long CDs with severe penalties like Penfed have a very real exposure to inflation. That 5 year CD will probably match inflation over 5 years, possibly beat it, but also possibly fall way behind. The ibond will match inflation 100% of the time, and has less of a penalty after 12 months. After 5 years, when you will roll into a new CD with the same restrictive penalty, that iBond will mature to zero penalty and continue to update rates regularly. Imagine if a bank offered a penalty free CD that allowed you to change rates several times a year? That is an iBond after year 5. Yes it returns less and has purchase limits, but the benefits are real also.surfer1 wrote:I-bonds are currently paying 1.38%, whereas you can get a 5-year CD for 3.04%, which is more than twice that amount. Depending on how long you planned on holding it, that makes the decision a little harder.
70% Global Stocks / 30% Bonds
Re: Anyone should not buy I bonds?
Yes, me. I don't want to bother with the government web site for owning securities. For many, particularly older people who have accumulated a lifetime of assets, 10K a year is not enough to make an impact on anything. And for me, I figure that when I die, nobody would figure out I had them anyway even if I told them to check.
-
- Posts: 1584
- Joined: Mon Jul 22, 2013 7:52 pm
Re: Anyone should not buy I bonds?
Why would I buy an investment that is only paying 1.38% and is limited to a maximum purchase of $10,000 per year? 10k is too small to effect my investment allocation and way below my return on fixed investments. I can do better buying muni bonds.
Re: Anyone should not buy I bonds?
Speaking of the horrible treasury direct site... I recently decided to begin purchasing I bonds. How and when does the interest begin accumulating? I logged onto the site and still shows my balance of 10,000 after a fee months of owning. I understand interest starts at day 1, but does it take 12months to show?
- Mel Lindauer
- Moderator
- Posts: 35757
- Joined: Mon Feb 19, 2007 7:49 pm
- Location: Daytona Beach Shores, Florida
- Contact:
Re: Anyone should not buy I bonds?
You're seeing the redemption value. TD withholds the last three months' interest as the penalty for redemption prior to holding them for five years. You should see the first month's interest after four months. Then, at the five-year mark, there is no penalty, so TD no longer withholds the past three months' interest.poker27 wrote:Speaking of the horrible treasury direct site... I recently decided to begin purchasing I bonds. How and when does the interest begin accumulating? I logged onto the site and still shows my balance of 10,000 after a fee months of owning. I understand interest starts at day 1, but does it take 12months to show?
Best Regards - Mel |
|
Semper Fi
Re: Anyone should not buy I bonds?
I believe it lags by 3 months until you have owned it 5 years.poker27 wrote:Speaking of the horrible treasury direct site... I recently decided to begin purchasing I bonds. How and when does the interest begin accumulating? I logged onto the site and still shows my balance of 10,000 after a fee months of owning. I understand interest starts at day 1, but does it take 12months to show?
Re: Anyone should not buy I bonds?
No, interest is calculated & distributed (into your I-Bond balance) monthly, right around the 1st of each month.poker27 wrote:Speaking of the horrible treasury direct site... I recently decided to begin purchasing I bonds. How and when does the interest begin accumulating? I logged onto the site and still shows my balance of 10,000 after a fee months of owning. I understand interest starts at day 1, but does it take 12months to show?
.....although I have also heard this is the case. I honestly haven't noticed (or cared to calculate it) with any of my I-Bonds...BL wrote:I believe it lags by 3 months until you have owned it 5 years.
Re: Anyone should not buy I bonds?
Hi Mel,Mel Lindauer wrote:Thanks, Victoria. One of the problems of being a forum Moderator is that we don't have as much time as we'd like to read more of the posts, so we often miss informative posts like that.VictoriaF wrote:Hi Mel,Mel Lindauer wrote:Do you have a link to that CD? I'm sure others might be interested.surfer1 wrote:I-bonds are currently paying 1.38%, whereas you can get a 5-year CD for 3.04%, which is more than twice that amount. Depending on how long you planned on holding it, that makes the decision a little harder.
It's in this thread: http://www.bogleheads.org/forum/viewtop ... 0&t=127430 .
Victoria
But is not it more fun to read off-topic posts (before surgically removing them)? {smile}
Victoria
Inventor of the Bogleheads Secret Handshake |
Winner of the 2015 Boglehead Contest. |
Every joke has a bit of a joke. ... The rest is the truth. (Marat F)
Re: Anyone should not buy I bonds?
If I Bonds are appropriate for your heirs, you can teach them how to accumulate their own I Bonds, and then getting yours would not be a problem.Calm Man wrote:Yes, me. I don't want to bother with the government web site for owning securities. For many, particularly older people who have accumulated a lifetime of assets, 10K a year is not enough to make an impact on anything. And for me, I figure that when I die, nobody would figure out I had them anyway even if I told them to check.
I Bonds are a good option for those in a high tax bracket who have exhausted all tax-deferred venues and still have plenty of taxable cash. Dealing with the government can be very painful, but most of the pain spikes in the beginning and then subsides. And some diversification between the industry (Vanguard) and government (the Treasury) may not be a bad idea.
Victoria
Inventor of the Bogleheads Secret Handshake |
Winner of the 2015 Boglehead Contest. |
Every joke has a bit of a joke. ... The rest is the truth. (Marat F)
- nisiprius
- Advisory Board
- Posts: 52105
- Joined: Thu Jul 26, 2007 9:33 am
- Location: The terrestrial, globular, planetary hunk of matter, flattened at the poles, is my abode.--O. Henry
Re: Anyone should not buy I bonds?
You are comparing apples and oranges. Municipal bonds have interest rate risk, I bonds do not. I bond redemption values are unaffected by interest rates.manwithnoname wrote:Why would I buy an investment that is only paying 1.38% and is limited to a maximum purchase of $10,000 per year? 10k is too small to effect my investment allocation and way below my return on fixed investments. I can do better buying muni bonds.
With ordinary marketable bonds, if interest rates rise you might wish you could exchange your old low-interest bonds for new ones with higher rates, but bond math guarantees that your old bonds will have dropped in value by exactly the right amount to make the exchange useless. WIth I bonds, if interest rates rise there is no loss in redemption value and can indeed replace the old bonds with new ones.
I bonds are the "non-remorse" bond investment.
Municipal bonds have higher risk and higher returns than I bonds? Yes, and stocks have higher risk and higher return than municipal bonds. So what?
Annual income twenty pounds, annual expenditure nineteen nineteen and six, result happiness; Annual income twenty pounds, annual expenditure twenty pounds ought and six, result misery.
Re: Anyone should not buy I bonds?
One more reason to not invest in I-Bonds....
I-Bonds do not pass the "Beer Truck Test". If I get hit by a beer truck today, the i-bonds will be the most difficult of all my investments to redeem (and especially for a small portion of our nest egg).
The Beer Truck Test states to keep is as simple as possible...make it easy for the heirs.
I-Bonds do not pass the "Beer Truck Test". If I get hit by a beer truck today, the i-bonds will be the most difficult of all my investments to redeem (and especially for a small portion of our nest egg).
The Beer Truck Test states to keep is as simple as possible...make it easy for the heirs.
Re: Anyone should not buy I bonds?
There are some specific situations where they can make sense like college savings, emergency fund, or for a specific goal, but for holding them long term in general I think they are currently a pretty poor choice at the current fixed rate they are paying. There are also situations where you only intend to keep them for a few years where they can make sense too since you are sometimes able to use them to get a higher interest rate than CD's or a money market fund.am wrote:Seems like most around here recommend buying I bonds every year. Assuming all tax advantaged space is filled, and putting money into taxable accounts, should everyone also invest in I bonds or are there some exceptions where it does not make sense?
They are taxed on the inflation adjustment and still have a fixed yield of next to nothing so after taxes they are pretty much guaranteed to lose purchasing power if you hold them for a long time.
To make matters worse they don't go to your estate at a stepped up cost basis either.
Re: Anyone should not buy I bonds?
No I bonds for me.
I think the TSP G fund is a superior fixed income product with inflation protection.
I need yet another "miscellaneous" financial account like I need a hole in the head.
I think the TSP G fund is a superior fixed income product with inflation protection.
I need yet another "miscellaneous" financial account like I need a hole in the head.
70/30 AA for life, Global market cap equity. Rebalance if fixed income <25% or >35%. Weighted ER< .10%. 5% of annual portfolio balance SWR, Proportional (to AA) withdrawals.
-
- Posts: 8372
- Joined: Tue Aug 06, 2013 12:43 pm
Re: Anyone should not buy I bonds?
My reasons are similar to others: small potatoes (bond alloc >400k) plus extra complexity with another account and heard stories of struggles with TD.
- nisiprius
- Advisory Board
- Posts: 52105
- Joined: Thu Jul 26, 2007 9:33 am
- Location: The terrestrial, globular, planetary hunk of matter, flattened at the poles, is my abode.--O. Henry
Re: Anyone should not buy I bonds?
I like the phrase "beer truck test."Igglesman wrote:One more reason to not invest in I-Bonds....
I-Bonds do not pass the "Beer Truck Test". If I get hit by a beer truck today, the i-bonds will be the most difficult of all my investments to redeem (and especially for a small portion of our nest egg).
The Beer Truck Test states to keep is as simple as possible...make it easy for the heirs.
Yeah, I've been brooding about that, too. Originally one of my reasons for investing in PAPER I bonds, with my wife as co-owner, was that it seemed to me that PAPER I bonds passed that test with ease.
1 High likelihood of discovery (physically in the safe deposit box);
2. Liquidationability (not a word but don't know the right word) diversification.The factors affecting whether heirs could liquidate them are DIFFERENT from other modalities).
3. Ease of liquidation (walk 25 feet from safe deposit box to teller's counter and hand them across the counter).
None of those things is true any more.
Annual income twenty pounds, annual expenditure nineteen nineteen and six, result happiness; Annual income twenty pounds, annual expenditure twenty pounds ought and six, result misery.
Re: Anyone should not buy I bonds?
I keep my TSP funds in the G Fund. But eventually (pretty soon) I will have to take the money out, place them in an IRA, and start Roth conversions. My I-Bonds will be with me long after the G Fund will be gone.MnD wrote:No I bonds for me.
I think the TSP G fund is a superior fixed income product with inflation protection.
I need yet another "miscellaneous" financial account like I need a hole in the head.
Victoria
Inventor of the Bogleheads Secret Handshake |
Winner of the 2015 Boglehead Contest. |
Every joke has a bit of a joke. ... The rest is the truth. (Marat F)
Re: Anyone should not buy I bonds?
Two hours ago, a large construction truck has hit a side of a bus. It happened in front of my eyes, I was immediately behind the bus. The first thing I thought about was my I Bond holdings. NOT.Igglesman wrote:One more reason to not invest in I-Bonds....
I-Bonds do not pass the "Beer Truck Test". If I get hit by a beer truck today, the i-bonds will be the most difficult of all my investments to redeem (and especially for a small portion of our nest egg).
The Beer Truck Test states to keep is as simple as possible...make it easy for the heirs.
Victoria
Inventor of the Bogleheads Secret Handshake |
Winner of the 2015 Boglehead Contest. |
Every joke has a bit of a joke. ... The rest is the truth. (Marat F)
-
- Posts: 1584
- Joined: Mon Jul 22, 2013 7:52 pm
Re: Anyone should not buy I bonds?
nisiprius wrote:You are comparing apples and oranges. Municipal bonds have interest rate risk, I bonds do not. I bond redemption values are unaffected by interest rates.manwithnoname wrote:Why would I buy an investment that is only paying 1.38% and is limited to a maximum purchase of $10,000 per year? 10k is too small to effect my investment allocation and way below my return on fixed investments. I can do better buying muni bonds.
With ordinary marketable bonds, if interest rates rise you might wish you could exchange your old low-interest bonds for new ones with higher rates, but bond math guarantees that your old bonds will have dropped in value by exactly the right amount to make the exchange useless. WIth I bonds, if interest rates rise there is no loss in redemption value and can indeed replace the old bonds with new ones.
I bonds are the "non-remorse" bond investment.
Municipal bonds have higher risk and higher returns than I bonds? Yes, and stocks have higher risk and higher return than municipal bonds. So what?
I am not comparing apples to oranges. I am comparing two investments- one of which generates an investment return of 1.38% which is subject to federal taxation with another investment that pays 5% tax free which I use to pay current living expenses. I use my stocks to generate qualified dividends to keep pace with inflation so I don't have to sell any investments. I don't need to put my money in an I bond and hope that inflation will dramatically increase over the next 30 years to justify the low interest rate in effect now. I don't need to put my money in a cooler.
Anyway 10k a year is too small an amount to be managed effectively and everything I read about TD says its not an investor friendly fund.
So if you like I bonds, knock yourself out.