Phineas J. Whoopee wrote:
Are you denying that, keeping all other things equal so we can isolate the difference, the investor will have just as many dollars to spend from a Traditional IRA as from a Roth IRA?
Brantley wrote: You're arguing if tax rates are equal, you end up with the same net money roth vs tIRA (also true).
Phineas J. Whoopee wrote:If you didn't get the earlier explanations in this thread alone why should you expect to get yet another one? If you'd like to disagree with them, including mine, fine but say so and why, please.
Misleading in which way? You just gave further details to prove my point.Phineas J. Whoopee wrote:
But it's a little misleading, although I know you didn't intend it that way, to say "With a traditional IRA, gains are taxed upon withdrawal."
jmndu99 wrote:If your girlfriend's portfolio was important to her, she would be the one coming with the questions, not you.
Sweet vocab bro.BackInTheBlack wrote:tangential
Not really. Didn't inquire about medians.Akiva wrote:Though I should note that Rick Ferri did answer your question in terms of medians...)
larryswedroe wrote:Brantely, all that data was from the study cited